inherit
∯ Oh Loredy...
455
0
Nov 29, 2024 11:46:30 GMT
31,169
gervaise21
13,094
August 2016
gervaise21
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
|
Post by gervaise21 on Mar 2, 2023 9:05:25 GMT
In that case, do you see the progress for elven rights in Orlais being completely undone? I know you're not asking me, but yes. If you'll remember, the elven Wardens also made apparent progress for elven rights in DAO, only for those to be completely undone, too. Ferelden is also a much more of a meritocracy than Orlais, which is why it is even more disheartening that even after an elven Hero saves Ferelden from the Blight, trying to maintain any reforms is well nigh impossible. As I said above, a lot depends on who ends up as Divine, as choosing Briala does considerably increase Leliana's chances. Previous reforms only had the backing of individual rulers whereas the elevation of the elves under Divine Leliana has not only the official backing of the Divine but also the Herald of Andraste. The latter reason is why one of my Lavellan's was happy to play along with accepting the title because it gave a great deal more weight to his campaign to improve life for the elves generally but specifically the acceptance of the Dalish. Leliana's insistence on restoring the Canticle of Shartan to the Chant should also help because that is recited on a daily basis throughout Thedas and so even people who can't read would learn of the contribution he made to her cause. It is particularly noticeable that Andraste herself elevates Shartan to the status of not merely a disciple but her equal in the eyes of the Maker, then entrusts him with maintaining the freedom of their united people against tyranny. Really observant people might also then make the connection between this declaration as she gives him her sword and the Liberator who appears in the Canticle of Apotheosis and attempts to save the life of Andraste, with a hundred of his people, eventually being struck down and killed. It might at least go some way to redressing the balance with the anti-elf propaganda that has been maintained by the Chantry down the years.
|
|
inherit
749
0
3,854
Iddy
3,860
August 2016
iddy
|
Post by Iddy on Mar 12, 2023 1:11:36 GMT
So... how exactly does awakening work for ancient elves?
Solas tells us that he "woke up" one year before the events of Inquisition, but did he simply will it? Does it have a timer that automatically ends uthenera when time's up?
|
|
inherit
471
0
5,383
ladyiolanthe
3,967
August 2016
ladyiolanthe
Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquistion, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
591
695
|
Post by ladyiolanthe on Mar 12, 2023 2:22:44 GMT
So... how exactly does awakening work for ancient elves? Solas tells us that he "woke up" one year before the events of Inquisition, but did he simply will it? Does it have a timer that automatically ends uthenera when time's up? In Solas' case specifically, he was watching the world through the Fade and probably decided the time was right for his plans. So I expect he did, in fact, will himself to wake up. In The Masked Empire, Felassan explains to Briala that some elves achieved perfection in uthenera and could sustain themselves on Fade energy. Solas seems to have accomplished this, as he notoriously doesn't really eat much at all, according to the Skyhold servants. It is probable that those ancient elves who accomplished this level of mastery could just will themselves awake. In the case of the ancient elves at Mythal's Temple, it seems likely that there was some sort of magical alarm system since Abelas said they wake up when the temple is threatened, then go back to sleep when the threat has been neutralized. In the case of other ancient elves, who knows? A lot of them just die in their sleep for lack of food. From another part of The Masked Empire, we know that those who couldn't sustain themselves on Fade energy had to be fed a mixture of honey, water, and herbs to keep them from dying. Those ones probably also need someone (or some magic alarm, like the temple elves) to wake them up. (And it's likely that most of them have died in their sleep since the Veil was put up by Solas, as who would have been left to feed them?)
|
|
xerrai
N3
Posts: 847 Likes: 1,177
inherit
1451
0
1,177
xerrai
847
September 2016
xerrai
|
Post by xerrai on Mar 12, 2023 4:42:09 GMT
So... how exactly does awakening work for ancient elves? Solas tells us that he "woke up" one year before the events of Inquisition, but did he simply will it? Does it have a timer that automatically ends uthenera when time's up? In Solas' case specifically, he was watching the world through the Fade and probably decided the time was right for his plans. So I expect he did, in fact, will himself to wake up. In The Masked Empire, Felassan explains to Briala that some elves achieved perfection in uthenera and could sustain themselves on Fade energy. Solas seems to have accomplished this, as he notoriously doesn't really eat much at all, according to the Skyhold servants. It is probable that those ancient elves who accomplished this level of mastery could just will themselves awake. [...] If that's true, then one would have to ask the question on why he didn't wake himself up sooner. Given his (presumed) ultimate goal, one would think he would have initiated to break down the fade sooner rather than wait as long as he did. That, or wait for an as-of-yet unknown factor to present itself. And if he was waiting for an unknown factor, what was it? One explanation is that he was waiting for his strength to return, since he noted that he was still weak by the time he woke up. But that in turn would beg the question on why he woke himself up ahead of schedule regardless of his relative weakness instead of waiting to return to full strength. On the other hand, he may not have willed himself awake at all and simply woke up whenever he was reasonably able. Or perhaps he was awakened by some other factor like a spell weakening? I'm inclined to think he just woke up whenever he was able to after his previous exploits, rather than simply willing himself awake (and regardless of his strength level)--even if a willing awakening would apply for others who enter uthenera under normal circumstances.
