inherit
∯ Oh Loredy...
455
0
31,186
gervaise21
13,101
August 2016
gervaise21
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
|
Post by gervaise21 on Aug 16, 2023 19:27:21 GMT
I was watching a You Tube today about the statue in the Black Hills that is meant to honour Crazy Horse and how it has still not been finished some 100 years or so after it was originally planned and this got me thinking again about that big statue of a wolf overlooking the Exalted Plains. I discussed this before but things are a big slow on the news front for DA:D, so what the hell, perhaps with nothing else to discuss people might like to ponder this one. When exactly was it carved and by whom? What is it meant to represent? Now you would imagine the answer to the second question would be Fen'Harel and it was carved by his supporters. Except that would have to mean he was always known as a Wolf, just not the Dread Wolf, because I can hardly see the Evanuris allowing a stonking big statue to be carved of their enemy out in the open, unless it was intended to scare their subjects. This comment also applies to the statue at the entrance to the Temple of Mythal. It was clearly on guard and in the Deep Roads it would seem he was shown as some sort of guardian to Mythal. Whilst it is possible he may have started the rebellion with her approval before her death, hence the spirits of the Well of Sorrow knowing the password, it is equally possible that there was some sort contact between Fen'Harel, or his followers, and the sentinels and that is how Abelas knew he was not responsible for her death. Either that or Abelas felt that owing to the nature of the relationship, it was impossible for him to have betrayed her. This leads me back to the idea that Solas was originally an Arcane Warrior as he states that in ancient times they acted as bodyguards to the nobility and that no one doubted their integrity and trustworthiness. It is possible they were likened to wolves because the subordinate wolves are always utterly loyal and protective of the Alpha male and female. If this was the case, it would have created shock waves that one of them, possibly their leader, had rebelled against the Evanuris. Hence him now being known as the Dread Wolf. In which case, perhaps the wolf statue wasn't meant to depict Fen'Harel but the Arcane Warriors generally and may be the area of the Exalted Plains was where they had their stronghold and trained for the task. Cillian, the Arcane Warrior from DAMP, was said by WoT2 to have obtained his knowledge from an ancient shrine dedicated to the Arcane Warriors and that he had spent many years secluded there but returned to civilisation when he saw the Breach in order to help. So, the shrine had to be somewhere in the south and since his clan frequented the area of the Dales, it makes sense that he would have discovered the shrine somewhere near the giant wolf statue. I think the reason the Emerald Knights had wolf guardians is that they had probably seen ancient depictions of elves with wolves at their side, which were symbolic of the relationship between the nobility and the arcane warriors, but the Emerald Knights concluded wrongly that they were seeing actual wolves. It may also be related to this half remembered history of Fen'Harel as an arcane warrior that the Dalish always place a statue of Fen'Harel at the edge of their camp to ward off evil spirits. Otherwise, it does seem odd that they hope he will protect them when their own folklore claims he doesn't care about them or their fate, particularly as in DAI the offerings found near shrines to him are more to appease him into leaving them alone. Incidentally, I think it highly unlikely that the wolf statues, large and small, date to a later period but the big one on the mountain seems the most unlikely. The Dales was only around for some 250 odd years before it was destroyed and I think the ex-slaves would have had more important things to concentrate their efforts on than carving a giant wolf statue on top of a mountain. Anyway, those are a few of my thoughts on the subject. Anyone else want to weigh in?
|
|
inherit
1398
0
4,633
Absafraginlootly
"Abso-fraggin-lutely!" ~ Captain John Sheridan and Satai Delenn
1,666
September 2016
absafraginlootly
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Mass Effect Andromeda, SWTOR
|
Post by Absafraginlootly on Aug 17, 2023 0:08:29 GMT
Well if all the personal guard or soldiers/army of the evanuris were known as (and possibly would shapeshift into) wolves then that would certainly explain the sheer volume of wolf statues. If they were all fen'harel then that would make him look like a very popular deity going by dai.
|
|
inherit
∯ Oh Loredy...
455
0
31,186
gervaise21
13,101
August 2016
gervaise21
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
|
Post by gervaise21 on Aug 17, 2023 8:04:15 GMT
If they were all fen'harel then that would make him look like a very popular deity going by dai. That is another problem I had with the statues. It didn't make sense there would be so many dedicated to him. I also don't see why the later Emerald Knights, or the other inhabitants of the Dales, would spend so much of their time carving wolf statues when they had the real Knights and their wolves to watch over them. Besides, at least one of the statues was impervious to water erosion and the others were out in the open and yet still apparently pristine, so it would seem they were created to include some sort of preservative magic unknown to the modern elves. I feel this question isn't just idle speculation but could be relevant to the next game, which is after all entitled Dreadwolf. In Tevinter Nights, Rasaan was adamant that Solas was not his "true name", whatever he might have implied to the Inquisitor. She also seemed to think that discovering his true name was important enough to spend time and resources looking for it. I know the Qun attach an importance to names as signifying what your role in life might be but I think it goes beyond that. Abelas indicated that he had changed his name more than once, first on entering Mythal's service and then on her death, so clearly there was some sort of similarity in the use of names in elven culture as there is in the Qun. I also seem to recall that if we allow the sentinels to depart in peace, Solas says to Abelas that he hopes he finds a new name (and purpose), which suggests it was common practice. Did Rasaan reach her assumption based on research and information she received back on the sentinels from their spies or from direct knowledge of elven culture in ancient times because of Kossith link to it? I suspect the latter, even if the link is Koslun and the knowledge he acquired on his travels before formalising his philosophy and writing his Tome. This being the case, Solas was a name that Rasaan claims he took for himself as a "self-styled martyr". Now the true meaning of martyr in the Christian faith is not that of a sacrificial victim but one bearing witness to enduring faith. In Celtic Christianity there were red martyrs, who were the ones who died bearing witness but also white martyrs who bore witness by devoting their entire life to service of the faith and living out the gospel. So what do you suppose Rasaan meant by the word? Whether she is right or not, it is clear from Abelas that it is entirely possible that Solas had a different name before he entered Mythal's service. Was that name "Solas", which became "the Wolf" and then "the Dread Wolf", or is Rasaan correct and he had another name before Solas? Knowing what role he actually performed in serving Mythal might go some way in understanding his identity at that time and thus which name belonged to which period. Nevertheless, I think this idea of his true name could be important going forward or why introduce the concept at all in TN?
|
|
xerrai
N3
Posts: 847 Likes: 1,177
inherit
1451
0
1,177
xerrai
847
September 2016
xerrai
|
Post by xerrai on Aug 18, 2023 3:28:56 GMT
If they were all fen'harel then that would make him look like a very popular deity going by dai. That is another problem I had with the statues. It didn't make sense there would be so many dedicated to him. I also don't see why the later Emerald Knights, or the other inhabitants of the Dales, would spend so much of their time carving wolf statues when they had the real Knights and their wolves to watch over them. Besides, at least one of the statues was impervious to water erosion and the others were out in the open and yet still apparently pristine, so it would seem they were created to include some sort of preservative magic unknown to the modern elves. [...] Gotta be honest, I don't like making theories about areas in the Dales because I have such a hard determining what was part of the Dalish Kingdom and what was leftover from Arlathan. But if we go with your idea that the area was one of Solas's territories or areas of influence, have we completely discounted the idea that the simple reason behind the wolves' more subdued appearance is just because people viewed it barely any different than the other animal statues used to represent an evanuris? There is nothing particularly grand about the various hart or owl statues we see all over the place. It's just the quantity on slight variance of wolf statues that we take interest in. But even the variance in wolf styles isn't all that unprecedented since Mythal has both the dragon and dragon-lady statues for herself. But I digress. Even if the "Dread Wolf" moniker came into being later, that may not have mattered to any followers who may have inhabited the region and chose to depict his more 'benign' iconography since Solas seems to be big on the "I am no god" messaging. The quantity (and magical preservation) of the statues may have even been a way to compensate for how Solas may not have had the same amount of 'grand' temples like the other evanuris did.
|
|
inherit
∯ Oh Loredy...
455
0
31,186
gervaise21
13,101
August 2016
gervaise21
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
|
Post by gervaise21 on Aug 18, 2023 7:49:30 GMT
Even if the "Dread Wolf" moniker came into being later, that may not have mattered to any followers who may have inhabited the region and chose to depict his more 'benign' iconography since Solas seems to be big on the "I am no god" messaging As I've said, I don't feel the statues date from after his rebellion against the Evanuris as it was too obvious an identifier of his supporters and there was no way of defending such a large area from a concerted attack by their enemies. By contrast, Fen'Harel's sanctuary was only accessible by eluvian, the surrounding land being covered in a noxious plant that would deter people from approaching the area, so I imagine that all their hideouts would be similarly protected, particularly as not all those fleeing the Evanuris would be capable of fighting. However, it is entirely possible that he had his own faction supporting him prior to his rebellion, whilst he was supporting Mythal. The fact that this area was relatively close to her major Temple in Thedas and it was once surrounded by a large city, would make the large number of wolf statues to the north understandable. Fen'Harel's statue was placed as though guarding her Temple, his statue in the Deep Roads suggested he was regarded as guarding/supporting Mythal, so it follows that both his supporters and hers might carve wolf statues as symbolic guardians of an area largely dedicated to Mythal. This tradition then found its way into Dalish lore in the placing of Fen'Harel's statue on the edge of camp, facing outward, to guard against evil spirits, which after all probably was what Fen'Harel specialised in, given his knowledge of the spirit world and the fact that there was no Veil to prevent their movement. So that would explain the statues but not why he is always depicted as a wolf unless that is related, as I suggest above, to the behaviour of wolves. So it is symbolic of his loyalty to Mythal and to the People. It is strange though that he is never depicted in elven form, not even when placed alongside the other gods. Is it possible that he never appeared among the people except in his wolf form or with his face/head concealed? It is noticeable that the picture in his sanctuary shows him with a wolf headdress that conceals much of his face and even his self portrait has him cloaked and hooded so that it is difficult to see his elven form. The Evanuris also warn of the "many forms of Fen'Harel", saying the one they should be most wary of is the humble wanderer whose only aim seems to be to impart wisdom. This latter "form" is of course the one we are familiar with. Is this the true person though? Could discovering his original identity be key to either stopping him or saving him from himself? This is why I feel the identity and purpose of those wolf statues could turn out to be important, if only in hindsight. I also still can't shake the idea that his commendation of the Arcane Warriors was significant and may indicate some sort of connection with them. They guarded the nobility, he guarded Mythal, so there is a similarity there. Also, we should not forget the elven folktale of a "trickster warrior who fought against tyrants". That is clearly a half remembered story of his rebellion, so it is possible that the warrior title should have been arcane warrior. As I said in my previous post, I think that if the arcane warriors, at least those in Mythal's service, were known as wolves, with Solas, as their chief, being the Wolf, then it makes sense that after his rebellion the other Evanuris would call him the Dread Wolf. Incidentally, Felassan always struck me as a pretty capable fighter, PW said his vallaslin were likely those of Mythal and he had a definite connection with Fen'Harel, so may be he was originally an arcane warrior in Mythal's service and Fen'Harel was his leader even then.
