[Day/Night Game] Trouble on the Citadel - round "LE Part 2: Why Cerberus Is Right For You"

I get it, I am in the same boat. The only reason I didn't change my vote in the end, however, was that it would have eliminated myself in the process, or put someone else with me in the tie.

Still I am getting more confindent in my intent to vote for you. (And so far, nobody gave me any good reason not to.)



That's just insulting!

Let's just say, it had a reason why I couldn't properly answer the question if I am the colour blue or not. In the ME universe, that's the equivalent of dividing by zero. I'm just glad I survived as long as I did.

Pffff. Say goodbye to your precious summaries if I'm eliminated

You know...she has a point

Now??  You didn't read my comments in other rounds which also found you very suspicious?  

Honey, you've been playing it as cool as the Sahara

I'm glad someone does!



Honey, I'm not aiming to play anything cool in games like these. Not even when I am GMing. (Now that I think about it, especially not when I am GMing as some people might confirm. xD)

Also, yes I am used to being suspected by you. Nothing new here, and I appreciate it. It's always good to stay on guard!

I'm male. But if you require me to show you my manly parts - no can do, sorry.

I'll take your word for it

regack, what's your take on all this?

*offers reg a big mug with steaming hot coffee for luring purposes*

I have to admit that I am surprised you are now offering more of a defense, Dragon. At least give an idea of who you think is the guilty party, if you are innocent of course. The fact that you don't does rather suggest you are a spy who is out of options who to frame.

Sorry that was a typo. It should have read "not" (typed it in something of a hurry and forgot to proof read as I have IRL things to do too: feeding animals and such).

So I will try again. Why are you not offering a better defense Dragon if you are a hero?"

Yes, although at this point I think that only rules out one role, because the others are accounted for. And I've already been accused of being Aria, Nyreen, or Morinth, all of whom are council races


Except my answers are more clear and explicit than seven's, since I've just been answering them plainly instead of posting gifs or quotes that would depend on at least a bit of ME knowledge to interpret. So if being open about hinting and answering questions is a reason to NOT suspect someone, then I ought to be less suspicious than seven.



Anyway, another summary since Arcadia asked so nicely (plus my thoughts on roles).
Clues thus far:

catilina - Good Glyph

OG - Good Gianna

dadi
1st: asked if female; is obviously not

fylimar - evil Niftu Cal

arcadia - probably Charr
1st: "my people are not on the council"
2nd: Thinks thresher maws are real nice fried.

seven - is claiming Aria, who I will remind everyone was one of the suspects for the killing
1st: Asked if has a blue butt - gave a picture of Stitch, so yes?
2nd: "There are secrets on Omega only I know."
Says the second clue is obvious.

gervaise - Good Kirrahe

dragon - accused of being Aria, Nyreen, or Morinth
1st: no questions asked
2nd: not human
3rd: is council race

vella/hag - Good Bailey

regack - Michel (not evil due to the Arcadia/Charr thing), or Khalisah
1st: is council race
2nd: human
3rd: is female

owl - I guess is claiming Kal'Reegar? I can't think of anyone else that fits and hasn't been claimed.
1st: said the council is weak when asked if council race, so I'm taking that as a no
2nd: we're all blue every once in a while
Says our interpretations are not as intended, calling out specifically the Aethyta interpretation, but "blue lady" had also been suggested, so...
3rd: male

space - only Conrad fits
1st: is council race
2nd: male



Now, here's the problem. We know Morinth is in this game, and yet I'm the only one left whose clues/claims could point to Morinth. I got asked some pretty generic questions with a lot of overlap, so that's part of the problem.

So why is that a problem?

Because it means you're trying to eliminate the person you believe to be Morinth...who can't eliminate anyone on her own at night. Who can't even win on her own. Giving the remaining spy or spies another night to eliminate people.

Why waste a voting round going after Morinth instead of a spy at this late stage? And then who will your suspect be tomorrow if I am eliminated? The only possibility left is seven as evil Aria instead of good Aria, or that someone/someones lied big time about their roles.


But ok, let's assume you believe I'm a spy!

Do you realize that leaves us without a Morinth, based on clues and claims made? Someone is lying.


But what's even more damning is examining who is voting for me: Arcadia, owl, seven, and space. Do you see who didn't vote for me? Regack. Who, through gervaise' ability and Arcadia's association, is good, and who therefore cannot be Morinth.

That means Morinth is voting for me. So either Morinth is voting for a spy, which completely goes against her role, or she is happily voting for a hero who ended up looking suspicious.


By voting for me, you are risking either voting for Morinth and giving the spy/spies another free night to kill, or you are voting for a hero.



I still need to think about who I want to vote for, but I just spent a whole hour on this post (yes, I'm slow), and Saxons need killing before bedtime.