|
|
inherit
471
0
5,383
ladyiolanthe
3,967
August 2016
ladyiolanthe
Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquistion, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
591
695
|
Post by ladyiolanthe on Mar 12, 2023 6:45:57 GMT
In Solas' case specifically, he was watching the world through the Fade and probably decided the time was right for his plans. So I expect he did, in fact, will himself to wake up. In The Masked Empire, Felassan explains to Briala that some elves achieved perfection in uthenera and could sustain themselves on Fade energy. Solas seems to have accomplished this, as he notoriously doesn't really eat much at all, according to the Skyhold servants. It is probable that those ancient elves who accomplished this level of mastery could just will themselves awake. [...] If that's true, then one would have to ask the question on why he didn't wake himself up sooner. Given his (presumed) ultimate goal, one would think he would have initiated to break down the fade sooner rather than wait as long as he did. That, or wait for an as-of-yet unknown factor to present itself. And if he was waiting for an unknown factor, what was it? One explanation is that he was waiting for his strength to return, since he noted that he was still weak by the time he woke up. But that in turn would beg the question on why he woke himself up ahead of schedule regardless of his relative weakness instead of waiting to return to full strength. On the other hand, he may not have willed himself awake at all and simply woke up whenever he was reasonably able. Or perhaps he was awakened by some other factor like a spell weakening?I'm inclined to think he just woke up whenever he was able to after his previous exploits, rather than simply willing himself awake (and regardless of his strength level)--even if a willing awakening would apply for others who enter uthenera under normal circumstances. I think the red lyrium being purposefully propagated and spread around southern Thedas by the Venatori may have had something to do with his waking up ahead of schedule. It's Blighted lyrium, he is terrified of the Blight, and likely knows more about than he's letting on, based on some of the things we've learned about ancient elves, dwarves, and titans interacting thousands of years ago.
|
|
inherit
1033
0
Nov 29, 2024 11:07:26 GMT
37,056
colfoley
19,170
Aug 17, 2016 10:19:37 GMT
August 2016
colfoley
|
Post by colfoley on Mar 12, 2023 8:19:16 GMT
If that's true, then one would have to ask the question on why he didn't wake himself up sooner. Given his (presumed) ultimate goal, one would think he would have initiated to break down the fade sooner rather than wait as long as he did. That, or wait for an as-of-yet unknown factor to present itself. And if he was waiting for an unknown factor, what was it? One explanation is that he was waiting for his strength to return, since he noted that he was still weak by the time he woke up. But that in turn would beg the question on why he woke himself up ahead of schedule regardless of his relative weakness instead of waiting to return to full strength. On the other hand, he may not have willed himself awake at all and simply woke up whenever he was reasonably able. Or perhaps he was awakened by some other factor like a spell weakening?I'm inclined to think he just woke up whenever he was able to after his previous exploits, rather than simply willing himself awake (and regardless of his strength level)--even if a willing awakening would apply for others who enter uthenera under normal circumstances. I think the red lyrium being purposefully propagated and spread around southern Thedas by the Venatori may have had something to do with his waking up ahead of schedule. It's Blighted lyrium, he is terrified of the Blight, and likely knows more about than he's letting on, based on some of the things we've learned about ancient elves, dwarves, and titans interacting thousands of years ago. This actually makes more sense the more I think about it as well and it would follow a natural propagation of events. Afterall the mural he was working on also had Meredith and Corypheus so this basically suggests that we have gone from the fifth blight, to the events of Dragon Age 2/ the discovery of Red Lyrium, to Solas awakening, to Corypheus, back to Solas and the revelation of the Dreadwolf as natual progression. One even directly led into the next event. Also depending on where one sits on the 'Shartan is Solas' theory then this would add more evidence to the idea as well considering Shartan/ Andraste came around direcly after the First Blight.
|
|
inherit
∯ Oh Loredy...
455
0
Nov 29, 2024 11:46:30 GMT
31,169
gervaise21
13,094
August 2016
gervaise21
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
|
Post by gervaise21 on Mar 12, 2023 8:50:26 GMT
And if he was waiting for an unknown factor, what was it? I've always assumed he was waiting for his orb to recharge. The amount of magical energy required to create the Veil must have been enormous and this would have drained both him and the orb. I think the red lyrium being purposefully propagated and spread around southern Thedas by the Venatori may have had something to do with his waking up ahead of schedule. This actually makes more sense the more I think about it as well and it would follow a natural propagation of events. The only problem with this theory is that Felassan was active from at least the time of Celene's ascension to the throne of Orlais, which took place in 9:20, some 19/20 years before Solas awoke, and he may even have been around before that. What was his purpose? Solas says it was to activate the eluvian network, which may have been true, although it is hard to understand why he concerned himself with Briala at all if that was the case. Unless Solas always needed a large number of compliant elves for his ritual. So, Solas must have been near to the planned time since his orb had been recharged fully by then and if he awoke at all early it may have been due to the fact that Felassan gave control of the eluvians to Briala, not to mention both Morrigan and the Qunari discovering their own independent way in, although it is possible the latter only did this after the Breach. No one knew about red lyrium until Hawke & Co stumbled across it. Corypheus and the Venatori only discovered its location from Bianca and I don't think Varric got her involved with it until after he saw the bad effect it had on his brother (although I could be wrong about that), so much closer to Solas' waking time. In which case, it may have hurried him awake a bit sooner than intended but it seems like he was planning his return long before that. Also, he still seemed to be in Uthenera during the events of Masked Empire, even though red lyrium was in circulation by then and the idol had been found, so control of the eluvian network would seem to be the major influence on his revival. There is, of course, the possibility that it was shut down originally with him inside the network (for security reasons may be), so no point in waking up until it was reactivated as he wouldn't have been able to get out.