|
|
xerrai
N3
Posts: 847 Likes: 1,177
inherit
1451
0
1,177
xerrai
847
September 2016
xerrai
|
Post by xerrai on Aug 20, 2023 15:04:10 GMT
Even if the "Dread Wolf" moniker came into being later, that may not have mattered to any followers who may have inhabited the region and chose to depict his more 'benign' iconography since Solas seems to be big on the "I am no god" messaging [...] So that would explain the statues but not why he is always depicted as a wolf unless that is related, as I suggest above, to the behaviour of wolves. So it is symbolic of his loyalty to Mythal and to the People. It is strange though that he is never depicted in elven form, not even when placed alongside the other gods. Is it possible that he never appeared among the people except in his wolf form or with his face/head concealed? It is noticeable that the picture in his sanctuary shows him with a wolf headdress that conceals much of his face and even his self portrait has him cloaked and hooded so that it is difficult to see his elven form. The Evanuris also warn of the "many forms of Fen'Harel", saying the one they should be most wary of is the humble wanderer whose only aim seems to be to impart wisdom. This latter "form" is of course the one we are familiar with. Is this the true person though? Could discovering his original identity be key to either stopping him or saving him from himself? This is why I feel the identity and purpose of those wolf statues could turn out to be important, if only in hindsight. [...] I think the Qunari may be onto something when looking into the idea of Solas's prior identity or identities. Whatever previous names he held will doubtlessly give us more knowledge of him. That said, I am not so sure he ever had a 'true' name to begin when he first 'manifested' as the 'elves-were-once-spirits' theory would typically suggest. He could have been something closer to a Fade Rifter or whatever the Lady of the Forest had going on (but wolf-themed?). Alternatively, he could have been a spirit who took possession of a wolf and lead a pack, just as the terror demon in the Hinterlands did in DAI, and lead the pack as a sort of unofficial guardian. And I can see Mythal controlling or making a deal with any of them.
|
|
inherit
∯ Oh Loredy...
455
0
31,186
gervaise21
13,101
August 2016
gervaise21
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
|
Post by gervaise21 on Aug 20, 2023 18:08:34 GMT
He could have been something closer to a Fade Rifter or whatever the Lady of the Forest had going on (but wolf-themed?). Ah yes, the Lady. I wonder if they are ever going to return that idea. She stated she was not a spirit summoned from the Fade by Zathrian but was part of the land. As a result of discovering the truth behind his longevity, the other Keepers even called his action a crime against nature. It was curious that her alter ego was a wolf though. Was that the nature of Zathrian's spell or something else? If he chose the wolf form for her binding, that would be curious in itself. There is also the whole business of werewolves generally in Ferelden and heroes who were connected with them, plus that odd story we discover about Ameridan and his companion fighting a Fell wolf which had glowing eyes of eldritch fire and the Fade in every breath. That sure sounds familiar. Curious also that it would appear to have been defeated by destroying an idol of Fade touched stone. It seems to me that it was possibly a demon that was mimicking the appearance of Fen'Harel and possibly the idol was in fact a statue of Fen'Harel, which somehow gave the demon its invulnerability. Once again, though, we have this strong link between wolves, spirits and the southern part of Thedas where Mythal had her domain and statues to wolves/Fen'Harel abound. Surely they didn't introduce all these ideas just as red herrings?
|
|
xerrai
N3
Posts: 847 Likes: 1,177
inherit
1451
0
1,177
xerrai
847
September 2016
xerrai
|
Post by xerrai on Aug 21, 2023 1:13:22 GMT
He could have been something closer to a Fade Rifter or whatever the Lady of the Forest had going on (but wolf-themed?). Ah yes, the Lady. I wonder if they are ever going to return that idea. She stated she was not a spirit summoned from the Fade by Zathrian but was part of the land. As a result of discovering the truth behind his longevity, the other Keepers even called his action a crime against nature. It was curious that her alter ego was a wolf though. Was that the nature of Zathrian's spell or something else? If he chose the wolf form for her binding, that would be curious in itself. There is also the whole business of werewolves generally in Ferelden and heroes who were connected with them, plus that odd story we discover about Ameridan and his companion fighting a Fell wolf which had glowing eyes of eldritch fire and the Fade in every breath. That sure sounds familiar. Curious also that it would appear to have been defeated by destroying an idol of Fade touched stone. It seems to me that it was possibly a demon that was mimicking the appearance of Fen'Harel and possibly the idol was in fact a statue of Fen'Harel, which somehow gave the demon its invulnerability. Once again, though, we have this strong link between wolves, spirits and the southern part of Thedas where Mythal had her domain and statues to wolves/Fen'Harel abound. Surely they didn't introduce all these ideas just as red herrings? The connections arguably gets a itty bitty deeper when you consider that mabari, Witherfang, and blight wolves have a game move conspicuously named " Dread howl" in DAO. I'm just not sure if I am reading too much into things or what it would mean if those connections were being made. But that is an odd amount of connections, all things considered. I've also been looking into that "tevinter artifact" in the magi origin that looks suspiciously like a Fen'Harel statue. Dog-like creatures are a peculiar choice for something of tevinter origin, but I suppose it could be a coincidence. Or were certain Fen'Harel statues always capable of amplifying magic?
|
|
Beerfish
N7
Little Pumpkin
Games: Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, KOTOR, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Mass Effect Andromeda, Anthem, Mass Effect Legendary Edition
Origin: Beerfish
XBL Gamertag: Beerfish77
Posts: 15,192 Likes: 36,401
inherit
Little Pumpkin
314
0
36,401
Beerfish
15,192
August 2016
beerfish
https://bsn.boards.net/user/314/personal
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, KOTOR, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Mass Effect Andromeda, Anthem, Mass Effect Legendary Edition
Beerfish
Beerfish77
|
Post by Beerfish on Aug 21, 2023 2:12:01 GMT
|
|
inherit
∯ Oh Loredy...
455
0
31,186
gervaise21
13,101
August 2016
gervaise21
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
|
Post by gervaise21 on Aug 21, 2023 8:08:22 GMT
I've also been looking into that "tevinter artifact" in the magi origin that looks suspiciously like a Fen'Harel statue. Dog-like creatures are a peculiar choice for something of tevinter origin, but I suppose it could be a coincidence. Well according to Fenris it was Tevinter that originally bred the mabari, so that could account for it. (To be honest I don't remember this statue). I wonder how far back that was in their history, though. Did it pre-date the Imperium, which would point to it perhaps being part of the Dreamer period when they may well have been influenced by what they discovered in elven ruins or even elves themselves, since I'm still convinced the Dreamers were in fact elf bloodied children and the elf parents were the ones who introduced many ideas into the northern barbarian tribes and taught them new forms of magic, including blood magic. Hence the similarity to elvhenan in the political and religious hierarchy that developed which were totally different to those found in the southern barbarians. Whilst on the subject of statues in DAO, I came across an entry about an elven statue you obtain early on from one of the humans, presumably if you either kill or threaten them as I don't recall ever receiving this: "A small stone statue of a woman with antlers like a halla, with the moon under her right foot, and two hares beside her. The base of the statue is covered in strange writing." Do you remember that mural in Skyhold with the figure of an antlered female being hugged/crushed by a bear? I initially assumed the pale antlered figure was that of Ghilan'nain. If that is the case, then the statue with the antlered woman stamping on the moon could be referring to her rebelling against or even killing Mythal (who is associated with the moon). The hare is the symbol of Andruil but why two hares? Servants of Andruil who were working with Ghilan'nain? However, looking at the Skyhold mural again, it is possible the "bear" figure is actually that of a wolf with its ears covered by its cloak. That would fit with other images of Fen'Harel. In which case could it reflect his anger with Ghilan'nain for what she did to Mythal? Notice there is a crescent moon shown over the figure's head, perhaps indicative of his loyalty to the moon. The alternative explanation that I came up with after reading Horror of Hormack was that the bear/wolf figure isn't attacking the antlered female but rather embracing her, comforting her for what has been done to her by another, whilst expressing their anger at the one who did this to her. However, my discovery of that entry from DAO about the antlered statue treading on the moon makes this seem less likely. Still, it is another instance of something introduced right back at the beginning of DAO that reappeared in DAI, so I feel it has to be significant.
|
|
dayze
N2
Posts: 187 Likes: 81
inherit
1270
0
81
dayze
187
August 2016
dayze
|
Post by dayze on Aug 21, 2023 11:18:11 GMT
I think the dog-like statue is the same model they used for "Fen'Harel" in the dalish camp in DAO. It may have been an attempt at a Fen'Harel reference of some kind.
That being said it was strangely dog-like for something that was supposed to represent a wolf....even in the camp.
As for the "bear mural" it does seem to be similar but possibly in reverse to Solas's look when he is shown in the mural removing the vallaslin.
Solas was a man/elf wearing the mask of a wolf whereas this is a bear wearing "elven" clothing? The markings on the bears' pants remind me of the markings on Solas's sleeves. The bear has stars on it's snout vs Solas's having the "stars" on his cloak....it also seems to be breathing fire, fade fire ala the Wolf Demon and the Archdemon?
There's a picture of Solas standing in front of the dread wolf where it has seven eyes and a big "sun" where the pituitary gland would be. Might be something similar going on here with the stars and eye of the bear.
The halla woman seems to be stopping the bear like Flemeth(white haired elf, staff seems to have two "heads", one resembling her look from DA2 and the one below it a dragon) is stopping the dread wolf in the mural with Solas/Dread Wolf/The Idol.
Only via her embrace versus using an object, could this a be a reference to the blight in some way? What with the pure black background....though combined with the moon/star imagery could just be a reference to night/lycanthropy. Or I suppose "bear-thropy" in this instance.
