[Day/Night Game] Trouble on the Citadel - round "LE Part 2: Why Cerberus Is Right For You"

Hi guys, I'm home and managed to get some sleep, so I now read through all the posts again and I have realised I totally spaced on a couple of important things

I am not convinced of Moon's guilt as much as I was before. As I believe Fylimar said, if what Moonae at is true and she is a hero, then we can't afford to lose her.

With that in mind, I'll switch from Moonae to Reed. But if Reed turns out to be a hero, my suspicion will probably fall back on Moon

SOMEONE'S GOING DOWN FIGHTING HERE FOLKS.

Just need to point out here that if I was evil then revealing myself as Wrex is no protection from being voted off because I would be the last spy and so it doesn't matter who I took with me as it would be game over. Therefore it does not benefit an evil Wrex to reveal themselves as it would simply make them a target for Garrus or Jack in the night (if they are in game).

As I have declared, I have decided to reveal myself so if we do get the wrong person this round, the spy will have a greater number of targets to choose from in the night. If they go for me that will save someone else. Meanwhile Liara ought to be able to check out at least one of the remaining suspects so there will be no doubt in the heroes minds who to vote for next day.

However, it would be helpful in identifying the remaining spy if we have some indication of who the remaining unknown people are. If you are Jack then give us a hint. However, please do not take out someone in the night unless you are absolutely sure of the status of your target because if you get it wrong then we would be three heroes down and only two people still in play, one of whom would be the spy. The same comment applies if you are Garrus. It will aid the heroes far more than the spies to know who you are.

I'm taking my computer in for its annual health check today. I hope they can get it back to me this evening but if they take longer then I just wanted everyone to know why I have fallen silent.

Ho, hum, well I'm back at last. Took 32 hours and I was getting withdrawal symptoms but finally I'm on line again.

I understand your suspicion Reed but I've tried to explain myself logically. Since I know I'm good then probability says that the spy is either you or Pela.

There is an outside chance that Moonae has been playing a very clever game totally acting as a good character would even to the extent of using her special ability in such a way as to allay suspicion but even then she only revealed her role when she was in danger, so I think her being evil is less likely than either of you.

If we get the vote wrong this round and I end up surviving the night, then heroes by all means vote for me if Fylimar has checked out the other main suspect and found them to be innocent as well.

Still I'd rather we got it right first time and that is why I keep pushing for information.

So, Reed, am I right in saying that you are not Grunt?

Wouldn't you like to know master spy!

Suffice to say that if we don't get the spy this round and the list is narrowed, my ability would still be quite useful. I feel like my hints aren't so vague (and yes there's 2)

Why would I switch my vote? Currently my only option of not being eliminated by the remaining spy (of which I have already stated that in my POV is most likely you or Pela. Changing my vote to someone I think is a hero does me no good and makes me look like a spy. lol) is to hope that Moonae trusts the person who has trusted her rather than being quick to jump on her for helping Space and thus garner a tiebreaker with Pela. The master spy comment is simply for fun as it may not necessarily be you. If you'll recall, I've called space and others master spies or some variation in the other game many times as well.

Switching to Fylimar means I'm voting for someone heavily hinting Liara. Switching to Romice means I'm voting for someone that has been claimed to be cleared. Switching to Moon would just encourage her to vote for me and would have me voting for someone I believe to be a hero. Switching to you makes sense, but currently doesn't help me, thus my vote must go on Pela. Basically, I could switch but there isn't much evidence to convince others to follow me, so I'm hoping my voting history and hints offer reason to switch. After all, it's only been 1 round. The only thing against me and Pela is that we are claiming roles not guaranteed to be good since we both voted to eliminate the known spy. And the only thing against you is that you didn't vote for space, but voted for me and fylimar who is claiming a guaranteed good role.

Of course switching would make a lot more sense if Pela or Romice decide to switch, but that isn't looking likely as you said. Pela will leave her vote on me as I believe she said you and I are her suspects. If she decides to switch to you, I'd follow naturally. Thus, I await the final vote.

You would have me waste my switches before all votes are in to do what? Have the votes be even more weighted against me? 1-1-3 is worse than 2-3 when you're on the verge of elimination. lol

Oops, got so wrapped up in how the Skyhold game played out I almost forgot this one was still going.

Okay, from my point of view I have three suspects: Pela, Reed and Gervaise. Of these, Pela and Reed would be dangerous to have around at night if they're evil, while Gervaise's power only activates on elimination. (This is assuming the hints aren't misleading, of course.)

I think we'll probably have this cleared up by morning anyway, but in the meantime it's better to vote off one of the more potentially dangerous ones, and since they both voted for Space earlier I'll just simply even things out by voting for Pela and see what happens next.

I meant in-game morning.

I'd die laughing.

Votes so far
Pela: 3
Reed: 3