I kind of wish you could get called out for inconsistent statements

My first PT I was all over the place. All three Divine candidates pled their case, and each time, I told them they'd make a great Divine.  

But the way they were selling themselves sounded so reasonable.   

I actually came across a really nice instance of this in my play through with Blackwall during my chat with him while he was in prison during his personal quest. When I called him out on lying about his identity as a Gray Warden he pointed out it wasn't so different than what I do because I had confided in him that I don't believe in the Maker but all my other dialogue options related to the Inquisition in public reaffirmed that I believed I was a divinely sent Herald from Andraste. I was really impressed with this nice bit of dialogue customization, particularly because I doubt that sort of play through (pretending to be a believer but really not believing in Andrastisim) is one that many players opt to RP. That said, yes, I would definitely like to see more of these sorts of moments in the future. Having companions call you out on your inconsistent BS more often would also be a great way to disincentivize players from doing a companion pleasing play through just for approval farming.

Can we also have an option to call out our companions too when they're inconsistent?

Haven't companions been doing this? It's the dreaded You Of All People/I Thought You Were Different conversation.

Vivienne calls you out on it if your answers contradict each other during a conversation about the fate of mages.

She says "It is amusing to see all the turns your mind takes".

We need an option to like posts multiple times....