|
|
inherit
749
0
3,854
Iddy
3,860
August 2016
iddy
|
Post by Iddy on Mar 14, 2023 20:10:18 GMT
If the Inquisitor has romanced the Iron Bull and was betrayed by him, we are told by Trespasser's epilogue that s/he is then ridiculed by tavern songs and Orlesian plays for years.
S/He is also blamed for the Qunari threat, as s/he was too "blinded by lust" to see it approaching.
That got me thinking... if the Dread Wolf's threat was common knowledge, as well as Lavellan's relationship with him, and the Inquisition remained publicly active, she could have been subjected to the same level of scorn.
|
|
inherit
∯ Oh Loredy...
455
0
Nov 29, 2024 11:46:30 GMT
31,169
gervaise21
13,094
August 2016
gervaise21
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
|
Post by gervaise21 on Mar 15, 2023 9:01:33 GMT
That got me thinking... if the Dread Wolf's threat was common knowledge, as well as Lavellan's relationship with him, and the Inquisition remained publicly active, she could have been subjected to the same level of scorn. I actually think his threat may not be common knowledge or his threat was played down/not believed generally. I am not sure how well known their relationship was either. The Iron Bull already had a reputation among the members of the Inquisition (we hear some ladies discussing him at Haven) and, let's face it, the advisors blundered in on them having sex, so I'm pretty sure that would get out before long, plus people would see them coming and going from each other's quarters in Skyhold. By contrast, I think Solas would have been more discrete and whilst our Inner Circle was in the know, it would have been less obvious to outsiders what was going on. After all, at least our first romantic encounter was in the Fade, so it is possible to imagine that everything was conducted there. Also, the Iron Bull literally attacked the Inquisitor, whereas Solas did save them, so it would be possible to spin the story in order for the Inquisitor not to come out so badly. Also, Lavellan would want the threat to be kept on a need to know basis because of the possible backlash against elves generally, and the epilogue says not everyone believed them anyway.
|
|
Entropy
N2
Games: Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, KOTOR, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire, Mass Effect Andromeda
Posts: 130 Likes: 367
inherit
366
0
367
Entropy
130
August 2016
abnocte
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, KOTOR, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire, Mass Effect Andromeda
|
Post by Entropy on Mar 15, 2023 21:44:41 GMT
It's been ages since last time I played, but it is common knowledge that the Dreadwolf and Solas are the same? May be it is known that the Inquisitor had a relationship with an apostate elven mage, that he was Fen'Harel's agent even, but that he was Fen'Harel himself?
And if it is known, once the Veil is destroyed, could it be that the remaining Evanuris target the Inquisitor as revenge? (assuming they somewhat think Solas still loves her)
|
|
xerrai
N3
Posts: 847 Likes: 1,177
inherit
1451
0
1,177
xerrai
847
September 2016
xerrai
|
Post by xerrai on Mar 15, 2023 23:33:08 GMT
It's been ages since last time I played, but it is common knowledge that the Dreadwolf and Solas are the same? May be it is known that the Inquisitor had a relationship with an apostate elven mage, that he was Fen'Harel's agent even, but that he was Fen'Harel himself? And if it is known, once the Veil is destroyed, could it be that the remaining Evanuris target the Inquisitor as revenge? (assuming they somewhat think Solas still loves her) I am also curious about this. We know people are aware that the Inquisition had an apostate mage named Solas (if Maryden's song is any indication in Trespasser) and we can reasonably assume that most national powers are aware of a "Fen'Harel Cult" existing ( and maybe that the same Solas from the Inquisition is in charge of it?). But i'm not too sure if they really believe he was the same elvhen 'god' of legend as opposed to a particularly skilled elf just taking on the name. But if any groups are going to make that connection first, it would be the Qunari and the Mortallitasi on account of having run-ins with them, but I'm not too sure if they actually acknowledge him as an ancient elf from the time of Arlathan as opposed to, for example, an elvhen experiment from the time of Old Tevinter or an odd necromancer experiment. Or maybe even something closer to DAO's Zathrian who was widely acknowledged by the Dalish (although I am unsure how many people believe in his existence outside of the clans). Did either of those groups ever explicitly say they believed Solas to be the same Fen'harel of legend?
