[Day/Night Game] Trouble on the Citadel - round "LE Part 2: Why Cerberus Is Right For You"

Hello, I'm back! Bloody awful weather over here. Not so much frosty the snowman as Noah's Ark although the BBC are suggesting that Frosty could make an appearance before the end of the night. It has been very mild for the last week so the change is a bit jarring and I have been explaining to the horses why they have to stay in overnight as they have been allowed the choice up to now. Plus grooming my itchy Thoroughbred and ferrying large amounts of hay to keep them occupied until morning.
-----

Okay, so back in character. I thought Aniken was meant to be good until he turned evil but that is neither here nor there as a different universe. Anyway, you seem to be so busy focussing on me that you are forgetting there are other people not yet identified and who must be quietly killing themselves laughing that you are ignoring them. I think I have given enough clues for now and am not obliged to reveal anything more, particularly as it may make me the target in the night.

First, sorry for being absent everyone. Holidays and what not.

Second, I know you casted your vote for gervaise, but I am curious about your suspicions of me. If it’s because I have yet to hint at my role, well, I will surely become the next target if I give one. Even though we’re killing it, I just believe my power is too important for the agents to know.

I never even hinted at Liara. Where did you get that from? Have you been drinking? Without my approval?  

Oh I'm not ignoring them.

I think the spies have figured out at this point who everyone is. So, keeping your roles oh so mysterious doesn't aid anyone.

We have 4 players who are oh so shrouded in mystery and I bet 3 or 2 of them are spies. One of their butts needs to be vote booted for sure this round.

Speaking of me not ignoring anyone. Pela and romice, do you have any insight you wish to share regarding your suspicions?

Speaking a bit from experience here if I were Liara, I would only come out of hiding for a spy, because here, you are dead pretty quickly, if you reveal yourself, so better make it count

Well... I feel like it’s important. Lol.

I gave it away anyway. I hadn’t realized a few pages back that addonniel literally propped up a list of who she believed was what. If I saw the previous conversation I would have just given it away anyway. I haven’t been paying much attention to this, but that’s my fault. I can understand people’s suspicions after that.

As far as my suspicions, I need to relurk this thread to see what I missed while I was gone.

Actually, I thought you might be Liara during the previous voting round when you sort of defended romice. I thought you're either invest who checked her or you're both evilz.

Happy Late Holidays all! I hope none of you guys were as sick as I was these past few days..

But, back to the game! I'm just going to make a list here of who I suspect and don't

Adonniel and gervaise - They might have hinted at a role but I haven't caught on so far. Possibly Javik and/or Kasumi. Nonetheless, I don't find them both suspicious on behalf of their reasonings/behavior so far. So yeah, I won't follow adonniel's vote this time .

Space- Seems like they're Diana to me. If not, they're a spy. But so far I'm not suspicious

flyimar- Hinted at a non-floating role that no one has counter claimed so I'm inclined to believe her.

Tittus- Also hinted at a confirmed role that no one has counter claimed, so I believe him.

Serza- At first I was suspicious, but after reading what adonniel believes what role this player is, I believe it as well.

Romice - I'm going to be honest, this player so far is a big mystery to me. Possible spy or floating role (If I had to guess, possibly Kaidan/Ashley or Wrex).

OG - Still pretty suspicious about this player, but I have to admit, it is mostly based on a feeling. Diana could actually be right about this...

Dad- Claim's to be a non-floating role, but the way they went about it is a little suspicious. Flyimar made a good point about how Dad could possibly be trying to lure the real Liara out. 

I'm going to put my vote towards Obsidian Gryphon for now because I definitely don't want to possibly vote off a powerful role. But, I do have to admit that flyimar makes a good point. We'll see if Dad is who they really claim to be, I suppose.

ETA: The more I think about it, the more I'm equally as suspicious of romice as I am of OG. I'll think about whether or not I'll switch.

A bit confused about the bolded parts to the point where I'm suspicious. You say all this while basically claiming the role. If you were truly apprehensive and if you were truly the role you say you are you wouldn't have outright say this while saying your role is too powerful for agents to know.  It just doesn't make sense the more I read this.

It seems to me you're more than likely luring Liara out. So you're either EC or an agent.

I do want to know what other players think of these comments. Am I reading too much into this?

Let's make it clear. No one is actually allowed to claim a role outright. People are allowed to hint at roles. If you are a role that the spies would like removed then you are likely to be wary about revealing too much. Currently several people are claiming important roles and only two of them have been pretty much confirmed by the action.

When I was Leliana I observed more than contributed because initially the information I had was not needed (the person I knew about was not a target) but when I had definite information about a spy I went on the offensive. So the person who is Liara is simply avoiding voting for anyone they know to be innocent and it is quite possible those people have not been in serious danger of being voted off up to now. The same is true when it comes to Liara being voted off. You only drop obvious hints as to your role if you are in serious danger of being voted off. The same is also true of other roles like Miranda, Kasumi and Garrus. However, once your special ability has been used then there seems no point in remaining secret, which explains why Miranda and Kasumi are willing to be higher profile now.

I would remind everyone that I was being attacked as suspicious the last game because I was keeping low profile when actually I was Miranda and trying to keep myself hidden until I had used my ability. I also made an erroneous comment about Miranda, suggesting they might have useful information. Of course they don't. Miranda only chooses to save someone but has no idea who that person is. Kasumi knows who Miranda is. The only other person who has information gained from their role thus far is Liara. As stated above, I'm assuming that Liara only knows two people who aren't spies but is keeping a low profile.

There are two aggressive roles that can retaliate against being voted off. Wrex can take someone with them but may take an innocent person by mistake. Legion can direct all votes to a particular person but, again, may target an innocent party by mistake. I was assuming that Legion could not be present but only if Tali was. As someone else pointed out, if Tali is not present then Legion could be and there would be no obvious voting pattern to show this. It is only Adonniel who has assumed that both roles are absent, although suggesting I had stated as much when I hadn't. So Legion could be the missing role instead of one of the other three, unless of course there are three spies.

Now I am curious about the role of Garrus. Someone previously hinted heavily at being that role, which seemed odd when that would make them a target for the spies. Someone else suggested a reason for their claim because apparently they were in fact Garrus so knew the first person was not genuine but did not make this clear at the time. What I find odd is that bearing in mind how obvious the first person was why didn't the spies target them instead of Miranda? Miranda had already used her ability so was no threat to the spies. Garrus could potentially still use their ability against them. So was the reason the person was left alone was that they were really a spy? The other person is apparently highly suspicious of me and yet did not make use of their ability against me last night. They are now complaining I have outed them and threatening to do so tonight, so if they are so confident about me, why not try and find another spy to vote off so they use their ability in a useful way? So are they really Garrus?

I am still suspicious of Dadi but once again everyone seems to assume that he can only be one role when he could be someone else that the spies would want to kill off at night to avoid having them around during the voting in the day. I am not changing my vote yet because I don't want to act in haste and run out of options to change. However, I would suggest that people examine very carefully the claim to be Garrus which seems to be being made by both Serza and Adonniel. I also wouldn't immediately assume that the false claim can be discounted as that of the Evil Clone.

I'm a bit rusty on people's foibles in ME but would someone more knowledgeable enlighten me please. Who likes tea?