[Day/Night Game] Trouble on the Citadel - round "LE Part 2: Why Cerberus Is Right For You"

I might not pick up as many clues as others, because I only know one third of ME. I don't know who most of the people, you guys are referring to, are. That evil clone is still a mystery, why is that thing on our side, if it's an evil clone? Is it like Peeves or Filch in the Harry Potter novels? You can spoil me, if you like.
So I try to go by behavior and reasoning here.
And there seems to be one role who is important, because she can investigate every night, and that is Liara. This game doesn't seem to have a protective role like Cullen in the other game, the protective roles here only can use their ability once per game and some of them have to guess right, before they can protect like Kasumi, so their ability might only come into play if they are lucky.

I 'm still suspicious, that dadi tries to flush out Liara. And yes, two people claiming the same role is suspicious too. Adonniel seems to be convinced, that Serza is the clone, if I interpret her post correctly, so she tries to convince us, she is Garrus? I 'm nor convinced here.

I like to give the question cave, adonniel, why so suspicious if gervaise? Just curious, I try to get a bigger perspective here.

The same question goes to romice.

Don't you think aggressively claiming to be Garrus is foolheardy if you are actually not, considering that the following morning you will wake up dead with a bullet in your head even if you somehow dodge the voting? How else will Garrus react to someone taking their role? If I were a spy I'd be claiming a floating role (which is actually something that was I assumed I am) and saying that space/serza/og are evil because those are also floating roles and they don't fit on my chart. Spies will not claim Legion or Garrus because this will make them dead.

Serza is an evil clone who want's one of the soldier roles or a spy faking evil clone.  That's why he hinted Garrus or maybe he was even hinting Ashley as Space pointed out.

Round 1 we had 4 voting bandwagons. Gerva, who is a highly active and analytical players, had stayed out of it until the very last 4th bandwagon which he started. So, when you're analyzing who had voted in parallel with who you can't even link any players to him. After I stated that this was suspicious and next round I intend to interrogate him for it - note intend means requires farther investigation not a hole in the head - he became extremely active and at the same time overly secretive.

Gerva says we aren't allowed to claim roles. No one is asking him to claim one. But, there is a huge difference between avoiding the question and making a vague hint. - We are allowed to make hints in this game. - In my opinion he's avoiding and being slippery rather than hinting and he's using the story 'we aren't allowed to claim roles' as means to justify his extremely dodgy answers. Gerva claims that revealing his role will endanger him. But also claims he isn't an important role. So lol, HOW is he in danger. We have Mira and Kas as good as revealed. These players cannot even be framed - real candidates to kick the bucket in danger of spies. Than we have Garrus and Liara the spies would want to target. IF (and I strongly doubt) Gerva isn't evil, then his death on the spy list is at the rock bottom - hey a floating role in a fight with another hero. How is he in danger from the spies soooo very much that he just must keep his identity very very secret.

After I've posted my list with my guesses based on the game info so far and po


I'm assuming 3 spies because Dragon said she wants a change from 2 and 4 spies will overpower 11 players too easily. Seems the most likely number.

1. spy
2. spy
3. spy
4. Lia
5. Mira - tit
6. Garrus
7. Kas - fyli
8. Dia - space
9. Clone - serz
10. EDI - proven smiles
11. Wrex - OG

I'm sitting here and wondering...

When exactly did I become an evil clone?

I guess I'll stop wondering whether anyone ever drowned in that massive lake. Because I'll drown someone in it myself!

Two questions.

Who's Aniken?
When have I hinted at Garrus?

I might go have to get Garrus' girl, who just by the way is my little sister, to explain this to you.

Ashley says she is cleaning her rifles in ME1 as default line when she has nothing new to say.

EDIT Just saying. This was merely for in game info, not assigning a role to anyone for them.

It's been a while but I definitely remember Ash saying she has to clean the rifles so doesnt have time to talk. Maybe later yeah. I doubt its because of Shep being mean to her though.

I'm really bad with clues and could be misreading. Is it possible Gerva is the clone? Or maybe a spy? I don't want to come across as defending anyone, just trying to piece all the clues together.

Oh, I was referencing...



...this.


Definitely no Anakin hints.

How am I dodgy?

Because I've literally been hinting at my character for the entire game and nobody bothered to pick up on the fine points of those hints?

In game the evil clone can't be alien, thats true. Here I suppose they could impersonate an alien though. But yeah either way seems like two different claims.

I totally missed the tea remark. There is no mention of tea in game that I remember so was probably literally that poster talking about getting some literal tea