[Day/Night Game] Trouble on the Citadel - round "LE Part 2: Why Cerberus Is Right For You"

Oh noes! I'm under suspicion! *shifty eyes* What gave me away? D: I was perfectly sneaky!

No I'm not! I made sure to hide my mask under the carpet!

So where are we with the voting?

Well Adonniel appears to want to be voted out so let's get this moving? Unless she starts objecting.

Maybe Chakwas will bring you back!

Well I don't think I find either of you particularly suspicious. Just jumping on a bandwagon. If you have a better target then convince me? I know, cati. But why?

And Reed is a guy. he did say he believes me innocent. Maybe he can clarify if there's some doubt.

Everyone can vote for me without sorry (of course, if wants to commit a big mistake), we all can vote for anyone, yes?

I'll just say that I have pretty much zero suspicion towards you, Space. 

Alright, I'll switch from Adonniel to Cati then. Sorry Cati.

Okay, I am going to be highly unorthodox here and do as Fylimar asked. Since Adonniel was casting aspersions at me at the beginning on the basis of things she has done as GM, I may as well live up to it.

There was a reason why I declared the voting up until Dragon's departure void and that was because whatever Dragon may or may not have said, she was no longer around to defend herself even if there was a perfectly valid reason why she did so. It was therefore rather unfair to condemn the person taking over the role on the basis of Dragon's behaviour. As Cati is less familiar with this setting than I am, I am going to put forward all the facts so people can make up their minds based on them rather than selective quotes that other people might make. So the narrative concerning Reed's role claim went as follows:









Moonae votes for Reed.


























Then after Reed's overnight elimination:













It was after this that the conflict kicked off between Adonniel and Dragon when the latter was questioning Adonniel's logic in voting for her.

To my mind what Dragon had been saying is the she didn't realise there were 2 clues to Reed's identity. It wasn't the 2nd (obvious) clue she didn't get, she thought that was the 1st clue. However, on re-reading the posts she realised there had been another earlier clue. Several other people were also unaware that was a clue.

Dragon also pointed out why Javik would not necessarily want to use their ability so early in the game. Anyone who has played the game previously would be aware of these drawbacks. It is not just the double elimination the following night but the fact that no one can use their abilities that night including Liara. So Javik is more likely to wait and give other defensive roles (if present) the opportunity to defend Liara. That said, we did have an instance when a person pretending to be Javik (because spies did not then have actual roles) used this as an excuse for why they did not act. What Dragon also pointed out was that since other defensive roles had not been used, or were not successful, then Javik would potentially be the last defensive role left and did people really want to risk eliminating him?