[Day/Night Game] Trouble on the Citadel - round "LE Part 2: Why Cerberus Is Right For You"

Well, honestly my suspicion is on Space right now as, when I looked at the list... I didn't see any roles, other than the VS, that matched his hint of being on the SR1 but not on the SR2 until ME3. I will look again to be sure though.

That said, my vote doesn't really matter unless someone else can be convinced of not voting for you. 



And I know the feeling lol


EDIT: I suppose Space could be Liara if Moonae wasn't actually Liara. But somehow I kind of doubt that. 

Okay so Reed has decided to sit on the fence whilst everyone else claims they have nothing to go on but are going to condemn that person anyway - nothing personal, sorry. 

It is like the excitement of the last round was just too much for everyone.

Current voting:
Fylimar 1
Pelassarias 3
Space Cowboy 1

The vote will close in just under 12 hours at 10.00 am GMT. You have been warned.

Going back to the beginning:

Night 1:

- Wrex was turned via indoctrination. I know this as Dragon misunderstood the new rule and thought that she wouldn't turn up as "evil" if investigated by Liara on Night 1 since she started off good.

Day 1:

- Adonniel votes for Fylimar based on previous game's popularity as villain (Also incriminates Pela). Space thinks this is a good idea but doesn't vote.

- Pela defends herself saying it wouldn't make sense to pick her or fylimar again because they're too popular and bring suspicion.

- Dragon says she was going to argue for fylimar not being a spy because it's too obvious, but immediately changes to saying she could be a spy because no one would expect it. (Keep in mind, she's a indoctrinated agent at this point. Suspicion for fylimar raised)

- Moonae votes for Dragon (I assume because she was potentially Liara and investigated Dragon on Night 1)

- Fylimar claims she can't hint at her role because the spies would want to take her out. And she doesn't know who to vote for and mentions using dice to decide. (After the fact we know that Moonae was probably Liara and Adonniel was Jack, so... who could Fylimar be hinting at? A large list I'm sure)

- Space votes for Pela saying he agrees that it's either Pela or Fylimar.

- Romice votes Adonniel, claims completely random as the reasoning. (we know Adonniel was Jack, possible suspicion on Romice?)

- Dragon votes for Space due to "random number generator." (We know Dragon was evil at this point, potentially means Space is not evil depending on if Dragon knows who the heroes are or not at this point?)

- Adonniel switches her vote from Fylimar to Dragon because "she wants to stir the pot" (And this is why I got put in danger, really Adonniel? )

- Reed follows suit and switches his vote from Space to Adonniel. (we know Adonniel is Jack now and that she went after me and died, possibly meaning I'm a hero, which I am.)

- Fylimar claims she doesn't want to be responsible for losing a big hero role. Votes for Romice using dice.

- Adonniel hints at being Jack, while Space hints at potentially being Liara. (If Moonae was Liara, this could be suspicious for Space)

- Pela doesn't want to vote for Dragon or Adonniel saying they both could be innocent. Says she doubts Romice is a spy with no reason given and then votes for Reed. (Now, going by what we know... Dragon was Evil/turned, Adonniel was Jack and a hero, and Reed is a hero. IF Pela was the spy she wouldn't want to vote her partner off, but she also could potentially not want to break the tie and then be suspicious as one of the people who voted off a hero. Suspicion level for Pela raised.)

- Space says he's sure Adonniel is innocent. (why? how? He doesn't say.)

- Fylimar insists she doesn't know who is good or evil when asked for help from Adonniel. (why? no suspicions at all? Seems suspicious!)

- Romice switches her vote from Adonniel to Moonae (1 we know was a hero and 1 who potentially was a hero. Quite suspicious)

- Adonniel changes her vote to Reed from Dragon. (tsk tsk)

- Space changes his vote from Pela to Moonae while saying it's because he hasn't heard much from Moonae. (Moonae was potentially a hero)

- Dragon has mercy (not fully indoctrinated?? ) and switches her vote from Space to Moonae to help Reed. (Since Dragon was evil, this means Moonae was good, right?)