|
|
inherit
749
0
3,854
Iddy
3,860
August 2016
iddy
|
Post by Iddy on Mar 16, 2023 0:24:34 GMT
It's been ages since last time I played, but it is common knowledge that the Dreadwolf and Solas are the same? May be it is known that the Inquisitor had a relationship with an apostate elven mage, that he was Fen'Harel's agent even, but that he was Fen'Harel himself? And if it is known, once the Veil is destroyed, could it be that the remaining Evanuris target the Inquisitor as revenge? (assuming they somewhat think Solas still loves her) I am also curious about this. We know people are aware that the Inquisition had an apostate mage named Solas (if Maryden's song is any indication in Trespasser) and we can reasonably assume that most national powers are aware of a "Fen'Harel Cult" existing ( and maybe that the same Solas from the Inquisition is in charge of it?). But i'm not too sure if they really believe he was the same elvhen 'god' of legend as opposed to a particularly skilled elf just taking on the name. But if any groups are going to make that connection first, it would be the Qunari and the Mortallitasi on account of having run-ins with them, but I'm not too sure if they actually acknowledge him as an ancient elf from the time of Arlathan as opposed to, for example, an elvhen experiment from the time of Old Tevinter or an odd necromancer experiment. Or maybe even something closer to DAO's Zathrian who was widely acknowledged by the Dalish (although I am unsure how many people believe in his existence outside of the clans). Did either of those groups ever explicitly say they believed Solas to be the same Fen'harel of legend? I believe that what really matters is whether they consider him to be a world ending threat.
|
|
inherit
∯ Oh Loredy...
455
0
Nov 29, 2024 11:46:30 GMT
31,169
gervaise21
13,094
August 2016
gervaise21
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
|
Post by gervaise21 on Mar 16, 2023 8:40:15 GMT
Did either of those groups ever explicitly say they believed Solas to be the same Fen'harel of legend? If the Qunari are going on what the Viddasala discovered, then they believe he is a agent of Fen'Harel/the cult. However, it is possible they acquired a more up to date perspective from, say, Varric, with whom Gatt was in contact. Since the Qunari don't believe in gods and they know he is a mage, they may probably assuming he is a possessed mage, regardless of how old he is. In fact, if they do believe he comes from ancient times, they probably think even more that he is really a demon. However, Rasaan was looking for information on Solas' true name, claiming that both Fen'Harel and Solas were not "true", which points towards them both knowing more about his origins and accepting he is not your regular sort of mage threat . She knew the story about Fen'Harel being given by his enemies, which is odd because I don't think you could glean that from the ruins we passed through and since she also says "Dread Wolf" was not the correct translation, it seems she was going off information that their agents probably acquired from scholars in Orlais. I actually found that whole nonsense about it not meaning "Dread" wolf a bit ridiculous considering Flemeth addresses him as such and his enemies wanted to emphasise that he was a threat to be feared, not that he had rebelled against them. Also, he says he took the name to encourage his friends and inspire fear in his foes and, again, I emphasise that "Dread" inspires far more fear than "Rebel". The Mortalitasi seem to have only limited knowledge, which is why they were willing to attend the meeting with Charter in order to discover more. Their representative suggested he could be a demon pretending to be an ancient elf god, which was understandable based on her encounter with him. The Dalish have always maintained that Fen'Harel stalks the Fade, which could account for their reluctance to engage with spirits there, and so it is likely that the Mortalitasi's knowledge is mostly connected with that side of him. Another group which seem to know more about Solas are the Executors as their representative specifically referred to him as "the Wolf", rather than the Dread Wolf. However, even they were curious as to what his intentions were, which is presumably why they attended the meeting, and Solas clearly didn't want them revealing what they knew to Charter and so silenced them before they could. This also meant they couldn't take back knowledge of his plan to the rest of their group, which Charter had revealed to the attendees. I believe that what really matters is whether they consider him to be a world ending threat. Oddly enough Charter didn't say it would be world ending so much as causing massive destruction. Was that the writers clarifying the information in Trespasser or Charter being unwilling to reveal just how deadly it would be? However, when talking to Solas direct, Charter returns to the assertion that his plan would destroy the world and he doesn't deny this, so I'm guessing the latter is how the Inquisition are framing his threat when talking to others. His agents would also seem to reinforce such a narrative since they seem to be promising modern elves a return of elven glory and destruction of their enemies, rather than simply destruction of the world.
