Rank the Mass Effect Series

Mine is

1) ME 1

2) ME 3

3) ME A

4) ME 2

1) ME:1
2) ME:3
3) ME:A
4) ME:2

ME1>>ME2~ME:A>>>>ME3

1
A
2
3

Lazy! When he realized how many combinations there are he just tacked "other" at the end of the poll.

I'm not telling.

Based on two PTs of each of the three games, A>2>3>1

I am about to finish the second Andromeda run, and it is hard for me to tell a favorite between Andromeda and 2.  I think on the whole, the more balanced design of Andromeda between main, side and companion missions, and its stellar interaction saturation, along with the extras like Nomad, combat fun and MP puts it ahead of my significant Mordin and Thane's adoration. And, well, Reyes on this second PT really helped to change my mind about romantic content being meh in Andromeda. So, third run of Andromeda is in the cards, but not for the Trilogy.

1. ME1
2. ME3
3. MEA
4. ME2

3
1
2
A

Close race between all parts of the trilogy, but ME3 edges the others out by being the most polished game with a strong story, palpable atmosphere, great music and memorable, often emotional moments that even the ending can't tarnish.
ME1 gets 2nd place for having a good, self-contained story with a few exceptional moments, like scaling the Citadel Tower with a giant, imposing Sovereign as a back-drop. Still one of my favourite sections of a video game. Also, I'm one of the few odd people that don't hate the game's combat weakest on characters as individuals, but as a squad it felt more cohesive and intimate, mainly due to the debriefings after each main story segment.
ME2 is a close 3rd for just being darn enjoyable to play through with an epic finish. Weakest story, but lots of flavour otherwise.

Maybe ME:A just has to 'settle' a bit, but at the moment it feels bland. The semi-open world game offers a lot of filler in terms of exploration and crafting and strike teams and side quests and it just tires me out. I just want to play through a good story and have some awesome cinematic moments and at least a handful of choices that have an impact, or at least the illusion of one. Whatever good ME:A contains gets somewhat lost in the static of all the meaningless stuff for me. Which is a shame, since there's obviously a lot of passion put into the game.
And Multiplayer feels less satisfying. I'm not sure what it is - the shorter matches, the terrible UI, the 'feel' of the gameplay (no more Krogan bitch-slapping enemies that sends them flying, for instance).

Hoping we get an ME:A2 that will retroactively add a little extra value to the first Andromeda game via save imports.

I would have gone with 3>A>1>2. For all of 3's foibles, has quite a lot of my favorite moments in the trilogy, some served well by the buildup of past titles. And although this is technically unfair, the DLC's add tremendous value for me.

Maybe we should repeat this vote after ME:A has gotten some DLC's too.
For instance - ME3 is hugely better with all DLC's included.
It feels not fair to compare a "barren" ME:A to all the others that have lots of extra's.

Really? I don't have any DLCs for ME3, and I like it a lot anyway.