[Day/Night Game] Trouble on the Citadel - round "LE Part 2: Why Cerberus Is Right For You"

I'm a bit rusty on people's foibles in ME but would someone more knowledgeable enlighten me please. Who likes tea?

Than what's all this talk from Gerva about being oh so unsure about who Garrus is. Unlike me, wouldn't he know the difference between Ashley claim and Garrus claim?

Why not say, 'I think Serza was hinting at Ahsley.' Rather than casting suspicion on me by saying there is a duplicate roles claim if there actually isn't one. Unless Serza did claim Garrus and now backpedaling. 

In ME 1 Ashley says to me that she doesn't have time to talk. Never heard the rifles line from her. But, my renegade Shep is mean to her. Maybe later in the game?

gervaise21

Actually, this round I find Pela and romice a lot more suspicious than OG based on the fact that I know zero about them.

OG I am giving the benefit of the doubt, but he is claiming a floating role, a convenient one that would persuade people not to vote them. I cannot trust floating roles in general, unless like fylimar proof appeared. It is my preference to test the validity of floating than garrus/lia/mer. Of course player behaviour affects this.

Actually, I do find the manner in which dad defends himself strange, but last round you cast suspicion on me that a few players seem to be following my votes eagerly. I might be confusing him with someone else but dad stated how he also thinks it's suspicious. So, if he found it suspicious than he could have investigated me. Then again, telling me that I'm innocent is more likely to raise my suspicions because it's difficult to contradict my role claim, and it isn't exactly useful to me to narrow down the suspects because I know I'm innocent.

Mind you, I finally noticed your Sherlock clue from voting 1, so if you are a Clone you might be after Liara yourself and I have no idea which side you will join. I also have reasons to suspect you might believe dad but want their role.

However, while I do not fully trust EC due to their undecided alignment, in this game I'm inclined to believe your role claim to be genuine since it's a new role and I feel it would be included in the game.

So, I will be changing a vote from you towards Pela, romice or most likely Serza.

Yea, idk what's with casting suspicion of fyli or Titt. They're the only ones I don't suspect.

____


I'm most inclined to vote Serza based on a few oddball moments.

For example, at the start of the game I complained during the night time how my Shepard can't hit the blasted evil toasters with any other weapons except for the pistols. And then the night story Dragon put up said that assassins used pistols (and Dragon said in later post that assassins asked her to use this weapon intentionally). This sounds like some kind of a goofball idea to frame me. Guess who named himself the Orlesiest Grinch in our DA day/night game to frame YOU?

This framing business sounds like Serza type of joke/shenanigans.

I'm kinda thinking to change from you to Serza and I most likely will.

This conversation it spiraling into repetitive and pointless.

"DID NOT!"

"DID TOO!"

I've already stated my reasons for my suspicions many times over and I won't type them up again.

I will not waste time convincing anyone to vote whoever I find suspicious. I have other ways of finding out who is who.

You know it may take a while for the penny to drop with me but I think I deserve an A* for effort.

Don't have to be a Walt Whitman buff but just a Robin Williams fan and familiar with Dead Poet's Society:

O Captain! my Captain! our fearful trip is done,
The ship has weather’d every rack, the prize we sought is won.

Serza, you definitely are the biggest nerd I am so sorry that I misinterpreted your clue and so made Adonniel suspicious of you. It is true you could still be a clever spy but I really can't bring myself to vote for someone who puts that much effort into their clues.

(Adonniel: In case you haven't discovered this yet in game, Ashley is a big poetry fan, particularly Walt Whitman. In ME3 you can buy her a book as a present for her when she is sick in hospital. She is also religious and prays a lot, which is why I mentioned that in connection with Dadi)

Since Ashley will never be alive after game 1 in my playthroughs (I don't like her and I like Kaidan, so yeah...), I probably would never learn about her Whitman love, even if I make it to ME 3 one day.
But I did get the other hints from Serza after a while.

I still don't get dadi though, so for now, I see no reason to change the Vite.

And yes,I get it, adonniel us Garrus

Shouting no I didn't?

I am pointing at the fact that you are - possibly intentionally - ignoring my claims and trying to smear my good name here.

Yet every one of those claims has been nullified.

And you persist.


You are also mistaken in my intent to remove Fylimar. I have randomly voted for her first round - and I have explained that at length - but since changed my mind. She and Gervaise are both reliable sources of information and good allies.

But we did get defensive too. I all but spilled my role to not get voted off , so I know, how it is, if you have a suspicion, but I really don't see, how Serzas behavior is different from me or Tittus for example

That is right, but we are different kind of people.
And you two had  quite the go, emotions flying high at the moment and that might be a reason for not looking for other suspects too.

I don't think, either of you two is a spy anymore. I had you both on my suspect list for a while, but you both seem to be the real deal

To be honest, I do not have a target group, I'm still not convinced of dadis innocence, but I don't see a group here.

Yea right, you tore the thread apart in round 2 voting at Skyhold and argued with everyone.

Unless that's what you call quiet.

You don't even have a bandwagon this turn just my vote with which nobody is agreeing. Last round nobody was touching you with a ten foot pole. Pela voted you once but nobody joined that either and you behaved by counter voting her immediately. That was that.

It seems odd in itself. fyli, tit, OD, smiles - all gathered wagons on them in seconds. You're oh so special...

Not to mention once again you haven't responded with your ideas as to who you think the bad guys are. I expect something more from a player who tends to keep excel charts.

Let's pretend believed your claim that you're Ashley.

Who in your opinion is evil then?

No theories?