|
|
Entropy
N2
Games: Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, KOTOR, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire, Mass Effect Andromeda
Posts: 130 Likes: 367
inherit
366
0
367
Entropy
130
August 2016
abnocte
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, KOTOR, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire, Mass Effect Andromeda
|
Post by Entropy on Mar 16, 2023 20:44:38 GMT
I believe that what really matters is whether they consider him to be a world ending threat. Oddly enough Charter didn't say it would be world ending so much as causing massive destruction. Was that the writers clarifying the information in Trespasser or Charter being unwilling to reveal just how deadly it would be? However, when talking to Solas direct, Charter returns to the assertion that his plan would destroy the world and he doesn't deny this, so I'm guessing the latter is how the Inquisition are framing his threat when talking to others. His agents would also seem to reinforce such a narrative since they seem to be promising modern elves a return of elven glory and destruction of their enemies, rather than simply destruction of the world. I always found "world ending" too dramatic, the world will change that is for sure but we don't know how. I wonder, will all elves be reconnected to the Fade and become immortal and able to use magic? what about other races? Solas says "as this world burned in the raw chaos", does this mean tearing the Veil will turn some spirits into demons, so instead of small rifts here and there the whole world will be flooded with them? or is he referring to the Evanuris taking action? Sooooo many questions
|
|
inherit
749
0
3,854
Iddy
3,860
August 2016
iddy
|
Post by Iddy on Mar 16, 2023 23:13:32 GMT
Oddly enough Charter didn't say it would be world ending so much as causing massive destruction. Was that the writers clarifying the information in Trespasser or Charter being unwilling to reveal just how deadly it would be? However, when talking to Solas direct, Charter returns to the assertion that his plan would destroy the world and he doesn't deny this, so I'm guessing the latter is how the Inquisition are framing his threat when talking to others. His agents would also seem to reinforce such a narrative since they seem to be promising modern elves a return of elven glory and destruction of their enemies, rather than simply destruction of the world. I always found "world ending" too dramatic, the world will change that is for sure but we don't know how. I wonder, will all elves be reconnected to the Fade and become immortal and able to use magic? what about other races? Solas says "as this world burned in the raw chaos", does this mean tearing the Veil will turn some spirits into demons, so instead of small rifts here and there the whole world will be flooded with them? or is he referring to the Evanuris taking action? Sooooo many questions ....This again. It is not "dramatic" or a metaphor. It is a question that has been presented to Solas in a literal sense, and he responded the same way. "Why bother disrupting the Qunari plot if you're going to destroy the world regardless?" "Because I'm not a monster. If they must die, I'd rather they die in comfort."
|
|
inherit
471
0
5,383
ladyiolanthe
3,967
August 2016
ladyiolanthe
Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquistion, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
591
695
|
Post by ladyiolanthe on Mar 17, 2023 4:43:20 GMT
So for me, the thing with Solas being convinced that he destroyed the world when he put up the Veil, and that to restore it, he must destroy it again, is patently false. The world still exists. There are still people and animals that are recognizably ones that existed before the Veil was created. Indeed, they are descendants of the people and animals that existed back in Solas' time.
Solas destroyed his world - his society and culture. But he did not destroy THE world. And chances are The world will still exist if he succeeds in his current plan to drop the Veil again. The current societies and cultures will be lost or irrevocably changed, but considering what those societies and cultures are, I'm not sure that's the worst thing ever. The survivors and their descendants will get a chance to create something new, and, one can hope, better.
|
|
inherit
Scribbles
185
0
Nov 17, 2024 22:23:52 GMT
31,578
Hanako Ikezawa
22,991
August 2016
hanakoikezawa
|
Post by Hanako Ikezawa on Mar 17, 2023 6:50:22 GMT
So for me, the thing with Solas being convinced that he destroyed the world when he put up the Veil, and that to restore it, he must destroy it again, is patently false. The world still exists. There are still people and animals that are recognizably ones that existed before the Veil was created. Indeed, they are descendants of the people and animals that existed back in Solas' time. Solas destroyed his world - his society and culture. But he did not destroy THE world. And chances are The world will still exist if he succeeds in his current plan to drop the Veil again. The current societies and cultures will be lost or irrevocably changed, but considering what those societies and cultures are, I'm not sure that's the worst thing ever. The survivors and their descendants will get a chance to create something new, and, one can hope, better. So screw the billions of innocent people who will be killed?
|
|
inherit
1033
0
Nov 29, 2024 11:07:26 GMT
37,056
colfoley
19,170
Aug 17, 2016 10:19:37 GMT
August 2016
colfoley
|
Post by colfoley on Mar 17, 2023 7:31:06 GMT
So for me, the thing with Solas being convinced that he destroyed the world when he put up the Veil, and that to restore it, he must destroy it again, is patently false. The world still exists. There are still people and animals that are recognizably ones that existed before the Veil was created. Indeed, they are descendants of the people and animals that existed back in Solas' time. Solas destroyed his world - his society and culture. But he did not destroy THE world. And chances are The world will still exist if he succeeds in his current plan to drop the Veil again. The current societies and cultures will be lost or irrevocably changed, but considering what those societies and cultures are, I'm not sure that's the worst thing ever. The survivors and their descendants will get a chance to create something new, and, one can hope, better. My big question on this is how much continuity will exist between one or the other. Afterall either because of the Imperium/ Early man or just the pure rigors of time we know next to nothing about the Pre Veil world and what it looked like specifically. Vague history and theories is pretty much it. And in modern Thedas and this world a big part of the narrative has been restoring continuity not only in terms of the pre veil world but discovering the true history of events, organizations, and individuals and using that as a basis to move forward. If Solas's destruction is metaphorical and is going to lead to a 'new' world then if it is going to have any chance at being a better one then it needs that knowlege.
|
|
inherit
∯ Oh Loredy...
