[Day/Night Game] Trouble on the Citadel - round "LE Part 2: Why Cerberus Is Right For You"

Dragon never denied there was at least one hint made by Reed, which is why she changed her vote. All she said was she hadn't realised there was a second even stronger hint at the role. This is because of the misunderstanding about the first hint actually being a hint, so initially Dragon thought there must be another hint even stronger than the one she had seen. Reed seemed to realise this as he continued to focus on explaining the party hint, which many people didn't get.

The whole case that rests against the role currently occupied Catilina is not whether or not Dragon got the hint, which she clearly did (or why change her vote), but why she didn't use her ability the following night, which she also explains. So essentially if you were in the same position, would that seem reasonable?

I didn't get the comment about space too until much later, therefore I don't hold it against her

You guys don't need to go for camp adonniel or camp Cati.

There are also romice, feli and pela.

For some reason not seeing Cati's evilness is being interpreted as me being evil. There are certain things related to intuition as well. Some people may see something Dragon said as suspicious and another person will read the same line and not see it. That doesn't make the person who does see it evil.

It's a bad situation that we are discussing actions of a missing person, but frankly, I feel I got the short end of the stick here since there is a GM involuntarily but representing another player even if I understand why and of course Gerva did an excellent job of trying to be objective and diplomatic in this case and being really good at outlining the situation in general.

To try to further clarify, I was trying to play off what I thought was Dragon's hint at her role (possibly being Javik what with being tons of fun at parties) and not give away my role to the spies because, as noticed, what happened when I gave a better hint at Liara? Insta-dead. 

To my mind what Dragon had been saying is the she didn't realise there were 2 clues to Reed's identity. It wasn't the 2nd (obvious) clue she didn't get, she thought that was the 1st clue. However, on re-reading the posts she realised there had been another earlier lue. Several other people were also unaware that was a clue.

Dragon also pointed out why Javik would not necessarily want to use their ability so early in the game. Anyone who has played the game previously would be aware of these drawbacks. It is not just the double elimination the following night but the fact that no one can use their abilities that night including Liara. So Javik is more likely to wait and give other defensive roles (if present) the opportunity to defend Liara. That said, we did have an instance when a person pretending to be Javik (because spies did not then have actual roles) used this as an excuse for why they did not act. What Dragon also pointed out was that since other defensive roles had not been used, or were not successful, then Javik would potentially be the last defensive role left and did people really want to risk eliminating him?

I got dragon's hint, but I'm not really getting reed's possible hint. If it's the "I don't go to parties" line then I'm even more confused for spoilery reasons I'll explain below. (Here's hoping the spoiler button works. If it doesn't, then don't read past this point if you haven't played the third game)