Though considering the bear might be something like that giant wolf that got fought, and if they both breath fade-fire/spirit fire like the archdemon, I have to wonder how many variations of that type of creature there might be. There is an arch demon for every god, does that mean there is an archdemon-wolf and archdemon-bear for every god?
|
|
inherit
∯ Oh Loredy...
455
0
31,186
gervaise21
13,101
August 2016
gervaise21
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
|
Post by gervaise21 on Aug 21, 2023 18:11:16 GMT
it also seems to be breathing fire, fade fire ala the Wolf Demon and the Archdemon? Only via her embrace versus using an object, could this a be a reference to the blight in some way? Well in the Last Flight it is said that the Arch-demon's breath was using magic that wasn't drawn from the Fade but somewhere else. I've tended to assume that meant the Void, as Banal'han, the "Place of Nothing", is where the Dalish believe the Blight originated. I assume this comes from a genuinely remembered ancient piece of lore as the ancient elves' story of Andruil in the ToM associates the Void with the Forgotten Ones and also believe they are associated with corruption and pestilence; hence Andruil returning with plague that attacks her land, which sounds very like the Blight. However, the Wolf Demon in Ameridan's tale is definitely said to breath Fade fire, so I think that is something different from the Arch-demon. If the colour of the flames being breathed by the bear/wolf are accurate in colour, that suggests Veil fire such as we ignite in DAI rather than the Void fire of the Arch-demon. It would be helpful if we knew exactly who painted the picture. It is not in the style of most of Solas' other murals but artists can change and develop their style over time. Otherwise, who is the anonymous artist? This might be helpful in establishing who exactly the horned figure is. We are assuming Ghilan'nain, although she is depicted in the mosaics riding a halla but not antlered herself. However, there is the Dalish story of Andruil transforming her into a halla, which could be a residual memory of Ghilan'nain having antlers. Mythal is shown in statues with wings for arms, so possibly having non-elven appendages was something the gods did with their appearance or it was the sculpture/artist's symbolic way of showing which animal they were associated with. Does it have anything to do with that strange rhyme in the Darvarad? One sees the hunter, one flees from it, one hunts it in turn, one outwits them all. This indicated the order in which to light the veil fire lamps in front of different statues: Owl, halla, dragon, wolf. The only one from the rhyme that does not have a statue is the "hunter", whom I assume is Andruil. So based on their associations this can be interpreted as: Falon'Din (the Owl) sees Andruil pursuing Ghilan'nain (the halla) but is hunted in turn by Mythal (the dragon) whilst Fen'Harel (the wolf) outwits them all. In what way I wonder? It cannot refer to the Veil/trap he created because Mythal was already dead, unless the dragon is not Mythal but Elgar'nan, who is also known for bringing Winged Death to their enemies. So, may be this refers to the chaos and conflict between the gods that occurred after Mythal's death, with Solas using it to entrap them.
|
|
dayze
N2
Posts: 187 Likes: 81
inherit
1270
0
81
dayze
187
August 2016
dayze
|
Post by dayze on Aug 21, 2023 22:36:01 GMT
it also seems to be breathing fire, fade fire ala the Wolf Demon and the Archdemon? Only via her embrace versus using an object, could this a be a reference to the blight in some way? Well in the Last Flight it is said that the Arch-demon's breath was using magic that wasn't drawn from the Fade but somewhere else. I've tended to assume that meant the Void, as Banal'han, the "Place of Nothing", is where the Dalish believe the Blight originated. I assume this comes from a genuinely remembered ancient piece of lore as the ancient elves' story of Andruil in the ToM associates the Void with the Forgotten Ones and also believe they are associated with corruption and pestilence; hence Andruil returning with plague that attacks her land, which sounds very like the Blight. However, the Wolf Demon in Ameridan's tale is definitely said to breath Fade fire, so I think that is something different from the Arch-demon. If the colour of the flames being breathed by the bear/wolf are accurate in colour, that suggests Veil fire such as we ignite in DAI rather than the Void fire of the Arch-demon. It would be helpful if we knew exactly who painted the picture. It is not in the style of most of Solas' other murals but artists can change and develop their style over time. Otherwise, who is the anonymous artist? This might be helpful in establishing who exactly the horned figure is. We are assuming Ghilan'nain, although she is depicted in the mosaics riding a halla but not antlered herself. However, there is the Dalish story of Andruil transforming her into a halla, which could be a residual memory of Ghilan'nain having antlers. Mythal is shown in statues with wings for arms, so possibly having non-elven appendages was something the gods did with their appearance or it was the sculpture/artist's symbolic way of showing which animal they were associated with. Does it have anything to do with that strange rhyme in the Darvarad? One sees the hunter, one flees from it, one hunts it in turn, one outwits them all. This indicated the order in which to light the veil fire lamps in front of different statues: Owl, halla, dragon, wolf. The only one from the rhyme that does not have a statue is the "hunter", whom I assume is Andruil. So based on their associations this can be interpreted as: Falon'Din (the Owl) sees Andruil pursuing Ghilan'nain (the halla) but is hunted in turn by Mythal (the dragon) whilst Fen'Harel (the wolf) outwits them all. In what way I wonder? It cannot refer to the Veil/trap he created because Mythal was already dead, unless the dragon is not Mythal but Elgar'nan, who is also known for bringing Winged Death to their enemies. So, may be this refers to the chaos and conflict between the gods that occurred after Mythal's death, with Solas using it to entrap them. Reading this I was wondering what kind of entity hunts gods and then the thought occurred to me....the ancient elven version of the Grey Wardens? Which makes me think, could these murals at times be referring not to the gods but their respective organizations or "followers" as such? Spy network as represented by Falon'Din and so forth?
|
|
inherit
∯ Oh Loredy...
455
0
31,186
gervaise21
13,101
August 2016
gervaise21
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
|
Post by gervaise21 on Aug 22, 2023 8:20:04 GMT
Reading this I was wondering what kind of entity hunts gods The god of hunting? In the legend of Andruil with her hunting in the Void, she appears to be obsessed with hunting and it says that the other gods became fearful she would hunt them in turn, so they asked Mythal to intervene. So the interpretation of that rhyme could be an allusion to that story, where Andruil has already started hunting the other gods, which is why Mythal (the dragon) is finally forced to act. What doesn't fit though is the bit about Fen'Harel outwitting them all, which is why I thought that perhaps the dragon was Elgar'nan and not Mythal. After all, if Mythal was the only one who was able to stop Andruil, with Mythal dead perhaps she resumed her hunting of the other gods. Which makes me think, could these murals at times be referring not to the gods but their respective organizations or "followers" as such? They could be something of this sort. However, something has struck me on considering these stories and that is how often the gods are said to be fearful and look to Mythal for protection. Aren't the gods powerful enough to defend themselves? The story about Andruil is found in the Temple of Mythal, so it could just be propaganda by her followers that suggests she is the only one who can deal with the situation. However, according to Solas, Falon'Din was causing a bloodbath elsewhere but Mythal only took action when he threatened her own lands and people, so perhaps several of the other gods aren't as powerful as we might imagine. Ghilan'nain's power seems to derive from her ability to create powerful monstrosities, so presumably the deal where she destroyed them on the promise of being elevated to godhood may have included being offered the protection of Andruil. Dirthamen is known as the god of secrets and knowledge, which give a form of power over others but ultimately may not aid against direct attack. Sylaise appears to be some sort of mimic, as her followers just point to how she can do what the other gods do, only better, and June is said to be "Clever" and is known to the Dalish as the god of crafting, which again suggests that may be his power lies in what he is able to invent and craft. So, perhaps all of these were vulnerable to attack by Andruil or Falon'Din and that is why they looked to Mythal for protection. May be that is why Solas blames them collectively for her death because he knows they couldn't have accomplished it individually but only by uniting together to defeat her. the ancient elven version of the Grey Wardens? I'm not quite sure what you mean by this. The Grey Wardens were formed specifically because of the Blight. It is not clear but it could be possible that a previous group of heroes had succeeded in killing Dumat, only for him to regenerate, so ordinary mortals could kill the vessel that god was contained in but not counter the magic involved that allowed him to soul jump. What is relevant though is this form of regeneration does seem to be connected in some way to the regenerative power of the Evanuris. It is also stated in the Core Rule Book that the idea for the Joining as a means of dealing with the problem was originally suggested by an elf Grey Warden, so that is significant. However, I don't think this points to there being a similar sort of god killing organisation in ancient times or surely Solas would have used them/their knowledge to kill off the other gods. Instead he states that he entrapped them because he knew if he killed them, they wouldn't stay dead. I found this claim to be a bit odd because if that was the case, surely he knew Mythal wasn't really dead, so I assume there had to be something to her murder that made him think she was really gone or prevented him from finding her in the Fade.
