[Day/Night Game] Trouble on the Citadel - round "LE Part 2: Why Cerberus Is Right For You"

I'd also point out that technically we also need to have Nvanfleet's vote, except he seems to have gone off grid. I hope nothing bad has happened IRL.

And you hope to do so by voting off a role that has the ability to prove their innocence? No erroneous logic here. I'm the only one doing it.

How can Garrus aim at one person and kill another? Unless I'm missing something in the role description, it seems straight forward. Garrus gives a name to the game master during the night and that person gets shot. How can Garrus say kill gerva and then romice gets shot out of the blue?

Unless the narrative meant that this is what Garrus was thinking that's he's killing a spy, but his assumption was wrong and he shot someone else.

Are there some sort of additional rules/special abilities for characters not included in the description? Shoot AND miss?

Don't know what you mean about bringing back corpses twice?

If he gets attacked by both a spy and gets shot by Garrus it would be double death. But, it seems romice wasn't the double target, so it doesn't apply.

target felt the attempt and successfully resisted it, either with or without help of another (seeing as Witch could apply to either of the two people that the Agent was likely to want to indoctrinate

We must be reading two different role lists. It doesn't say on the roles list that some role can resist indoctrination on their own.

Well, I figured that Garrus told the gamemaster that they wanted to shoot romice either because they thought they were an agent or wanted to get rid of a role that could help the agent. Or they figured both were possible and thought shooting romice was the player that was the safest bet. I also assumed dragontartare wrote that garrus almost shot the agent for entertaining/dramatic reasons

Also, it doesn't seem me that there are two players that are claiming the same role, especially after luke's last post. So, I still need to mull this over some more!

Okay, good point.  I'll retract my vote from Obsidian Gryphon and vote for luketrevelyan then and see what happens.

There is a huge difference between saying, 'I think you are using your newbie status to hide being a spy' and 'you're making a lot of erroneous assumptions.'

The polite way of saying it would have been: I believe you are either trying to mislead us or trying to pry information about the roles by faking the lack of knowledge. NOT 'you're wrong about everything all the time.' That comes off as you informing the player, 'you're either dumb or a spy trying to confuse us.' along with your suspicions regarding their role.

If you do not agree with the way someone interprets something, you can always quote them and explain why you think the events happened in a different way. What is the point instead of an explanation in getting all mysterious and saying 'I know something you do not' or telling them that they're making erroneous assumptions all the time? To let them know they suck?

I never said this. I have been nothing but helpful towards you and then you take one comment and blow it out of all proportion and it seems to me you did so because I had the gall to suggest you might be a spy, which was a perfectly legitimate suspicion to have. I think I will just back off now and leave things as they are. Then it can play out as you wish it to.

Any vote that isn't for OG is the wrong choice.

Wrex says why not crush both.

Oh. Right. Nobody here is a Krogan.

I'm hard to kill, anyone should know that.

Over the years I've grown used to smell of dead bodies... that's probably a bad sign but one more wouldn't make any difference.

---

Off game.

I'm off for some ME3 MP. I'll check back in later. 

Hmm

Points of contention #1 Luke/Pela and #2 Luke/Obsidian

Common denominator: Luke

Tempted to change to Obsidian.

I'd be scared to contend Legion's role as a spy considering they can flatten me with a flick of the fingers. Garrus who can't shoot anymore is a way safer choice, so that's where the spy is hiding.