[Day/Night Game] Trouble on the Citadel - round "LE Part 2: Why Cerberus Is Right For You"

Might as well double post and ask a question while we wait


Space and Gervaise, are you human?

I think it was just a reference to the mad prophet on Omega

Pela, did we decide that humans should be regarded as a Council race or not? pelassarias

Hope everything's alright,pela  Speaking about health scare's this coronavirus has really created a pandemonium here...But i'm guessing that is the case in everyone's country.
No,i am not!

I thought humans became a council race as soon as they got a councilor?

Edit: pela posted before I refreshed the page. Obviously I agree

It would be helpful if a few more people gave their view on who they think was the protector overnight as there seems a difference of opinion on how to interpret the narrative.

This is important because if Dadi didn't protect me overnight then there is no actual proof he is Charr. As Dragon pointed out after he "saved" me from the tie-breaker, up to then there had seemed no evidence of Charr being in the game. So if the spies had realised this, then one of them could immitate Charr safely knowing they would not be found out until it was too late to do anything about it. However, if Dadi is Charr, then since I am a hero so is he and thus it narrows down the possibilities for the spies.

As I thought the narrative pointed towards Charr saving me (even though there are problems with this), this would leave the choice of spies between Seven, Dragon, Space and Hero.

Seven is a council race and says that technically they can use biotics even though it is not in the character description. So likely one of the Asari or Oriana (who I assume can use biotics like her sister - correct me if I am wrong). However, as Oriana gives blanket protection, if she is in the game and good then I'd have thought she would have used it by now. There is nothing in the narative to suggest that Oriana was the saviour last night so I am ruling out that role for the present.

Dragon is a council race and can definitely use biotics. This means she is profiling similar roles to Seven, plus one other.

Space is familiar with the Citadel and has not yet answered Dragon's question about whether he is human or not. This could be an oversight on his part or possibly he knows his answer would be too revealing, so has been waiting to see what other people say first.

Hero is male and not human, which narrows him down to just 3 roles, two of which are protection roles but not guaranteed good, which is why it is vital to establish who was responsible for saving the hero in the night.

I totally missed Dragons question. Thanks Gervaise.

I’m not human.

Not yet. I'll be updating my notes this evening now that we have more clues, though. I'll cast an initial vote at that time.

One think occurs to me, Gervaise might not have been the one attacked. That would mean there is another protector out there, right?

First night is hit or miss, I tend to hoard my powers until I think they're most useful, in which case is kinda good for us this round because we are running out of heroes. If I use them first night, others might also use theirs at the same time, it kinda gets wasted if we are all doing the same time.
Just some food for thought.

interesting indeed

Edit:

We are all probably reading too much into it. Here’s the deal. I only
Know that I can protect Gervaise. It’s debatable if Gevaise was targeted.

Whoever has a protection role 100% has a better understanding, on their side, how things went.

IF someone has a protection role and they used it for someone other than Gervaise or myself - well, then, done deal. But that’s up to them.

If they protected myself, then they’d know that I was targeted, which means I’m innocent, which makes Gervaise innocent.

If they protected Gervaise, it doesn’t count for my innocence, but it sure does count for Gervaise. From that, how would I know Gervaise is innocent? I know I had a lucky guess from last game, but it’d be especially risky for me to *pretend* to be a role and simultaneously declare my love in the same round. And let’s just say Gervaise is evil - that would mean that I am evil, which means someone other than myself DEFINITELY used their ability. No one has even made any hint to say as such.
So, as I was saying, if a player protected someone last night, it’s completely up to them to vote accordingly- even if they were Kal, they wouldn’t have anything to lose as the game is cutting pretty short...

The fact that no one has spoken up makes me think otherwise. Gervaise is now in danger.

So.... Dragon, Space, Seven, and Hero are making me think right now.... and I trust none of them

To be honest, the moment I saw in the narrative that Glyph was in the game I thought it was probably Space as he was the only person who categorically stated he knew the Citadel well. (which Glyph does in the Citadel DLC). Then Space saying he was not human pretty much clinched it as the only people familiar with the Citadel are human apart from Glyph. I certainly wouldn't think he was either Aria or Aethyta as I wouldn't say either of them know the Citadel "well". So unless it becomes apparent that someone is unable to vote this round, that would suggest Space is good Glyph.

Suggesting Space is either Aria or Aethyta also presents something of a problem to me since I thought they were two of the roles you were most likely to be, Dragon. Which is why I said it would be bad news for us if you are evil as it would rebound on us if we tried to vote you off. There is one other role you could be, so in view of what you said regarding Space, I am going with that.

I agree with your probable roles for Hero; Kal'Reager; Kirrahe or Niftu Cal.

I also agree with the likely role for Seven in view of the hints she has been giving.

I'm going to have to trust Dadi because the narrative sounded to me like he saved me and the trouble is now that if someone votes for him it could be because they know they were doing the protecting last night or it could be a spy capitalising on the situation.