|
|
dayze
N2
Posts: 187 Likes: 81
inherit
1270
0
81
dayze
187
August 2016
dayze
|
Post by dayze on Aug 22, 2023 20:49:54 GMT
Reading this I was wondering what kind of entity hunts gods The god of hunting? In the legend of Andruil with her hunting in the Void, she appears to be obsessed with hunting and it says that the other gods became fearful she would hunt them in turn, so they asked Mythal to intervene. So the interpretation of that rhyme could be an allusion to that story, where Andruil has already started hunting the other gods, which is why Mythal (the dragon) is finally forced to act. What doesn't fit though is the bit about Fen'Harel outwitting them all, which is why I thought that perhaps the dragon was Elgar'nan and not Mythal. After all, if Mythal was the only one who was able to stop Andruil, with Mythal dead perhaps she resumed her hunting of the other gods. Which makes me think, could these murals at times be referring not to the gods but their respective organizations or "followers" as such? They could be something of this sort. However, something has struck me on considering these stories and that is how often the gods are said to be fearful and look to Mythal for protection. Aren't the gods powerful enough to defend themselves? The story about Andruil is found in the Temple of Mythal, so it could just be propaganda by her followers that suggests she is the only one who can deal with the situation. However, according to Solas, Falon'Din was causing a bloodbath elsewhere but Mythal only took action when he threatened her own lands and people, so perhaps several of the other gods aren't as powerful as we might imagine. Ghilan'nain's power seems to derive from her ability to create powerful monstrosities, so presumably the deal where she destroyed them on the promise of being elevated to godhood may have included being offered the protection of Andruil. Dirthamen is known as the god of secrets and knowledge, which give a form of power over others but ultimately may not aid against direct attack. Sylaise appears to be some sort of mimic, as her followers just point to how she can do what the other gods do, only better, and June is said to be "Clever" and is known to the Dalish as the god of crafting, which again suggests that may be his power lies in what he is able to invent and craft. So, perhaps all of these were vulnerable to attack by Andruil or Falon'Din and that is why they looked to Mythal for protection. May be that is why Solas blames them collectively for her death because he knows they couldn't have accomplished it individually but only by uniting together to defeat her. the ancient elven version of the Grey Wardens? I'm not quite sure what you mean by this. The Grey Wardens were formed specifically because of the Blight. It is not clear but it could be possible that a previous group of heroes had succeeded in killing Dumat, only for him to regenerate, so ordinary mortals could kill the vessel that god was contained in but not counter the magic involved that allowed him to soul jump. What is relevant though is this form of regeneration does seem to be connected in some way to the regenerative power of the Evanuris. It is also stated in the Core Rule Book that the idea for the Joining as a means of dealing with the problem was originally suggested by an elf Grey Warden, so that is significant. However, I don't think this points to there being a similar sort of god killing organisation in ancient times or surely Solas would have used them/their knowledge to kill off the other gods. Instead he states that he entrapped them because he knew if he killed them, they wouldn't stay dead. I found this claim to be a bit odd because if that was the case, surely he knew Mythal wasn't really dead, so I assume there had to be something to her murder that made him think she was really gone or prevented him from finding her in the Fade. Far as the grey warden's go, I was thinking about how the Archdemon's are supposed to be the old gods and they spend their time hunting them down and killing them. Thought there might be a similar organization back in the day that took care of gods if they went rogue. But them not knowing how to kill them kind of puts a dent in that theory, that and if it was so easy to put them down they wouldn't have to resort to entrapment or possibly mind wipes. Of course the simple answer for taking care of out of control gods "That's What Andruil was for" probably applies. That's a good point about having to fear Andruil starting to sport hunt them again once Mythal was gone, does it ever specify exactly what Mythal did to turn the other gods against, especially with that kind of potential consequence waiting in the wings?
|
|
inherit
∯ Oh Loredy...
455
0
31,186
gervaise21
13,101
August 2016
gervaise21
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
|
Post by gervaise21 on Aug 23, 2023 9:05:27 GMT
That's a good point about having to fear Andruil starting to sport hunt them again once Mythal was gone, does it ever specify exactly what Mythal did to turn the other gods against, especially with that kind of potential consequence waiting in the wings? The only clue we have comes from Solas and, of course, he may be biased. He says it was their lust for power that drove them to kill her. So, in what way was she threatening their power? As I said in my previous post, the nature of their power may vary according to their abilities but it is noticeable how Mythal was regarded as the one the majority looked to for protection and adjudication in the event of antagonism between factions potentially leading to violence. For example, it was her idea that when Elgar'nan and Falon'Din were shaping up for a conflict, she suggested they use champions to resolve the dispute rather than opt for all out war. Another example would seem to be when a follower of Dirthamen had broken the rules but claimed they had been encouraged to do so by Ghilan'nain, the matter was given to Mythal for judgement and she thought it serious enough that she passed it on to Elgar'nan as the ultimate authority. It was Elgar'nan who banished the Forbidden Ones (as we know them) in punishment for desertion during their war with the Earth. So, there was clearly a hierarchy within the gods that all seemed to respect and had served them well, which does make one wonder what could have caused the others to break it. It also seems impossible that the other "lesser" gods could have done this without the approval of Elgar'nan because it is clear that he is absolutely someone you would not want to offend or anger. Anyway, in no particular order, here are some possible motivations that have been suggested for their actions: Personal resentment: Andruil and Falon'Din. The latter in particular, according to Solas, thought a lot of himself, so her "bloodying him in his own temple" would be a motivation for revenge but also the fact she persuaded him to use a champion in his dispute with Elgar'nan instead of allowing the war that he wanted. Jealousy: Elgar'nan - Did he suspect Mythal of taking a lover? Flemeth says that "She was betrayed as I was betrayed". Now we were given two different versions of her story. In the first Flemeth is the wife of Conobar, runs off with her lover, Osen but is tricked into returning out of compassion for her former husband, who then kills Osen and imprisons Flemeth. With Morrigan's version she says that she was originally the wife of Osen and Conobar was jealous of the poor bard, tricking Osen to his death, after which Flemeth took revenge on him. Either way it is a story of jealousy leading to betrayal and death. Except in Flemeth's case it didn't lead to her death, so I'm not sure what Flemeth meant by that, unless it refers to the fact she was betrayed by someone close to her. (Whilst Morrigan denies that Flemeth was aggrieved by Osen agreeing to sell his wife to Conobar, as her situation in life would have improved as the latter's wife/lover, I would certainly have regarded it as a betrayal). Still, it would seem that the betrayal is something that Mythal wants revenge for and the main driving force behind her assistance to Flemeth and everything they have done down the years. As I've already stated, I do not believe the other gods would have acted without Elgar'nan's tacit approval even if he wasn't directly involved in the deed. Mythal likely knew this too, which is why it is Elgar'nan who was likely the main target for her revenge. The other gods discovered Mythal was behind Fen'Harel's rebellion: This depends on whether you think the rebellion started before or after her death. Since Solas claims he only moved against the gods as a result of her murder, that would seem to discount this theory but it is possible to put a different interpretation on his words and whatever the Inquisitor may have meant by their question, he answered as though they were asking about his final action of entrapping them. So, from this perspective, Mythal approved of his rebellion and it was making progress but someone, probably Dirthamen, discovered her duplicity, and the other gods, particularly Elgar'nan, were enraged as it was a direct attack on their power, so they killed her, thinking that would quash the rebellion. Fen'Harel feared this too, as her death meant there was no one to hold the other gods in check, so he took drastic action. Various snippets of information would support this theory. The spirits of Mythal's priesthood knew the password to Fen'Harel's sanctuary. Abelas was adamant that Fen'Harel was not guilty of her death, suggesting he knew this to be impossible. Mythal and Fen'Harel were clearly shown as allies in the Deep Roads. Flemeth says to Merrill: "The People are too quick to bow the knee", which might suggest that Mythal had started to doubt the cult of godhood that had developed around the Evanuris. I also wonder if Mythal had discovered what was going on in the Deep Roads as revealed in the Horror of Hormack and that more than one of the Evanuris was complicit in it. Mythal had tried to deny them access to either lyrium or more likely red lyrium: The latter would be something that those lusting for power would covert. Red lyrium is blight infected lyrium. Flemeth definitely opposed the Blight and actively helps the Wardens. Solas also said that anyone who thinks they can use it safely is mad. From what we know of them, that would accurately describe several of the Evanuris. Is this what Andruil discovered in the Void and brought back with her? Was it red lyrium that sent her mad? The legend speaks of her crafting "armour of the Void" and "weapons of darkness". Corypheus called the Blight "the Darkness". Now it is possible that all of the above could have been contributing factors that led to her death. All I do know is that I shall be very annoyed if we don't get some definite answers in DA:D. As to potential consequences, some of these happened at the time. Community cohesion between the gods had probably started to break down before Solas locked them away, but clearly continued afterwards until at least some of the factions decided the only thing to do was to withdraw from the world. One of these was the community in Arlathan Forest, which according to Strife was the domain of Andruil, which would account for the favourable memories about her among the Dalish and the emphasis on The Way of Three Trees. I assume they stayed in Uthenera until disturbed by the expansion of the Tevinter Imperium when they retaliated in much the same way as the Sentinels did in the Arbor Wilds. What I found interesting about the history concerning this in WoT is that the Imperium initially did their best to form diplomatic relations with them and then put up with a lot of aggression when this approach failed before they finally decided enough was enough. Was there something in the archives of Minrathous that meant the leadership knew more about these humanoid creatures than they let on to the general populace at the time? Also, why were the Venatori and Corypheus so interested in finding elven artifacts? Cory definitely knew that the elves had a special connection with the Fade that made their blood more potent in blood magic rituals. Was this something that the Altus had worked out from their prolonged use of their slaves or were they going on something they already knew? Where did Danarius acquire the knowledge that he used on Fenris? Apparently he didn't just tattoo him with lyrium by hand but used the sarcophagus introduced in Blue Wraith. So, did he construct this himself or find it somewhere? If the latter, who was responsible for it originally, June perhaps? A box that creates the ultimate warrior though marking them with lyrium, so the ultimate form of blood writing, and is even more potent with red lyrium. It certainly points to something that was devised in ancient times. Currently, going by the short story Ruins of Reality and the comic series the Missing, something is definitely "wrong" with the forest. Varric and Harding seemed to assume Solas was responsible but I'm not so sure. I'm also not clear if RoR occurred before or after the events in the comic series. According to that short story, the halla idol appeared to have some connection with the strange anomalies and control them but the Veil Jumpers made no mention of this to Varric and Harding, so perhaps RoR happened after they left. Concept art has also shown a floating landscape, similar to what happened when Cory punched a hole in the Veil at the end of DAI, so I suppose it is possible that Solas' ritual to remove the Veil has already started to work over a limited area. It is certainly something you wouldn't want spreading.
