Class know-how

So what exactly are you asking? Why doesn't our hero know everything? Because they don't...
the Mage Warden, while exceptionally talented, is also drafted into Grey Wardens more or less right after their Harrowing, so before they had a chance to explore deeper mysteries of the Arcane.
Hawke was likely never taught any magic beyond what they needed to remain undetected by Templars and to survive.

And why does Shepard need to have complexities of the universe explained to her? Simple, she is no scientist, no technician, she is a soldier.


(Well, those are in-character explanations, but most likely reason is that lore needs to be explained to us, players...also, ouch, that english hurts)

Yes, but the fight in the citadel dlc was only a more detailed fight like every other, basically.  



No, I don't want that the HC know everything, he should know his own school. The noble should know about the behavior as nobleman, he should have knowledge about circumstances in some kingdomes and there politics. Compared to other origins the Trevelyan in DAI is the best written HC. At least he knows a little bit about politics and nobility families, which corresponds to his role. Thats enough, already.
But how Shinobu said, it is awkward that our Dalish, when a mage, is the First of the Dalish Clan Keeper but need to have Morrigan to explain the easiest things about those things a Merrill knew about. that does not fit. It does not matter that the player don't know nothing. We are playing someone how lived in his world, even before we take the controll over him. From all sides you can hear that our mage has unusually strong magic and is talented. Our warrior wins all of the battles and is unbeaten.
In ME Shepard could be a biotic and have to learned to control this power and what are the possibilities. We know it because Kaidan had explained that, but in the trilogie we only see Shepard can people with it, nothing more. In the collector base, some of the biotic squad mates have to give a hint they could use biotic. Shepard has no idea.
Same as with the tech Shepard. There is no scene where Shepard could be better then other classes to master a situation. All of it are only 'How to kill people' not 'How could we survive or solve this problem'





We don'T know when Trevelyan brought to the circle, but the Amell have to be very young when he got his magic und brought to the circle. The Trevelyan knowing about his family, the Amell not. The Amell lived the whole life in the circle and in the game get to hear that our mage was very interested to learn about magic. He was the favorit from ther First Enchanter and his Apprentices. That means our mage had access to all books and spells.
Circle mages have to know very much to be not a danger for others, so I think he should already know about the veil, the dangers of tears, the fade, the demons and the ghosts. He have to know that the circle could help to enter the fade and only to kill the demon to rescue everyone.



Hawke learned everything from his father, who is a former circle mage. Actually, it is the same. Hawke have to learn even more, because like you already said they have to hide in freedom.
But how I said, Hawke talks more about magic knowledge then Trevelyan, Adaar and Amell together. Trevelyan is needing a ghost to prevent to be possessed.



well, I know, but I always had a problem with grammar and time in English. it is very confusing to me.

Uhhh

wat