[Day/Night Game] Trouble on the Citadel - round "LE Part 2: Why Cerberus Is Right For You"

I think you were Still, I don't think my suggestion was very popular, so your subtlety will stay subtle.

I think this would depend on whether one or two spies are in play. Having run a game on Skyhold with only one spy in play to begin with makes them very vulnerable to investigation and elimination the first round as well. Liara is already a strong role and making her immune to elimination the first time it happens for the entire day/night cycle seems overpowered to me but particularly if there is only one spy in play. At present, with only eight people participating, having more than one active spy does seem to give them too much advantage.

However, we could play the next game with two active spies if you protect Liara in that way as it would balance the advantage to both sides.

Whilst it seems like Liara is cursed that is really only because she often falls to people who are the target of early elimination/suspicion. Is it the role that is cursed or the player? Also being an investigative role is always going to be a two edged sword because you have to balance disclosure against the fact that spies will want to take you out. If you take the jeopardy of that role away then it gives too much of an advantage to the heroes.

Hmm, well, based on Moonae's previous posts, it seems she probably investigated one of the players who were helpful with providing questions from the last round during Night 1: gervaise, reed, or flyimar. I'm thinking maybe she investigated gervaise, but it's possible it's one of the other three.
We can also safely assume she didn't investigate romice or Cati since she did cast a bit of suspicion towards them for being a bit quiet.

I do think, the information from Laira should be shared, since she wasn't eliminated at night, but you, dragon, are GM, and if you say, you won't release it, because one person is not ok with it, then it is your decision.

Privately via PM with me, we have one player uncomfortable with revealing anything that Moon didn't already say before she was eliminated. Publicly, we have this:

Space said no, but isn't set on that.
Fylimar is ok with revealing the investigation, but didn't specify player or role.
Pela is ok with revealing the investigation, but didn't specify player or role.
Gervaise is ok with the role being revealed, but not the player.

Moon, Romice, Reed, and Catilina haven't said whether they want the info revealed or not.

I wanted to reveal the player investigated, not the role. I am not willing to reveal a player's role like that when all of you so far are keeping your roles very secret. This is different than, for example, Kasumi's role being revealed because she saves someone during the night.

dazk you stealthy rascal you. You should play next round

To everyone else, narrative coming very soon.

Yeah the description is a bit misleading. Bringing back would suggest to me restoring someone previously eliminated like Chakwas does.

Miranda blocks abilities.

Coming back for next round?

Well, that would be me. And the reason I did it: it was a random vote as yours and then I realised, that I helped voting someone out, who made well be innocent. I wasn't in your situation, so I switechd to give Moon at least a chance. She was no more suspicious to me, than anyone lese and I didn't want to target you or pela, because you two (and me) get targeted so often.

I didn't think we were allowed to straight up ask space who voted for who? But I see that doesn't matter because fylimar just came out and said it...

Uh, I was gonna argue that the spy switching still makes no sense because we don't know who voted so why resort to a tie when you can just eliminate someone? lol