- Pela doesn't want to change her vote away from Reed. (another example of not wanting to vote for Dragon or a hero to decide who is gone next)

- Moonae says she's highly suspicious of Dragon (again hinting she was a hero)

- Space switches his vote to Dragon from Moonae.

- Fylimar changes her vote from Romice to Dragon. (Possibly removes the suspicion from her)

- Pela makes a couple posts that I can't quite understand. One has a typo and thus eludes me as to what she meant and the other says not to vote for dragon. (possibly suspicious)

- Dragon gets voted out and takes down Moonae. (We know Dragon was evil... again, points at Moonae being a true hero)

Night 2:

- Adonniel is eliminated when investigating Reed while also being chased by the spy. Meaning no one tried to protect her.

Day 2:

- Fylimar claims she isn't a spy after Adonniel accuses her and Pela again.

- Space drops a hint that could possibly mean the VS or Liara again. (Later confirmed he didn't mean VS. So, possibly Liara again. We know Moonae could have also been Liara. I'm thinking this is suspicious and he's possibly EC Liara now after Moonae was eliminated.)

- Fylimar votes for Space because she thought he meant he was the VS and the VS isn't necessarily good.

- Space switches his vote to Pela and cites "shot in the dark" as his reason.

- Romice votes for Pela and cites not wanting to hold the game up as her reason.

- Pela votes for Space saying that it's possible he voted for Dragon quickly as not to be suspicious and to get rid of Moonae at the same time. (Suspicion raised for Space here, especially if him potentially being EC Liara is a correct assumption.)

- Pela throws shade at Romice. (I attribute this to just trying to save her ass and convince anyone to vote for anyone else. Don't blame her.)

- Adonniel accuses Pela again (lol)

- Fylimar switches from Space to Pela.

- Reed votes for Fylimar.


So, sorry for the long post, but I'm trying to sniff out who the guilty party/parties here are. If Pela was evil, she wouldn't vote for Space or throw shade at Romice if either of them was evil (I don't think) just to save herself. So, I don't really think Pela is guilty.

I'm thinking that Space is possibly the EC Liara as he has claimed a great hero role twice that could potentially be seen as Liara. He also switched his vote rather quickly to Dragon which could be trying to avoid suspicion and kill off Moonae to activate his EC ability.

That's just after initially going through all of this. Now I need to reread it all and see if anyone else is more suspicious than Space. Hopefully this helps out the true heroes out there. I don't want Pela going down if she isn't a Spy!

If that were true, I would be Liara now, and probably good. Besides, if anything Moonae was the impostor

That was some good analysis there, Reed. I'm going to switch from Pela to Fylimar, help her out. Sorry Fyl

It would have been more interesting if I hadn't been voted off 

I do look forward to finding out the truth about this EC/Liara business. 

This, in theory. They are sort of a neutral, out-for-themselves role, but can choose to help out either side. This role has never succeeded so far, though. It's cursed, I guess It'll be cool if the clone this time actually got to claim a role.

Yeah that does suck. sorry. You got killed first night as the clone last game too I remember.

and so do I

Lol. You sound like me 

Maybe that's why I tried defending your indoctrinated self! Had that link lol



He's the EC! Don't let him fool you!

I still don't think the EC would be on the good side. Does not compute with my brain even though I know that's the rules. lol

I meant the role itself. Not Space in particular should he be the EC.

You're probably referring to the posts where I expressed that I would much rather have the night killing roles (Jack and Garrus) take out Dragon so we could possibly save Moonae. If we have a Good Protective role, like a Good Kasumi, Moonae could have been saved during the night if Dragon didn't get voted off.

As for my post with Romice, I was just trying to figure out romice's possible role (which points to Kasumi) and why she could have possibly not saved adonniel. Yeah, I did feel like I needed to save my skin a bit , but I was mainly trying to figure out Romice's hint.

All in all, I appreciate that I'm not naturally suspicious to every player, but the majority does over rule regardless. I doubt romice will show up again, and if she does, she probably won't change along with flyimar. Space seems dead set on his vote as well. It would have been nice to have at least go through a tiebreaker, but oh well.

Also dragon, I've definitely noticed you've been unlucky so far as well. Hopefully things will change a bit during the first round of the next game.