[Day/Night Game] Trouble on the Citadel - round "LE Part 2: Why Cerberus Is Right For You"

Sorry, my bad since I started this. Well there are still other people we can ask about since only Fylimar and I have said what we did. There is still one other unidentified person who voted for Moonae, two people who voted for me and the people who voted for Reed and Fylimar. So there is plenty still to work with and Space still gets the chance to protect his ally.

We don't have to make all the questions about the voting choices either. How about returning to some of the earlier suggestions that weren't used last round? For example, is the spy an alien?

If you'd all rather discuss your votes, maybe we should make role hints against the rules. Though I recall that rule getting broken quite a lot in the Skyhold game.

In any case, Space needs three new questions

I agree with flyimar about the voting questions, mainly because it is the first round so far and there is only one spy. At this point, the spy could have voted for Moonae or anyone else. Plus, I also feel a bit bad that I know more than I should have about who voted for who, so I think we probably shouldn't know any more about voting until the next round.

I think maybe we should try to narrow the field down a little bit more and try to exonerate some of the male roles. So yeah, I'm thinking about asking Space about the spy's specialty/class and whether or not he's an alien. I could ask if if his class is a mixed/hybrid or not for the two questions, and then ask whether or not he's an alien. And of course, I'm open to more feedback/suggestions.

Yay

Well, I need to refresh myself on whatever the heck we learned last round cause it's been awhile.

(after looking back like 5 pages) So, we learned that the spy is probably a male character. Good to know. Now, to check who the male roles are...

So there is:
Garrus, Javik, Wrex, Kaidan, Legion?

That's a short list.

But I'm never good at choosing a question. I feel they need to be something that conflicts with each other like the previous round of (are they male/female) and then one obvious one so that it's hard to lie.

The already proposed questions are: Are they alien? Which I'm guessing would garner a "yes" answer being that the majority of those 5 are alien. What if we asked if they are human as well? Only one is human...

Then make the third question something obvious he would want to lie about. Idk how specific we can get, but Garrus would be easy to single out, so if we make him lie about this one, we'll find out whether they are alien or not for sure. So Garrus has been a squadmate in all 3 games and been on all 3 Normandys, the others have not. So I think we need to work a question in there that would point to Garrus.

Read spoiler at your own risk. lol

Thanks, since I'm not sure, I will ever make it that far, the spoiler is absolutely ok

Yes, I think you are right

I think he counts as alien if you take a broad approach to the meaning (anything not human is alien) but does (he) actually count as male? I'm thinking he does since we regard EDI as female but she does have the advantage of a female shaped body whereas Legion is a flash light on top of a robot body, so what does everyone else think?

I find this discussion...interesting. As a reminder, if I think a question is too specific, I won't allow it. Otherwise, it would just be a matter of the heroes lasting enough rounds to narrow down the options, giving the villains no chance to win.


How far along are you?