|
|
catcher
N2
Casts Wall of Text
Games: Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire
Posts: 246 Likes: 414
inherit
11818
0
414
catcher
Casts Wall of Text
246
February 2021
catcher
Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire
|
Post by catcher on Sept 1, 2023 0:17:48 GMT
Fair warning: this topic is wandering all over the place (lorewise) so I reserve the right to do the same. Ph3@r! On the wolves, the best answer is not one you are going to like, namely it was a placeable that was 'elfy' and they only had so many of those owls, halla, and dragon ladies before they got too repetitive. I know we like to believe that everything is placed for a lore specific reason but there are some things that can be overthought and my first reaction is that this is one of them. There is a bit of a pattern where the wolf statues do seem to be placed as 'guardians' of a sort. There's one just inside the Lost Temple of Dirthamen. There's one on the edge of the Crow Fens/Ghilan'nain's Grove that marks the edge of the Fens which I believe is a destroyed elven city (based on the artefacts including those weird energy trees buried in the Giant Hand tomb and the crater shape with stone walls all around). There's a big one just before you reach the inner courtyard of Suledin Keep and one at the lower end of Alphonse's Passage. I think, largely, they were just placed in the 'Elf' areas with this thought in mind instead of a specific statement. As for provenance, I've kindof gone back and forth on this. One one hand, the ones in the Lost Temple of Dirthamen and Mythal's temple argue that they are products of the ancient elves. On the other, the one in Watcher's Reach has a note by Fairbanks that mentions 'centuries of water' which indicates he thinks that one at least only goes back to the Dales period. Of course, some could be Dales elves copies of original works which is probably the safest conclusion. All of this gets me off on other questions though. Things like timelines and the ancient elves and some odd lines thrown out by some characters in Inquisition. This is kindof in a line of reasoning but bear with me if it seems a bit random. We know from Fen'Harel's final speeches in Trespasser there were two big wars of the ancient elves. The first led to the rise of the Evanuris in the first place and was probably the conquest of the dwarves and at least one Titan. This probably led to the elves mining operations in the Deep Roads and the legends that drove Fairel's Clan to the surface. Here we have my first question though. The wording of the response to the shrine to Mythal's victory over a titan in the Trespasser Deep Roads hints that the elves angered something else in their greed with words that sound very like what Fen'Harel says at the end of Trespasser. The problem is there he talks about the Evanuris killing Mythal as the breaking point. Verbal comments from the Inquisitor state that the elves were mining for something else eventhough that's not explicit or implicit in the veilfire runes. Maybe red lyrium? Anywho, my next puzzle is that Abelas states that Mythal was murdered by those who destroyed the temple, which when I heard it in reviewing sounded odd given we are standing in the temple with a guardian you would have expected to have died defending it. My own interpretation is that he means that the temple as a place for Mythal's worshippers was destroyed but its an odd way to put it given all the safeguards still in place (like the death rays that destroy Corypheus' body). Anyone got a better read on that? Maybe the Guardians only came later and rebuilt some things? Oh and one other comment, seems Abelas knew Fen'Harel as the Dread Wolf so he definitely knew about the Rebellion. He was either being cagey or clueless about Solas himself, as an elf without valleslin would have to be at least a devotee of Fen'Harel. On the art of the antlered woman and the bear/wolf: that certainly looks like embracing to me with how the arms are intertwined on the left of the picture and the antlered figures fingers are depicted as spread against the creatures body. You can also find the painting in a couple of huts in the Crossroads of the Hinterlands and a few other places that would make the art maybe Alamarri. I interpret it as another case where southern barbarian legend has echoes in elven lore/legend as well. The stars on the muzzle of the bear/wolf do look kind of like the eyes on the end of the muzzle of other depictions of Fen'Harel's wolf form. Good find on the DAO statue, BTW. I need to dig on that a little more. It does seem to dovetail with the hints also from DAO about humans living with elves in both the Dalish Origin story and in the Brecilian Forest. Shouldn't be a surprise then that some legends bleed over and get morphed into similar stories. Good to read everyone's thoughts. Thanks.
|
|
inherit
∯ Oh Loredy...
455
0
31,186
gervaise21
13,101
August 2016
gervaise21
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
|
Post by gervaise21 on Sept 1, 2023 8:50:24 GMT
Fair warning: this topic is wandering all over the place (lorewise) so I reserve the right to do the same. Ph3@r! Not problem, my threads do have a tendency to wander but that's why I like making them as it encourages participation. On the other, the one in Watcher's Reach has a note by Fairbanks that mentions 'centuries of water' which indicates he thinks that one at least only goes back to the Dales period. That doesn't necessarily rule out it being from an earlier period, just that Fairbank's assumed it was just an artifact of the Dales period. After all, why would he assume any different when even the Dalish lore suggests the old elven empire was located up in the north. Mind you, I think Andraste knew something different, which is why she specifically promised the Dales to Shartan. According to the Canticle of Shartan (in WoT), which was based in elven oral tradition, the sword she gave to Shartan (which we can acquire in DA2, Act 3) originally belonged to her mother, who was a Ciriane from that area. The Alamarri poem, Where the Willows Wail, is said to be based off an elven lament found in the ToM, where glandival would appear to translate as "freedom". The sword was called Glandivalis and Andraste handed it to Shartan with the words: "Take this my Champion and free our people forever". In a different part of the Chant of Light, Shartan is referred to as "the Liberator" when he tries to save Andraste from the fire, which is likely how the reference survived when the main canticle about him was purged, because it wasn't obvious it referred to Shartan without it. According to the preface to the Canticle of Shartan, there were suspected to be elements of a much earlier elven folktale in there of a "trickster warrior who fought against tyrants". This is clearly hinting at Fen'Harel's rebellion. Now I am wary of World of Thedas as a reference because the writers do seem to often expand on lore without necessarily considering the impact on readers who are trying to piece things together and which are not carried through to the games or later contradicted by what we discover there. This is then explained by the "unreliable narrator" excuse. Nevertheless, considering what we know from the lore in game, the ideas in WoT do seem consistent with it when it comes to the wolf statues being more than simply random elfy placements. Anywho, my next puzzle is that Abelas states that Mythal was murdered by those who destroyed the temple, which when I heard it in reviewing sounded odd given we are standing in the temple with a guardian you would have expected to have died defending it. I had wondered about this myself. However, the surrounding area was in ruins so it is possible he was referring to the whole complex rather than that inner sanctum, which was likely accessible only to her chosen. After all, the sentinels started attacking us out in the forest, long before we got to the temple in the middle of the lake. What did they think they were defending out there? Some clue may lie in the quote from Sylaise worshipers: "Sylaise, whose temples rival Mythal's cities." Perhaps the entire city area was considered sacred to Mythal, which is why the sentinels were alerted to start defending it the moment outsiders entered the Arbor Wilds. Otherwise, why not save your strength to defend the actual temple should the intruders ever get that far? According to the codex connected with the area, attributed to a Tevinter scholar, the place had long had a fearsome reputation. He commented how it was odd that the Dalish shunned the area considering it was so obviously an elven ruin, which normally interested them. He had also observed that the architecture was very similar to that found in Arlathan Forest. This presumably peaked the curiosity of the Magister to whom he was reporting, who ignored the warning and made a doomed expedition to the area the following year. Back in ancient times, likely the city was destroyed in the battle between the two factions, bearing in mind a lot of magic was probably involved. However, the inner temple probably survived because the enemy forces withdrew, possibly when the gods directing them were imprisoned so they were no longer receiving orders or perhaps they were recalled by their superiors because of the civil war that had broken out elsewhere. Abelas was adamant that it was the elves themselves who had destroyed the empire but if he was shut away in the temple, how did he know? Abelas knew Fen'Harel as the Dread Wolf so he definitely knew about the Rebellion. He was either being cagey or clueless about Solas himself, as an elf without valleslin would have to be at least a devotee of Fen'Harel. As you say, he must have known Solas to be a follower of Fen'Harel, if not the Dread Wolf himself, because of the lack of vallaslin and the fact he acknowledged him as one of his own People. I do wonder though if he did recognise him but knew to keep quiet about it, may be even received some sort of secret sign or mental projection to that effect. When Solas tells him his people still linger elsewhere and he should join them, I suppose he might take the word of just a Fen'Harel follower but he would definitely believe Fen'Harel himself as an ally of Mythal. Incidentally, I don't think Solas was truthful about what his words were to Abelas, or rather he didn't give the entire translation. Good find on the DAO statue, BTW. I need to dig on that a little more. It does seem to dovetail with the hints also from DAO about humans living with elves in both the Dalish Origin story and in the Brecilian Forest. Again, this would tie in with the fact that an ancient elven lament ended up in a human poem of Alamarri origin. Also, the similarity in some of the legends of the elves, the Alamarri and the Avvar (who were an offshoot of the Alamarri). Could it be how an ancient elven sword ended up in the possession of a barbarian leader? I realise they could have just looted it from ruins but that wouldn't explain how Andraste knew its name and meaning. I really hope all these breadcrumbs of lore were leading somewhere and they were not simply tossing them out there randomly, with it being just coincidence that some of them seemed to tie together. I could accept that being the case if there were only one or two but they were constantly occurring across all three games and in WoT. What makes me doubtful is that I recall one of the writers saying how they would refer back to the Wiki when unsure of a bit of lore. This had me worried because not only does the Wiki occasionally misrepresent the lore but I would have thought they would have a core lore book of their own to reference when writing the narrative. The lack of such a reference would certainly explain the anomalies and outright inconsistencies at times in the writing with what we had been told previously. So, when discussing what various clues might mean, I am working to the assumption that there is a core narrative they are following rather than what may actually be the case.
