[Day/Night Game] Trouble on the Citadel - round "LE Part 2: Why Cerberus Is Right For You"

😬 ouch

.

I've got wired internet! I decided to bet on my modem itself being the problem and went to get a new one from my ISP. I was partially right. Unfortunately, my router's WAN port also appears to be dead. The pain of no wifi is real

Can a storm take out connected ethernet ports on a modem and a router? Is that a thing??



Anyway, as for the game, I thought someone did ask Hero a question? Hero went through and liked a bunch of my posts earlier today, so maybe we'll hear from him soon.

Editing later to add clue summary again.

I would love to hear from hero too, unless he's a spy and wishes to spin lies

*steals popcorn*

I asked Hero if he was human and he answered a couple of pages back that he wasn't. Day 1 he said he was male. Hence my assumption that he was either Kal'Reager, Kirrahe or Niftu Cal. It seemed unlikely that he lied on Day 1, so that is why I immediately ruled him out for Glyph, although thinking about it, telling the truth would have been a dead give away.

I still maintain that the only person who could be Glyph, based on the answers given, is Space.   However, I suppose the second most likely candidate would be Hero.   Hence Space saying that I had made false assumptions in my reasoning and people might have wanted to conceal their identity.   Of course there is no guarantee that Glyph is good regardless of who has the role.

Do I need to be indoctrinated for you to never say that word again? 

Anyway, first-round voting behavior isn't enough for me, especially since it was just Space putting Dragon in a huge tiebreaker. Also, Dragon has the potential to sway the votes anyway - it'd be an extremely smart move on their part to feint us like that. 

Dragon is still high-risk to me due to her potential power. Seven's potential power is not a definite win for the spies, unlike Dragon's. All of her potential roles spells bad news for us. 

I guess we'll see... 

I'm glad someone else sees it!

However, Aria can duplicate any role either on the Citadel, in previous games or in Wolf Hunt, where there is a vote-swaying role. This is why it is such a powerful role and why I understand Dadi's fears concerning it. It is also why I thought, instead of worrying about what you could do, it might be more productive to see if there was any evidence to suggest there was no need for heroes to fear her.



Here is the problem. If Dragon is Aria then she can re-direct the votes to a hero regardless of whether we vote for her or not. So it makes sense to try and identify her partner. Since you would agree that can't be Seven and you seem convinced of her innocence, why didn't you join me in voting for Space? He would be the most likely spy partner for Dragon (based off your logic) and if Seven had swapped to me as well then we would have at least have had a tie-breaker with the potential for a spy to be eliminated. Essentially if both spies survive this round we are sunk regardless of whether Aria is in the game or not, particularly if Glphy is evil and so can block dangerous night roles that could potentially take one of them out.



Okay, the way I see it is this. By voting for Hero, Dragon had just broken the tie-breaker. So why would Dragon do this as a spy and vote for the same person as her fellow spy, then her fellow spy swap out and put her in the tie-breaker, particularly if it risked her having to use up her ability in the first round (based off the idea Dragon is Aria)?

Bear in mind also that Dragon is insisting she isn't Aria and Space was hinting at not being Glyph.   In which case, what role is Space?   He could be Aria based off his hints that he is familiar with the Citadel and not human.  So why aren't you worried about him?

Sadly not, though I'd like to be. The thing is he hardly ever gets it wrong but I admit I often do. Which is why I'd really appreciate feedback on my little theories.

I'm still puzzled why everyone avoided joining me in voting for Space seeing as he could also be a potentially dangerous role. Even if the person who is Glyph invited him to a party last night, that wouldn't have stopped his partner from acting. If he was the person doing the protecting, he hasn't been that explicit about it, or indicated he trusts the person he protected, and the potential victim of the spies would not know it was him. Alternatively, the protector role protected Space from the spies, in which case it might have been helpful for them to hint as much by saying they had confidence in his innocence. Yet everyone has been silent on the subject, so appearing to confirm that it was Charr who did the protecting.

I voted for Space to test out my theory about him being on team spy and at present I still think he is, just not sure about his partner, who could be anyone who refused to vote for him.