So is Mass Effect Andomeda MP going to be good or will they screw it up?

judges of these things like it when you improvise

Here's my small personal "hope list" .

*Actual servers. No more P2P BS. Enough is enough about the "host + 3 lagged as fuck clients" type of gameplay.
*No random rewards. Grab that fucking RNG store and cast it into the biggest fire the north Earth as ever seen.
How would I change it? Adding "challenge type rewards" . Complete a challenge and "X" item/s gets unlocked in the hypothetical store, and if you have the money, then you can buy it.
*No more synckill BS. Seriously that's stupid as fuck. You want to make a challenging AI? then make a challenging AI. Don't throw some hax-like type of bullshit in front of the players face.
*Bigger maps and greater variety of maps. This is the only thing I assume would be an actual feature in ME:A.
*Less monotone gameplay. I'm okay with the co-op and I hope they keep it that way, but I want more things to do in a round rather than shoot to death 11 waves of enemies with the occasional objective wave mixed in the middle.

I just read it in the E3-thread. And about the random rewards you mention: DAI MP rewards were worse. It had an urn model where each draw was replaced. Happy doublette times.

Fite me irl biotic babby.

DA:I was built on Frostbite and combat was bad. MP was bad. I think both MEA and MEAMP will be bad and we will still play ME3MP.

Even if by some unussual circumstances MEAMP will happen to be good, ME3MP will still remain a true classic, like the original Deus Ex or Diablo 2 for example. Or a more recent example: was Magicka 2 good? No, it wasn't. Dumbed down simplified cash grab. It was mediocre but Magicka 1 was a masterpiece. You cannot undo a masterpiece, and since BioWare as it was is no more, the people that made the original 3 games are not around anymore, it's just not in this realm of possibilities.

There is no way ME:A and it's MP will be anything like what ME3 was. I don't remember a one single successful attempt of revitalizing an old franchise with different developer team and making it stand up to the original. It can be mediocre at best. I will probably most likely be still here playing and modding ME3 after Andromeda release. Remember these words.

You ninja'd me before I added more words to my post. I only played DA:I MP a littel bit and immidatiely reinstalled ME3 after a few rounds. The combat and game modes were tedious to me. The lobby "room by room" progression was also not inspiring. Weapon drops, leveling and classes were not as cool and meaningful as what we had in ME3, even tough I was a big DA fan the classes and random weapons with "+x damage" stats just didn't speak to me compared to ME where every single piece of gear and a character/race felt important and meaningful. And overall the combat just didn't have the right feel for me. 

Maybe I bash it too hard. It wasn't really that bad and I could possibly still play it, it's just not something what I expected after ME3MP... It just feels quickly put together just because and design around grinding for random loot. It just doesn't capture the magic for me.

My conspiracy theory has been that the reason we lack information about MEA is because they decided to model it after Destiny. And at the time, it seemed like a great idea; Destiny was overhyped, but once it released, failed to live up to its hype. So now they are unsure of how to market a game that copies a flop. Meanwhile they are in a mad scramble to attempt to add/revise things that might make the game more fun.

Of course, this also means there is no Multiplayer Mode, it's all wrapped up into the campaign.

From the bits I've been reading, it's going to be Dragon Age: Inquisition....in space!

I look forward to many probings of planets for valuable minerals to fill N7 Pathfinder Requistion Orders that do nothing, spending hours tracking down Remnant Memory Shards that do nothing, and giant fucking space spiders everywhere.

 I'll trash ye' Cough by Cough m8, till ye eat the dirt chum

Yep, they did it with SW: Battlefront (Lack of content), BF: Hardline, etc...

I disagree about sync kills, if you are careless you die and it keeps even the best players on their toes.  At this point you simply cannot make good enough AI to deal with players that 'get gud'.  I don't overly care about syncs in the next game but I didn;t find much wrong with them in ME3mp, a lot of games would have been utter boredom.

Well I am sure bioware will listen more to their community now that they got rid of those pesky forums.