455
0
Nov 29, 2024 11:46:30 GMT
31,169
gervaise21
13,094
August 2016
gervaise21
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
|
Post by gervaise21 on Mar 17, 2023 8:14:55 GMT
My big question on this is how much continuity will exist between one or the other. Afterall either because of the Imperium/ Early man or just the pure rigors of time we know next to nothing about the Pre Veil world and what it looked like specifically. Vague history and theories is pretty much it. Well, provided you believe Solas is telling the truth, then it is a lot less vague than it was. Some assertions have also been confirmed by him. For example, the Dalish maintain their ancestors were magical and immortal; according to Solas this is true. The Dalish believe Fen'Harel was responsible for their gods being locked away and no longer able to interact with them; Solas confirmed this is true. However, the Dalish believed their loss of immortality, whilst occurring around the time that their gods disappeared, was down to their contact with humans; whilst Solas says it was down to the creation of the Veil, so also his responsibility. It is this last part that he regrets and wants to reverse. If Solas's destruction is metaphorical and is going to lead to a 'new' world then if it is going to have any chance at being a better one then it needs that knowlege. Outside of the wholesale death and destruction he admits his plan is going to cause (even if the actual world is not destroyed), it is his lack of a plan, or willingness to divulge it, for the aftermath that is frustrating. We can challenge him about the potential release of the Evanuris, to which he replies with the vague "I had plans" (which was presumably when he still anticipated having his orb) but beyond that there is nothing to say how the survivors are going to prevent history repeating itself. We do have evidence of how the cycles have gone before. Back in ancient times, the elves were confronted with a threat which caused a degree of chaos and destruction among their communities. Leaders arose to deal with that threat but in the aftermath did not relinquish the power they had been granted over others and ultimately became tyrants. A new leader, Fen'Harel, arose who removed them from the scene but did nothing beyond that to organise elven society, which quickly degenerated into warring factions, resulting in chaos and destruction of their civilisation. Meanwhile, leaders arose among the humans who were able to capitalise on the downfall of the elven gods and consequent disorder in order to raise their own profile and assume leadership of their people, ultimately becoming tyrants over them and subsequently over the surviving elves too. Do you see a pattern there? It was tearing down the old regime without having a proper plan for the aftermath that was the real problem with Solas creating the Veil, not the loss of magic and immortality, so if he simply restores the latter by removing the Veil without giving thought to what comes after, history will just repeat itself again. This history, of course, only relates to elves and humans. We have yet to discover how much influence the Evanuris had over the development of the dwarven society but it is clear they did have some sort of impact. We also know next to nothing about Koslun and the Qunari beyond the limited information adherents to the Qun have granted us. However, Solas does seem to have such hatred for them that I sense it goes beyond just not approving of their philosophy.
|
|
inherit
∯ Oh Loredy...
455
0
Nov 29, 2024 11:46:30 GMT
31,169
gervaise21
13,094
August 2016
gervaise21
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
|
Post by gervaise21 on Mar 17, 2023 8:26:29 GMT
So for me, the thing with Solas being convinced that he destroyed the world when he put up the Veil, and that to restore it, he must destroy it again, is patently false. The world still exists. There are still people and animals that are recognizably ones that existed before the Veil was created. Indeed, they are descendants of the people and animals that existed back in Solas' time. This has always been one of the frustrating parts of the writing of this narrative. Perhaps it would help if they didn't keep using the word "world" to indicate civilisation or organisation of society. Nevertheless, the creation of the Veil was a reality changing occurrence on a Thedas wide scale (did it extend to continents beyond Thedas?) and its removal would alter reality for the inhabitants in a profound way. Just as creating the Veil essentially created a new world reality and the destruction of the old, so removing it would do the same in reverse. We do not know the population of the different races at the time he created the Veil but I think it is safe to assume that the elves in particular suffered a dramatic reduction, leaving the survivors weakened and open to being preyed upon, or assimilated into the culture of other races, inter marriage and a consequent loss of all traces of their elven heritage. The only groups of elves to survive were the Sentinels of the Arbor Wilds and the Evanuris supporters of Arlathan Forest (probably Andruil worshipers, hence their emphasis of the Way of Three Trees in the subsequent culture of the Dalish), who later came into conflict with the Tevinter Imperium. However, even if he is largely speaking metaphorically, Solas seemed in no doubt as to the consequences for the majority of people currently inhabiting Thedas; they are going to die a premature death as the direct result of his action (or at the very least have similar results as that of the ancient elves outlined above). There is no ambiguity in what he believes about that.
