[Day/Night Game] Trouble on the Citadel - round "LE Part 2: Why Cerberus Is Right For You"

What about Romice? She may not have switched her vote to Fylimar but she didn't vote for Reed. Also since Dusty was willing to transfer her vote away from Romice and didn't try claiming Miranda for herself, I think Romice's role claim is genuine. Also voting for Dusty seemed reasonable enough last round considering that she has not really given any real indication of who she might be.

Votes
Catilina - 1

Crew
01] Space Cowboy
02] Dustyelf
03] Pelassarias
04] Dragontartare - voted
05] Sgtreed24 - Tali'Zorah vas Normandy
06] Romice
07] Gervaise21
08] Fylimar - Agent Kaidan
09] Catilina

Unlike last round, this time I only know who not to vote for. So I thought it would be more informative to observe what other people do. However, anyone reading my analysis should be able to work it out based off who I didn't mention.

If I were Allers, whether guilty or not, why would I openly admit to it? The entire reason we retired the role when I was GM was because she has no redeeming qualities and players were voting off Allers based purely on the role, regardless of suspicion of guilt.

And don't start with "it's a good spy cover" either, because as I explained above, it isn't. Any role that gathers votes based purely on the role itself rather than on player behavior is NOT a role anyone would want to claim falsely, whether spy or hero.

In any case, if I were Allers, it would be pretty damn easy for people to figure it out.

So... maybe I'll throw in a vote for Space Cowboy. No secret info here, of course, but I do need to vote for someone

I caught your hint. Did I change my vote? There is your answer.

As for who else, dusty voted for reed, but also hinted at an important role, though the hint was vague. That said, it would almost be too obvious to vote for reed and then eliminate him the very next night, but the obviousness of it might actually make it a good cover move for a spy. Who would expect the spy to do that?

We aren't quite as lacking in information this game as in the last game, but we do still have several players we don't know anything about. I'm not completely confident in my suspicion of dusty (because the spy is Catilina, obviously), simply because we lack so much information, but it's the best I can think of right now.

So from where I'm sitting, Dusty and Pela are unknown roles, Dragon seems to be Allers, who could be evil. I'm not sure how evil Allers works. maybe she can choose her own role. That was the case in one of the first games when I was a spy and chose Allers for my cover. Of course, the evil roles are not merely covers now.

All the rest, as far as I can remember, are cleared.

Catilina. Dude. Read the whole thread and take a hint.

Votes
Catilina - 1
Space Cowboy - 1

Crew
01] Space Cowboy
02] Dustyelf
03] Pelassarias
04] Dragontartare - voted
05] Sgtreed24 - Tali'Zorah vas Normandy
06] Romice - voted
07] Gervaise21
08] Fylimar - Agent Kaidan
09] Catilina

What was the hint?

Thanks dragontartare It's a possibility.

I'm still undecided on who to vote for