Zha'til SAM and the Protheans a friendly rant.

Those were the apparent observations of the Leviathan but their sample was limited to the Milky Way. No conclusions can be drawn for outside of the MW. Also, this didn't happen with the geth (they let their creators go) or the Zha'til (who did what they did under direct Reaper control). In fact, it's right up there in your quote, which I've highlighted. In other words, it could just be that the reason synthetics are rebelling against their creators is because the Reapers are forcing them to do so. It may never happen without Reaper influence. Even the geth only used violence in response to violence against them, and the desire to continue existing. That changed when, you guessed it, the Reapers came along. It was only then that the geth began to attack organics in earnest (aside from those they perceived to be invading their territory).

Yet another thing that makes me dislike this game, Bioware AI fetish is starting to take on ridiculous proportions.

My interpretation/headcanon is that the Catalyst worked with what it "knew" via its programming.  If its programming says A = true then it doesn't really matter if B disproves A.  B isn't part of the equation. (My math skills may not be up to the task for the equation but I hope you understand.)  I think the conclusion of the Leviathan is false but the Catalyst is hindered by programming that says it is true - and perhaps it will even do whatever is necessary to make it true.  SAM would be dangerous if a Reaper ever interacted with it.  Otherwise, no, it seems invested in the well being of its "host".  (Host isn't precisely accurate since SAM seems to be located in a node but has a deep connection with Alec and then the twin of your choice.)

The Quarian's are in a migrant fleet with a total population of 16 million,16 MILLION from a possible population that could of been in the 10's of Billions,they didn't let them go they ran out targets,the Quarians moved as far away as possible.

They might of well have, less than 1% of them are left,i think the only reason they didn't exterminate the survivors was they had fled so far into Citadel space the Geth knew they would be turned into spare parts by the Combined might of the Council if they pursued into the their territory 

The Quarian military tried to shut down the Geth,so by your reasoning every man,woman and child that was slaughtered by the Geth deserved it.Nothing stopping the Geth from rounding up the non combatants sticking them on a shuttle and telling them "don't come back".
They did not though they hunted down every last man,woman and child they could find and coldly,calculatingly ended their lives,but hey it's their own fault they started it.
They let them go,really all 16 million of them,they could not let all the non combatants go?
So please don't get misty eyed over a bunch of genocidal toasters and don't bring up the prevarication of in-game facts.

That's your interpretation (and easily disproven!):

Ok, so explain to me WHY the Geth allow the Quarians back onto Rannoch in ME3 (if you played your cards right) and why they are even HELPING THEM? If they wanted them exterminated then they would have kept shooting after they got the Reaper-Upgrades back (permanently this time!), they could have blown the Migrant Fleet to smithereenes if they wanted to!

Fact is: They didn't!

Another fact: They didn't spread their "wings" so to speak, they took over a number of systems and then stayed there and started building a DYSON-SWARM, they didn't want to fight organic beings! They wanted to be left alone! Sure they probably killed people who entered the Perseus Veil (we don't actually know, they might have only imprisoned them to live out their lives in there, they just might have been forbidden (and unable) to leave!), but that's it!

greetings LAX
ps: I love the "AI-Fetish" (it's a core topic of this universe and I for one like AI, hell I am alll for augmenting humanity and I'd love a permanent and working BCI (Brain-Computer-Interface!) implanted in my head...I might not go as far as Ryder does, so that the AI can basically run my body and optimize it (not that I wouldn't like that! In fact this might be a way to achieve something I want more than anything: Immortality! No dying of fucking "natural" causes (death is an illness IMHO and we should be working on a cure!), no aging (also a disease!)), but otherwise? Sign me the fuck up! IMHO humanity has to transcend its biological limitations, otherwise we'll never travel space like in science fiction!

The very fact that the Geth did break off pursuit (and only took up arms in self-defense and defense of Quarians who stood with them) proves it and if you say:

"They feared council reprisal if they followed the Quarians further"

Well, they could have easily done so as fucking programms in the extra-net (!), the Geth aren't hardware, they are software as Tali says! So they could have uploaded themselves say on cargo-ships and rammed those into the Migrant Fleet and arranged for other catastrophes (shut down the defense systems and let Batarian Slavers attack the fleet!) etc.

Fact is: The Geth did no such thing, so they at heart aren't war like, they don't want to fight - not even people who attacked them first! They fought a defensive war (sure they did the "The best defense is a good offense!" thing, but over all they didn't go out and they didn't attack people just because they could!)

greetings LAX

Weren't they dead already (for the most part - I mean there surely were survivors cut of from spaceports who continued to fight till they were dead!), I mean didn't the Quarians start running when they were already being pushed back to smallish pockets of resistance (probably around spaceports and military facilities)? I mean it would make no sense to start running when you still control most of the planet, would it?

greetings LAX

I don't think anyone is really arguing that the geth were "good" in the level of killing they did during the Morning War.  What *is* true is that they didn't start the war.  The initial point of this thread is that they were an example of why synthetics couldn't be trusted.  The reverse was true in this situation since it was the organics who couldn't be trusted.  It was true with the geth and with the sentient mechs (seen in Citadel Archives) who wanted to be recognized by the Council before being gunned down by C-Sec.  The Zha'til are also another failed reference since it's the Reapers themselves that made them turn on their creators.

Here's what we know: some unspecified slave race of the Leviathan was destroyed by synthetics.  We don't know any details.  It could even have been that they attacked the synthetics first.  We just don't know.  Next up is that the Leviathan themselves were overthrown by the Intelligence that they had created.  However, the Leviathan believe that the Intelligence/Reapers are "just doing their job".

Where's the real evidence that synthetics always rebel against organics?  I'm not seeing it.  Even that AI on the Citadel that was stealing credits stated that organics would always attack synthetics and so deemed them enemies.  Seems like it had information about organics doing such things routinely.

Is it possible to coexist with synthetics?  I don't know.  We simply haven't seen any verifiable information that synthetics - as a rule - will dominate and destroy organics.  Given real life human society as a benchmark, the more likely scenario is that organics were use tech implants like SAM over creating sentient robots.  But I guess we'll have to wait and see.

That's Mac Walters for you - his understanding of scifie ended at the Matrix and Terminator. Especially fatal: The most alien thuing BW could come up for their NEW GALAXY was Bone-Borg and Emo-Cat-People.

During the walk through the Geth collective with Shepard and Legion we saw Geth gunning down Quarians,so we know that happened,we did not see or hear about Orbital bombardment from either side,so you are guessing at best mate, in fact you are making random stuff up,it's so much of a bald faced lie you should be embarrassed. 
The Quarians went Nazi on the Geth,you sure about that as the Quarians are the ones that are 17 million in number,Rannoch is not rubble,the Geth state in me3 they have been keeping the planet as pristine as they could on behalf of the creators.Your erroneous statements are beginning to get embarrassing,it is clear you will make up anything to justify why the Geth are poor misunderstood underdogs,you might have to change your name to Goebbels!