|
|
inherit
749
0
3,854
Iddy
3,860
August 2016
iddy
|
Post by Iddy on Mar 17, 2023 13:48:18 GMT
So for me, the thing with Solas being convinced that he destroyed the world when he put up the Veil, and that to restore it, he must destroy it again, is patently false. The world still exists. There are still people and animals that are recognizably ones that existed before the Veil was created. Indeed, they are descendants of the people and animals that existed back in Solas' time. Solas destroyed his world - his society and culture. But he did not destroy THE world. And chances are The world will still exist if he succeeds in his current plan to drop the Veil again. The current societies and cultures will be lost or irrevocably changed, but considering what those societies and cultures are, I'm not sure that's the worst thing ever. The survivors and their descendants will get a chance to create something new, and, one can hope, better. Do you remember Vir Dirthara, the library? It was destroyed in quite the literal sense. The place was sundered and there were memories of elves falling because the floor was gone. The physical world continued to exist, yes, but their spiritual realm did not. Quite literally. As told by Solas: "There were various other marvels. All intrinsicallly tied to the Fade, all destroyed". Their society wasn't only damaged in a social, cultural sense. Does anyone expect DA4 to end with the protagonist going "Ohh gee, we totally misunderstood what you meant! Sorry, Solas. Please, continue."
|
|
Entropy
N2
Games: Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, KOTOR, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire, Mass Effect Andromeda
Posts: 130 Likes: 367
inherit
366
0
367
Entropy
130
August 2016
abnocte
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, KOTOR, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire, Mass Effect Andromeda
|
Post by Entropy on Mar 17, 2023 22:35:59 GMT
...This again. It is not "dramatic" or a metaphor. It is a question that has been presented to Solas in a literal sense, and he responded the same way. "Why bother disrupting the Qunari plot if you're going to destroy the world regardless?" "Because I'm not a monster. If they must die, I'd rather they die in comfort." I haven't been to the forums in years, sorry for bringing this up again. I agree with ladyiolanthe 's definition of world: society and culture. I consider the rise an downfall of nations trough the ages a normal ocurrence because life is change. Sometimes it happens pacefully sometimes violently. Such is life. That is why the idea that Solas is going to destroy de world, understood as the physical place lifeforms inhabit, is bizarre to me. He says " I will save the elven people, even if this world must die", how is he saving the elven people if he destroys the place they need to live? or are we talking about death being their salvation? Do you remember Vir Dirthara, the library? It was destroyed in quite the literal sense. The place was sundered and there were memories of elves falling because the floor was gone. The physical world continued to exist, yes, but their spiritual realm did not. Quite literally. As told by Solas: "There were various other marvels. All intrinsicallly tied to the Fade, all destroyed". Their society wasn't only damaged in a social, cultural sense. Does anyone expect DA4 to end with the protagonist going "Ohh gee, we totally misunderstood what you meant! Sorry, Solas. Please, continue." Just because the world, understood as the physical place lifeforms inhabit, is not destroyed does not mean changes brought by the Veil being removed won't threaten the lives of everyone in Thedas. I think that is reason enough to try to stop Solas. And I, for one, think that at the end of DA:D the Veil will be no more. I base my theory on: Sandal's prophecy in DA2: One day the magic will come back. All of it. Everyone will be just like they were. The shadows will part, and the skies will open wide. (This also why I think the physical world won't be destroyed) The letters "Dragon Age" in DA:D logo are cleary shattered As far as we know, Solas is the most powerful being walking Thedas at the moment. How can he be stopped? Mythal "survived" her murder and Solas took a 1000 years nap after creating the Veil, I assume because the spell drained him In the released art, we have seen references to the blights/archdemons, the red lyrium idol and the Foci, effectively tying DAO, DA2 and DAI. Each game exposed us to different lore that seem related to the creation of the Veil and possibly its destruction. At the moment, and without any further info, I think that the first three games have been a set up to the destruction of the Veil. My opinion may change as we learn new info, but such is life
|
|
xerrai
N3
Posts: 847 Likes: 1,177
inherit
1451
0
1,177
xerrai
847
September 2016
xerrai
|
Post by xerrai on Mar 18, 2023 4:03:29 GMT
[...] As far as we know, Solas is the most powerful being walking Thedas at the moment. How can he be stopped? Mythal "survived" her murder and Solas took a 1000 years nap after creating the Veil, I assume because the spell drained him [...] My opinion may change as we learn new info, but such is life It's an extremely dark way to go about things, but destroying Solas's soul isn't entirely out of the realm of possibility. Old Gods are permanently taken out when their soul tries to overtake a not-too-corrupted Grey Warden. Assuming that narrative holds true (because how was that verified with 100% certainty? They could be sent to the void or something for all we know.), would stand to reason that something similar may be applicable to even powerful beings like Solas provided certain criteria are met. There's still debate on what those criteria are, but most agree that one major component is, in Flemeth's words, how "One cannot force a soul upon the unwilling"...and I can very much see Solas attempting to do just that if he is genuinely believes there is no other way and if he is given no other option. He may even cling on to the hope, or otherwise be influenced by hubris, into thinking that whoever he overtakes is not that opposed to being taken over. And that can be what destroys him. Mind, his physical body would probably need to be killed and possibly even blighted...but there may be something there if we really are looking into his total destruction. Not too sure I would WANT to take that option, but it would depend on what the next game tells us.
|
|
inherit
∯ Oh Loredy...