|
|
catcher
N2
Casts Wall of Text
Games: Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire
Posts: 246 Likes: 414
inherit
11818
0
414
catcher
Casts Wall of Text
246
February 2021
catcher
Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire
|
Post by catcher on Sept 2, 2023 2:30:27 GMT
Not problem, my threads do have a tendency to wander but that's why I like making them as it encourages participation. "Not all who wander are lost, but we might have lost our minds" That doesn't necessarily rule out it being from an earlier period, just that Fairbank's assumed it was just an artifact of the Dales period. After all, why would he assume any different when even the Dalish lore suggests the old elven empire was located up in the north. Mind you, I think Andraste knew something different, which is why she specifically promised the Dales to Shartan. According to the Canticle of Shartan (in WoT), which was based in elven oral tradition, the sword she gave to Shartan (which we can acquire in DA2, Act 3) originally belonged to her mother, who was a Ciriane from that area. The Alamarri poem, Where the Willows Wail, is said to be based off an elven lament found in the ToM, where glandival would appear to translate as "freedom". The sword was called Glandivalis and Andraste handed it to Shartan with the words: "Take this my Champion and free our people forever". In a different part of the Chant of Light, Shartan is referred to as "the Liberator" when he tries to save Andraste from the fire, which is likely how the reference survived when the main canticle about him was purged, because it wasn't obvious it referred to Shartan without it. According to the preface to the Canticle of Shartan, there were suspected to be elements of a much earlier elven folktale in there of a "trickster warrior who fought against tyrants". This is clearly hinting at Fen'Harel's rebellion. Now I am wary of World of Thedas as a reference because the writers do seem to often expand on lore without necessarily considering the impact on readers who are trying to piece things together and which are not carried through to the games or later contradicted by what we discover there. This is then explained by the "unreliable narrator" excuse. Nevertheless, considering what we know from the lore in game, the ideas in WoT do seem consistent with it when it comes to the wolf statues being more than simply random elfy placements. First, let me clarify. I was asserting that the placement wolf statues were probably more about the human level designers behind the game, not specific hints from the writing team about lore. Sometimes, we all have to remind ourselves this is a game. Sometimes a big honking wolf statue is just a big honking wolf statue. Along that line, just finished clearing Suledin Keep. Looking back over the steps that would lead to the first red lyrium infected giant, there's a big wolf statue looming over a couple of owls (representing Falon'Din I believe). All throughout the keep there are archer statues (Andruil) and halla (Ghilan'nain). There aren't any Mythal statues but we do see those scattered all over with those selfsame archers, owls, halla, and wolves. If we don't go looking for meaning at the placement of art to the entire pantheon in the Temple of Mythal, placement of wolf statues around areas that were obviously occupied by the ancient elves shouldn't be a suprise. I would heartilly agree there had to be ancient elven settlements in the south (Brecilian Forrest we've already mentioned, Dead Hand dungeon and Ruins on the north bank of the river in the Exalted Plains, Din'an Hanin in the Emerald Graves). As for why they remained when the Dales Elves settled those lands, as you pointed out, they had much bigger fish to fry and may not have been as hostile to Fen'Harrel as the later generations of Dalish, twice shattered would be. I had wondered about this myself. However, the surrounding area was in ruins so it is possible he was referring to the whole complex rather than that inner sanctum, which was likely accessible only to her chosen. After all, the sentinels started attacking us out in the forest, long before we got to the temple in the middle of the lake. What did they think they were defending out there? Some clue may lie in the quote from Sylaise worshipers: "Sylaise, whose temples rival Mythal's cities." Perhaps the entire city area was considered sacred to Mythal, which is why the sentinels were alerted to start defending it the moment outsiders entered the Arbor Wilds. Otherwise, why not save your strength to defend the actual temple should the intruders ever get that far? According to the codex connected with the area, attributed to a Tevinter scholar, the place had long had a fearsome reputation. He commented how it was odd that the Dalish shunned the area considering it was so obviously an elven ruin, which normally interested them. He had also observed that the architecture was very similar to that found in Arlathan Forest. This presumably peaked the curiosity of the Magister to whom he was reporting, who ignored the warning and made a doomed expedition to the area the following year. Back in ancient times, likely the city was destroyed in the battle between the two factions, bearing in mind a lot of magic was probably involved. However, the inner temple probably survived because the enemy forces withdrew, possibly when the gods directing them were imprisoned so they were no longer receiving orders or perhaps they were recalled by their superiors because of the civil war that had broken out elsewhere. Abelas was adamant that it was the elves themselves who had destroyed the empire but if he was shut away in the temple, how did he know? Indeed a minor mystery and your explanation is as good or better than anything I can come up with. Note: the writers left themselves some wriggle room by having Abelas talk about Mythal's murder in such vague terms. On how Abelas knew what he did, I had to go back and relistne to a recording of that particular bit. He replies to the Inquisitor placing 'ancient elves' as those before Arlathan was destroyed by Tevinter with: "The shemlen did not destroy Arlathan. We Elvhan warred upon ourselves. By the time the doors to this sanctuary closed, our time was over." So the civil war was winding down by the time they were sealed in. Again, this would tie in with the fact that an ancient elven lament ended up in a human poem of Alamarri origin. Also, the similarity in some of the legends of the elves, the Alamarri and the Avvar (who were an offshoot of the Alamarri). Could it be how an ancient elven sword ended up in the possession of a barbarian leader? I realise they could have just looted it from ruins but that wouldn't explain how Andraste knew its name and meaning. I really hope all these breadcrumbs of lore were leading somewhere and they were not simply tossing them out there randomly, with it being just coincidence that some of them seemed to tie together. I could accept that being the case if there were only one or two but they were constantly occurring across all three games and in WoT. What makes me doubtful is that I recall one of the writers saying how they would refer back to the Wiki when unsure of a bit of lore. This had me worried because not only does the Wiki occasionally misrepresent the lore but I would have thought they would have a core lore book of their own to reference when writing the narrative. The lack of such a reference would certainly explain the anomalies and outright inconsistencies at times in the writing with what we had been told previously. So, when discussing what various clues might mean, I am working to the assumption that there is a core narrative they are following rather than what may actually be the case. We certainly are getting several ideas that the what everybody knows about history just isn't true which is an old lesson for everyone. I wouldn't be too hard on the writers and some discrepancies even just plain drops. I don't think any game has lore this dense which has had to survive Now almost two decades (Dragon Age started as a follow-up to Neverwinter Nights remember) and has undergone so many reboots, development ups and downs and lost its chief architect nearly a decade ago. You ever try to make sense of a comic book hero's lore after twenty years? Yeesh! Until we do know (whatever we don't know), it's still entertaining to chew on it with you and the other crazies like ourselves.
|
|
inherit
∯ Oh Loredy...
455
0
31,186
gervaise21
13,101
August 2016
gervaise21
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
|
Post by gervaise21 on Sept 2, 2023 8:54:40 GMT
First, let me clarify. I was asserting that the placement wolf statues were probably more about the human level designers behind the game, not specific hints from the writing team about lore. Sometimes, we all have to remind ourselves this is a game. Sometimes a big honking wolf statue is just a big honking wolf statue. I did realise what you meant about it simply being level designers randomly scattering some appropriate iconography. However, that wolf statue is so big and obvious on the skyline, it seemed it just couldn't be because they tossed a coin and that's what they came up with. I mean, why have a statue up there at all? I suppose the opposing argument would be, why didn't they reference it in a codex, if only one saying: "Many people have speculated why there is a giant wolf statue overlooking the Exalted Plains but to date no one has an answer", or something equally cryptic. The ones that do have a codex associated with them are clearly intentional. With this in mind, I have been thinking again about the codex connected with the one at the entrance to the temple of Mythal. Without Trespasser that codex is odd. Why make reference to the name possibly having an alternative meaning of "rebel" when even Flemeth/Mythal refers to him as "Dread Wolf". Also, I questioned how human scholars were meant to have a better knowledge of the elven language than the Dalish, considering whenever we needed something translated in the Inquisition, we called upon our Dalish agents to do this and even they apparently couldn't translate those ancient writings we find in the temple complex. Incidentally, this makes the entry in WoT2 about meaning of the elven poem found there somewhat strange as well. Did Morrigan translate it for them on a whim? Or perhaps the default world state has the Inquisitor drink from the well, as that would explain it. Anyway, once we have the information from Trespasser, whilst Solas still seems to insist that "Harel"does indeed mean "Dread", I suppose it is possible that he was the one who altered the meaning from just being that of "Rebel" as he admits he wanted to frighten his enemies with the name that was originally intended as an insult. The knowledge that he did in fact lead a rebellion, that the spirits of Mythal in your head know the password to his sanctuary and that codex about his name originally meaning rebel being given in response to Morrigan's assertion that having his statue placed there was sacrilege, does seem to lend a lot of credence to the idea that Mythal not only supported the rebellion but may even have instigated it, using her old ally Fen'Harel (or Solas as he was known before the rebellion) as her front man. It has just occurred to me that perhaps it was Mythal who originally came up with the insult Fen'Harel and suggested it to the other gods, having already agreed with Solas that he should adopt that name once the Evanuris named him as such. I also wonder if they are going to connect the rebellion to what was revealed in Horror of Hormack. It would seem that Ghilan'nain was conducting horrific experiments on elves. Since the murals indicate the elves already regarded her as a god, it would seem different to the episode we find related in the Temple of Mythal when her elevation to godhood was dependent on destroying her monsters. If Mythal, or Solas, uncovered the fact that she had gone back on the deal and some of the other gods were implicated as well, it might explain why she couldn't simply act against Ghilan'nain alone. If what was being buried in that text in the Deep Roads, was not just red lyrium but possibly the monsters, darkspawn perhaps or something worse (the original broodmother perhaps?), that Ghil had created, it would fit with the words in that codex: "What the Evanuris in their greed could unleash would end us all. Let this place be forgotten. Let no one wake its anger. The People must rise before their false gods destroy them all." It certainly seems to be linked to the rebellion. They also sealed the caverns in the Deep Roads with stone and magic. Somehow the Magisters Sidereal breaking into the Black City, also broke the seals on the caverns in the Deep Roads, or enough of them to release the darkspawn, even if the worst of them were still contained. Then Cory using the orb to create the Breach, if only by accident, weakened the seals once more. If it was sufficient to awaken the Titan in the Descent, what else might have been released? Hence the cavern in the Horror of Hormack being opened up to the outside world, when apparently the dwarves at the height of their empire were unaware of it.