455
0
Nov 29, 2024 11:46:30 GMT
31,169
gervaise21
13,094
August 2016
gervaise21
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
|
Post by gervaise21 on Mar 18, 2023 8:25:57 GMT
That is why the idea that Solas is going to destroy de world, understood as the physical place lifeforms inhabit, is bizarre to me. He says " I will save the elven people, even if this world must die", how is he saving the elven people if he destroys the place they need to live? or are we talking about death being their salvation? Why does he say to Lavellan (male or female) that it will result in the death of their people? They are elves, although not in the eyes of Abelas, who recognises Solas as one of his own but not Lavellan or Sera. In Tevinter Nights he seemed to think it possible that Charter would survive but her origins are mysterious so it is possible she is another of his agents who effectively switched sides, like Felassan. He talks of the "elves who remain", not all elves. I've mentioned in my earlier post that on the face of it only two groups of elves survived to the present. The modern elves descend from the enclave in Arlathan Forest, which would seem to have been doing something similar to the Sentinels, sleeping out the millennia until the Evanuris return (which strangely enough they did believe will happen eventually) but were forced to awaken permanently through the intrusion of the Tevinter Imperium. Could it be there are other enclaves of elves sleeping in uthenera awaiting the restoration of their world? Could it be that, like the gradual deterioration of the Crossroads, they will slowly starve to death because of the Veil, which impedes their sustenance from the Fade? That might explain his determination to reverse his action in order to "save his people". Solas took a 1000 years nap after creating the Veil, I assume because the spell drained him Actually, it was closer to a 3,700 year nap, 2800 years before the modern calendar and 840 years after it. That is a very long period of history during which other races have grown and developed in the current reality. For that matter we don't know modern creatures are the same as the ones that existed pre-Veil and likely they also adapted over time to a world with reduced magic. As Solas admits, the reversal of his previous action will have severe implications for all life that has developed post Veil. I don't deny that the narrative could have Solas succeeding in some way in going through with this ritual and the result may not be as he anticipated, for good or ill, leading us to have to deal with the aftermath. Thus, it will be possible to survive it but that will apply to our hero and their companions, who will effectively have plot armour to preserve them. May be they will be in the Crossroads and protected from the immediate effects (the game leak information talked of using an eluvian to leave the hub) or may be they will have some sort of floating hub that does the same. That won't lessen the impact on the population at large who have no such sanctuary. Incidentally, I do wonder if there will be some localised weakening and removal of the Veil, even if it is not Thedas wide. The concept art would suggest as much (there being a shattered floating landscape surrounding the archer and what appear to be floating aravels with a similar backdrop), bearing in mind when Corypheus punched a hole in it at the end of DAI, the surrounding country also started to levitate. Of course, the narrative didn't take into account what would really happen when such large quantities of rock plummeted back to earth, having everyone survive even if they had been left behind on the ground. So, it is entirely possible the statements by Solas were written without really considering what the implications would be.
|
|
Entropy
N2
Games: Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, KOTOR, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire, Mass Effect Andromeda
Posts: 130 Likes: 367
inherit
366
0
367
Entropy
130
August 2016
abnocte
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, KOTOR, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire, Mass Effect Andromeda
|
Post by Entropy on Mar 18, 2023 15:52:55 GMT
It's an extremely dark way to go about things, but destroying Solas's soul isn't entirely out of the realm of possibility. Old Gods are permanently taken out when their soul tries to overtake a not-too-corrupted Grey Warden. Assuming that narrative holds true (because how was that verified with 100% certainty? They could be sent to the void or something for all we know.), would stand to reason that something similar may be applicable to even powerful beings like Solas provided certain criteria are met. There's still debate on what those criteria are, but most agree that one major component is, in Flemeth's words, how "One cannot force a soul upon the unwilling"...and I can very much see Solas attempting to do just that if he is genuinely believes there is no other way and if he is given no other option. He may even cling on to the hope, or otherwise be influenced by hubris, into thinking that whoever he overtakes is not that opposed to being taken over. And that can be what destroys him. Mind, his physical body would probably need to be killed and possibly even blighted...but there may be something there if we really are looking into his total destruction. Not too sure I would WANT to take that option, but it would depend on what the next game tells us. Don't get me wrong, I don't think it is impossible just EXTREMELY difficult and I agree with everything you said actually. With the information we have I can't think of any other way to end Solas Why does he say to Lavellan (male or female) that it will result in the death of their people? They are elves, although not in the eyes of Abelas, who recognises Solas as one of his own but not Lavellan or Sera. In Tevinter Nights he seemed to think it possible that Charter would survive but her origins are mysterious so it is possible she is another of his agents who effectively switched sides, like Felassan. He talks of the "elves who remain", not all elves. Sorry I didn't make myself clear in my post, but when I quoted Solas "I will save the elven people" I was thinking about whatever "true" elves like Abelas remain. They need a "world" (physichal place) to live too. Actually, it was closer to a 3,700 year nap, 2800 years before the modern calendar and 840 years after it. That is a very long period of history during which other races have grown and developed in the current reality. For that matter we don't know modern creatures are the same as the ones that existed pre-Veil and likely they also adapted over time to a world with reduced magic. As Solas admits, the reversal of his previous action will have severe implications for all life that has developed post Veil. I haven't played in ages and need to refresh my knowdledge on the lore, sorry for the inaccuracy
|
|