|
|
Beerfish
N7
Little Pumpkin
Games: Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, KOTOR, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Mass Effect Andromeda, Anthem, Mass Effect Legendary Edition
Origin: Beerfish
XBL Gamertag: Beerfish77
Posts: 15,192 Likes: 36,401
inherit
Little Pumpkin
314
0
36,401
Beerfish
15,192
August 2016
beerfish
https://bsn.boards.net/user/314/personal
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, KOTOR, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Mass Effect Andromeda, Anthem, Mass Effect Legendary Edition
Beerfish
Beerfish77
|
Post by Beerfish on Sept 5, 2023 20:06:20 GMT
|
|
catcher
N2
Casts Wall of Text
Games: Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire
Posts: 246 Likes: 414
inherit
11818
0
414
catcher
Casts Wall of Text
246
February 2021
catcher
Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire
|
Post by catcher on Sept 6, 2023 20:36:20 GMT
I did realise what you meant about it simply being level designers randomly scattering some appropriate iconography. Good to know, I will proceed then. However, that wolf statue is so big and obvious on the skyline, it seemed it just couldn't be because they tossed a coin and that's what they came up with. I mean, why have a statue up there at all? I suppose the opposing argument would be, why didn't they reference it in a codex, if only one saying: "Many people have speculated why there is a giant wolf statue overlooking the Exalted Plains but to date no one has an answer", or something equally cryptic. Why are there big, angular armored figures looming over the Western Approach? Why are there hammer hefting dwarves appearing on top of peaks in both the Hissing Wastes and Storm Coast? Why are there statues of Maferath above Old Crestwood with flags in them? They don't all have nor need lore entries to tell the Player 'This is old Dwarven country', or 'Tevinter holdings', or other flavors. As for why, specifically, its the wolf, there could be several reasons. First, and most likely, it was the model that looked best on that scale and distance. I know that's disappointing from a secret lore perspective but they snuck in so many other hints and clues, couldn't we give them that? One more lore entry that says basically nothing other what you already know (Hey, there used to be elves here). Basically that's what the note on Morrin's Outlook gives you anyway. That doesn't mean I've given up entirely on some significance to that specific wolf statue. Read on later. The ones that do have a codex associated with them are clearly intentional. With this in mind, I have been thinking again about the codex connected with the one at the entrance to the temple of Mythal. Without Trespasser that codex is odd. Why make reference to the name possibly having an alternative meaning of "rebel" when even Flemeth/Mythal refers to him as "Dread Wolf". Also, I questioned how human scholars were meant to have a better knowledge of the elven language than the Dalish, considering whenever we needed something translated in the Inquisition, we called upon our Dalish agents to do this and even they apparently couldn't translate those ancient writings we find in the temple complex. Incidentally, this makes the entry in WoT2 about meaning of the elven poem found there somewhat strange as well. Did Morrigan translate it for them on a whim? Or perhaps the default world state has the Inquisitor drink from the well, as that would explain it. Anyway, once we have the information from Trespasser, whilst Solas still seems to insist that "Harel"does indeed mean "Dread", I suppose it is possible that he was the one who altered the meaning from just being that of "Rebel" as he admits he wanted to frighten his enemies with the name that was originally intended as an insult. The knowledge that he did in fact lead a rebellion, that the spirits of Mythal in your head know the password to his sanctuary and that codex about his name originally meaning rebel being given in response to Morrigan's assertion that having his statue placed there was sacrilege, does seem to lend a lot of credence to the idea that Mythal not only supported the rebellion but may even have instigated it, using her old ally Fen'Harel (or Solas as he was known before the rebellion) as her front man. It has just occurred to me that perhaps it was Mythal who originally came up with the insult Fen'Harel and suggested it to the other gods, having already agreed with Solas that he should adopt that name once the Evanuris named him as such. I also wonder if they are going to connect the rebellion to what was revealed in Horror of Hormack. It would seem that Ghilan'nain was conducting horrific experiments on elves. Since the murals indicate the elves already regarded her as a god, it would seem different to the episode we find related in the Temple of Mythal when her elevation to godhood was dependent on destroying her monsters. If Mythal, or Solas, uncovered the fact that she had gone back on the deal and some of the other gods were implicated as well, it might explain why she couldn't simply act against Ghilan'nain alone. If what was being buried in that text in the Deep Roads, was not just red lyrium but possibly the monsters, darkspawn perhaps or something worse (the original broodmother perhaps?), that Ghil had created, it would fit with the words in that codex: "What the Evanuris in their greed could unleash would end us all. Let this place be forgotten. Let no one wake its anger. The People must rise before their false gods destroy them all." It certainly seems to be linked to the rebellion. They also sealed the caverns in the Deep Roads with stone and magic. Somehow the Magisters Sidereal breaking into the Black City, also broke the seals on the caverns in the Deep Roads, or enough of them to release the darkspawn, even if the worst of them were still contained. Then Cory using the orb to create the Breach, if only by accident, weakened the seals once more. If it was sufficient to awaken the Titan in the Descent, what else might have been released? Hence the cavern in the Horror of Hormack being opened up to the outside world, when apparently the dwarves at the height of their empire were unaware of it. I'll just add a few comments here. Sometimes, a group of 'experts' can become so steeped in a particular approach or viewpoint that it is hard to break the mold. Note Morrigan's shock when Abelas confirms that not only was there a Mythal but that she was murdered. Morrigan is supposedly well-steeped in elven lore but this just floors her. While I'm doubtful about the textual approach in what seems to be depicted as a largely verbal tradition, but then, we find out that is closer in Trespasser. The inclusion isn't particularly odd though. Fen'Harel was known to be the villan in DA4 which was supposed to be coming soon even when Inquisition was wrapping up. The lore was just setting up some additional reveals for DA4 for those that didn't get Trespasser. I don't hold out too much promise for Tevinter Nights linking into DAD. I think that was the plan then but Bioware has gone through so many plans now, I have to wonder if they aren't using Suessian 'On Beyond Zebra' letters by now. I do think that the fact that Fen'Harel states that the murder of Mythal and the raising of some kind of existential threat were reasons for his rebellion means that it is likely she opposed the course of action taken by whatever group of Evanuris did both deeds. As for the inscription, most likely is referring to red lyrium to me. We know the ancient dwarves sealed it away and we suspect that the ancient dwarves did have access to magic (Primeval Thaig buildings, the Valdasine staff, the use of staves as badges of office by the deshyrs of Orzazmarr). Was that what was severed when the elves conquered them long ago and slew a titan? Is that why a later dwarven king sealed away the Primeval Thaig? Now it only seems fitting that I should stick my own neck out a bit. Something(s) have struck me while researching a bunch of this both with online and in game resources. First is that there are two types of 'wolf' statues (and not coincidentally I believe, two Mythal 'dragon' statues as well) in Inquisition. The first is the one we are all pretty familiar with and is found (among other places) atop high places in the Exalted Plains, Emerald Graves, and Emprise du Lion. The other, though is a smaller 'howlin wolf' design that you will most often find around an eluvian. My memory may not be entirely correct, but it seems that the reclining wolf is only seen where there are no Mythal statues like in the wilderness area of the Emerald Graves, Exalted Plains, etc. The smaller howling wolves are seen usually where Mythal is present (Din'nan Hanin, Altar of Mythal, etc.) There's also the central piece of the Dalish myth about Fen'Harel ticking both the Evanuris and the Forgotten One that Fen'Harel could pull it off because he moved between both groups. What if Fen'Harel was believed to be in both camps until the one killed Mythal and thus the two statues and the big ones not being destroyed in the rebellion. Of course, it also begs thebquestion: why are there two Mythal statues? Is the representation of Elgar'Nan actually supposed to be one? The more dragony one as opposed to the female figure with wings? It's a thought. Just for more fun, what do you make of the two statues seen around the Venatori Camp in the Hissing Wastes? They also appear (that I'm aware of) on the huge pillars that held up the ancient highway in Emprise (not Judaciel's Crossing. The one from early Tevinter according to Genetivi) and in Vir Dirthala as massive pillars. One looks like a fully armored Tevinter warrior with that horn-nose helmet and the other is a female figure with curled horns that I have seen variably interpreted as a Desire Demon and a Qunari. Neither one of those really appeals to me. A theory that's kind of swirling around in my head is that these are the early Tevinter representations of Fen'Harel and Mythal before the worship of the Old Gods took hold. That would then fit with Genitivi's timeline but why they are on the opposite side of the Sunstop Mountains. They don't make any sense as flavor in a Dwarven area and the Venatori wouldn't be carving them themselves. There's plenty of other random, dropped junk (like the weird orbs near the Colossus that do nothing and the abandonded elven camp that has no known purpose) that I'm tempted just to ignore them myself. Have fun.
|
|
inherit
∯ Oh Loredy...
455
0
31,186
gervaise21
13,101
August 2016
gervaise21
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
|
Post by gervaise21 on Sept 7, 2023 8:26:10 GMT
Just for more fun, what do you make of the two statues seen around the Venatori Camp in the Hissing Wastes? They also appear (that I'm aware of) on the huge pillars that held up the ancient highway in Emprise (not Judaciel's Crossing. The one from early Tevinter according to Genetivi) and in Vir Dirthala as massive pillars. One looks like a fully armored Tevinter warrior with that horn-nose helmet and the other is a female figure with curled horns Whilst I have reservations about referring to WoT2 on this, it is possible there is another option contained in the Chant of Light found there. Now according to this the ancient barbarian tribes did worship the Maker, possibly as one among many gods, but he seemed the ultimate one to appeal to in times of trouble. The Neromenians honoured dragons as they thought they were the reincarnation of their heroes. Note how the priesthood in Haven believed Andraste had been reborn as a dragon, suggesting this belief may not have entirely died out among those tribes not eradicated by Drakon. Anyway, when Thalsian introduced the worship of Dumat to the Neromenians I wonder if originally he was represented as a dragon because that form was associated with reincarnated mortals, not gods. Then when they attacked the Planasene to the south and the Planasene's appeal to the Maker didn't prevent their soldiers from being slaughtered, they were offered help by a demon if they would worship her instead, to the exclusion of the Maker. They took the offer and she afflicted their enemies with physical ailments that prevented them continuing the war, so thereafter this demon became their goddess and Maker worship ceased. Scroll forward several centuries and in the history of Darinius, first Archon of the Imperium, we have the Neromenians with their principle god being Dumat, with their other patron gods being Toth and Lusacan. Meanwhile the patron goddess of Tevinter is Razikale. No information is given where the other Old Gods fit into this but since Qarinus was a third independent kingdom at this time, I would assume at least one of them was patron god/goddess there. When Darinius united the three realms into the Imperium, it is likely that the two most important gods who led the pantheon would be Dumat and Razikale, as he was high priest of the former and his mother had been queen of Tevinter and high priestess of the latter. So, either they set up those statues to represent these two gods or, as apparently was often the case, they repurposed statues already present to represent their gods. As you say, if the armoured warrior was originally Elgar'nan and the horned female was Mythal, it would be easy enough to envisage them as Dumat and Razikale. This leads me to ponder another question. When did the ancient Tevene start representing their gods as dragons? Apparently, the Planasene were well aware the being they worshiped was a demon and if Thalsian was listening to whispers from a being in the Fade, then he was likely aware it was a demon too. As I say, if the Neromenians thought their heroes were reincarnated as dragons, why start associating them with the divine, even if they did indulge in some form of ancestor worship? However, if the Avvar are any indication, then among the barbarians the term "god" was simply associated with spirits and demons. According to the writers, originally the Arch-demon was going to be precisely that and it was only at a fairly late stage they decided to make them dragons and adjusted the lore accordingly. The images that have been shown of the original concept make them very similar in appearance to the elven gods we find in the ruins in the Dalish Origin and other statues we find subsequently without a specific association, so I think they did intend us to make a connection between them but the alteration of Arch-demons into dragons made it less obvious. I also think there must be some connection between the fact that Cory chose to split his soul with a dragon, Hakkon was summoned into a dragon by the priest, the Old Gods are demons in dragon form that can soul jump to other beings of a similar essence and Flemeth/Mythal being able to cheat death by similar means. That surely wasn't mere coincidence. First is that there are two types of 'wolf' statues (and not coincidentally I believe, two Mythal 'dragon' statues as well) in Inquisition. As you have pointed out, it may well be that there is nothing more to this than designers wanting to add a bit of variety but also trying to be a bit consistent in their application. So, they had two different wolf statues and the general rule about which to use was connected with the location. Ditto the Mythal statues. I'm starting to feel that may be you are right about this and I am placing way too much faith in the idea that these features are connected to the ongoing historical narrative instead of being merely appropriate decoration. I still can't help wondering though why Fen'Harel is only ever shown as a wolf, even in the mosaics where he is depicted with the other gods? Even that statue next to Mythal in the Deep Roads is a wolf and his self portraits or those depicting him in his sanctuary always have his upper face concealed by either a hood or a wolf head mask. Even the warning of the gods against him says he can have many forms and the humble wander that we encountered is just one of many. So, I am hoping that the suggestion in Tevinter Nights that no one actually knows his true identity is something they are going to follow through with in game and is going to prove significant in dealing with him.
|
|
catcher
N2
Casts Wall of Text
Games: Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire
Posts: 246 Likes: 414
inherit
11818
0
414
catcher
Casts Wall of Text
246
February 2021
catcher
Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire
|
Post by catcher on Sept 11, 2023 21:51:21 GMT
Whilst I have reservations about referring to WoT2 on this, it is possible there is another option contained in the Chant of Light found there. Now according to this the ancient barbarian tribes did worship the Maker, possibly as one among many gods, but he seemed the ultimate one to appeal to in times of trouble. The Neromenians honoured dragons as they thought they were the reincarnation of their heroes. Note how the priesthood in Haven believed Andraste had been reborn as a dragon, suggesting this belief may not have entirely died out among those tribes not eradicated by Drakon. Anyway, when Thalsian introduced the worship of Dumat to the Neromenians I wonder if originally he was represented as a dragon because that form was associated with reincarnated mortals, not gods. Then when they attacked the Planasene to the south and the Planasene's appeal to the Maker didn't prevent their soldiers from being slaughtered, they were offered help by a demon if they would worship her instead, to the exclusion of the Maker. They took the offer and she afflicted their enemies with physical ailments that prevented them continuing the war, so thereafter this demon became their goddess and Maker worship ceased. Scroll forward several centuries and in the history of Darinius, first Archon of the Imperium, we have the Neromenians with their principle god being Dumat, with their other patron gods being Toth and Lusacan. Meanwhile the patron goddess of Tevinter is Razikale. No information is given where the other Old Gods fit into this but since Qarinus was a third independent kingdom at this time, I would assume at least one of them was patron god/goddess there. When Darinius united the three realms into the Imperium, it is likely that the two most important gods who led the pantheon would be Dumat and Razikale, as he was high priest of the former and his mother had been queen of Tevinter and high priestess of the latter. So, either they set up those statues to represent these two gods or, as apparently was often the case, they repurposed statues already present to represent their gods. As you say, if the armoured warrior was originally Elgar'nan and the horned female was Mythal, it would be easy enough to envisage them as Dumat and Razikale. This leads me to ponder another question. When did the ancient Tevene start representing their gods as dragons? Apparently, the Planasene were well aware the being they worshiped was a demon and if Thalsian was listening to whispers from a being in the Fade, then he was likely aware it was a demon too. As I say, if the Neromenians thought their heroes were reincarnated as dragons, why start associating them with the divine, even if they did indulge in some form of ancestor worship? However, if the Avvar are any indication, then among the barbarians the term "god" was simply associated with spirits and demons. Thanks for the additional information as I do not have either of the WoT books. Its as good a theory as we're likely to get and, to tell the truth, I'm not sure there's anything to those statues. There are none visible in the Silent Ruins which are the oldest in-game Tevinter Ruins I know about. Ditto Coracavus and the Temples of Razikale in the Frostbacks. (Side note: there are a pair of GRIFFONS in the Silent Ruins which I think just proves the point that sometimes, weird stuff just got by QA). The "tevinter" statues DO apparently also appear in The Fade but that's an artistic junkyard anyway so no help. According to the writers, originally the Arch-demon was going to be precisely that and it was only at a fairly late stage they decided to make them dragons and adjusted the lore accordingly. The images that have been shown of the original concept make them very similar in appearance to the elven gods we find in the ruins in the Dalish Origin and other statues we find subsequently without a specific association, so I think they did intend us to make a connection between them but the alteration of Arch-demons into dragons made it less obvious. I also think there must be some connection between the fact that Cory chose to split his soul with a dragon, Hakkon was summoned into a dragon by the priest, the Old Gods are demons in dragon form that can soul jump to other beings of a similar essence and Flemeth/Mythal being able to cheat death by similar means. That surely wasn't mere coincidence. First is that there are two types of 'wolf' statues (and not coincidentally I believe, two Mythal 'dragon' statues as well) in Inquisition. As you have pointed out, it may well be that there is nothing more to this than designers wanting to add a bit of variety but also trying to be a bit consistent in their application. So, they had two different wolf statues and the general rule about which to use was connected with the location. Ditto the Mythal statues. I'm starting to feel that may be you are right about this and I am placing way too much faith in the idea that these features are connected to the ongoing historical narrative instead of being merely appropriate decoration. But I'm still holding on to the significance of the Bulbous One I still can't help wondering though why Fen'Harel is only ever shown as a wolf, even in the mosaics where he is depicted with the other gods? Even that statue next to Mythal in the Deep Roads is a wolf and his self portraits or those depicting him in his sanctuary always have his upper face concealed by either a hood or a wolf head mask. Even the warning of the gods against him says he can have many forms and the humble wander that we encountered is just one of many. So, I am hoping that the suggestion in Tevinter Nights that no one actually knows his true identity is something they are going to follow through with in game and is going to prove significant in dealing with him. Now you are giving me more reason to push my Fairel is Fen'Harel crazy theory. More to your point, the being we knew as Solas was deeply concerned with spirits to the point I would call spirits his actual 'people'. The artistic renderings make me think the real 'Fen'Harel' is also a spirit-like entity like Mythal and shares a physical body just as she did with Flemeth. Last, now you KNOW I'll have to go back to Tevinter Nights and reread some stories. Thanks again for the valuable conversation even if we are chewing a a long overchewed bone (like a hungry wolf).
|
|
inherit
∯ Oh Loredy...
455
0
31,186
gervaise21
13,101
August 2016
gervaise21
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights
|
Post by gervaise21 on Sept 12, 2023 7:32:33 GMT
Thanks for the additional information as I do not have either of the WoT books. Its as good a theory as we're likely to get and, to tell the truth, I'm not sure there's anything to those statues. There are none visible in the Silent Ruins which are the oldest in-game Tevinter Ruins I know about. Ditto Coracavus and the Temples of Razikale in the Frostback Something I forgot to mention was the idol depicting Razikale that can be fund in a cave in the Western Approach. This seems to show a female figure holding a large horned head in the air. It may be that only the horned head is meant to represent Razikale and the figure holding it up is her high priestess, who possibly dons the mask to stand in place of their goddess during worship. Why would Razikale be worshiped as a horned humanoid if the Old Gods were thought to be dragons? I have questioned in the past how exactly people knew that the Arch-demon was Dumat? Who identified him? In the Fade there is the memory of that worshiper who saw the Arch-demon arise: I made the expected offerings this morning, but the gods remained silent. The priests are frightened. All of Tevinter is frightened. Our gods have led our people for centuries. Now, they have gone still. Are we alone here in this world, no better than the savages to the south who beg for guidance from spirits? And what of the strange creatures who come from underground, like our friends the dwarves? These spawn of the darkness and the plague they carry... Why do our gods not protect us from this?
Now the ground shakes. The statue cuts my hand as I fall against it. A great roar sounds. It is massive, shaking the temple market, and I see the silhouette cut the sky. It is a dragon. No, it is Dumat! I have made the offerings so many times—his form is as familiar as my own hand. He has returned in glory to destroy these darkspawn that threaten us, to lead Tevinter back to an age of glory and wonder!
But no, his scales are sickly and mottled, his form twisted and corrupt, like the darkspawn themselves. He opens his great maw, and fire billows forth, igniting the market.
The flames rush toward me.
What did we do wrong?
—Memories somehow caught in the blood on an ancient Tevinter statueCompare this with the other inscription nearby: Look upon the Temple of Dumat God of Silence, who speaks to the faithful in dreams No words of desire may sway His will No cry of valor may stand against Him For His Silence conquers all And His Secrets are shared only with the worthy Look upon the Temple of Dumat And fear Him
—Inscription written below the demon statues
Note how the inscription shows that Dumat speaks to the faithful in dreams, so there is no suggestion they have ever seen him in the flesh. Yet the priest in the memory instantly recognises the Arch-demon as Dumat. How? Even if they had previously been shown Dumat in a dream as a dragon, the Arch-demon has been altered in appearance by the Blight, yet the priest insists his form is instantly recognisable as Dumat and not simply a dragon. He also disparages the barbarians in the south for being guided by spirits, so apparently does not regard Dumat as such. I find that puzzling. Another oddity is the fact that at first he thinks Dumat has come to lead Tevinter back to "an age of glory and wonder". Surely though Tevinter was meant to be at the height of its glory when the 1st Blight occurred? However, it does tie in with the memory of Corypheus' slave, which suggests that his master was already having difficulty communicating with Dumat before they went to the Fade since he was cutting himself ever deeper and more frequently, suggesting a blood magic ritual being used to contact his god. The servant speaks of a weakening of the Temples disturbing his master's equilibrium and that he had been vexed by a loss of followers, not just of Dumat but the Old Gods generally. However, the servant does say that Corypheus only seems to listen to the voices in his dreams. When we free Corypheus in Legacy, he complains to Dumat that the city wasn't golden as he expected and possibly promised by the voice in his dreams. By the time we find his memories in the Temple of Dumat in DAI he seems to have decided that finding the darkness wasn't such a bad thing after all and he allowed it to permeate his being but that is only to be expected now he has decided to be a god himself. The disorientated individual we hear in Legacy seems closer to the truth and, of course, it is the same attitude he returns to when facing death and he appeals to his god for help. Why did all the gods fall silent once the Black City was opened? That does suggest that they must all have been in on the plan and having achieved their aim they had no more use for their worshipers. Or did breaking the prison cause some sort of curse to rebound on them that was put in place in the event of such by their captor? Was the aim to arise and conquer the world with their darkspawn army or was it actually intended to place them in a confrontation that would lead to the death of their fleshy prison? Does being killed by a Grey Warden really lead to the destruction of the soul or its freedom? Flemeth speaks of Urthemiel's soul having been "snatched from the jaws of darkness" but that could mean anything from death to the Void. The Old God soul embodied in Kieran certainly didn't sound evil. Was that just the effect of speaking through the mind of a child or were the regrets expressed about past events genuine? Why was Flemeth/Mythal so determined to "save" it? Just to acquire the power or something else? There are still so many questions left unanswered.
|
|