[Day/Night Game] Trouble on the Citadel - round "LE Part 2: Why Cerberus Is Right For You"

If that's a Mordin hint then it narrows my suspect list down to Romice and Reed. It's technically possible for Mordin to be evil, but I'm just gonna go ahead and vote for Reed. 2/3 shot anyway.

The crux of the matter is whether both spies were voting for Dusty. If not, then Catilina has to be a spy since every other person who voted for Romice is a proven hero.

The fact that Catilina voted for Romice proves nothing about Romice since it seems to be an established spy ploy to vote for one of their own to deflect suspicion that the two are collaborating. Catilina also did this early when it might not have seemed to place Romice in much danger.

Romice also voted for Moonae and only switched votes at the last minute to save herself, not because she accepted that Moonae was someone who should not be voted off. Her original vote for Moonae was after I had moved mine though and before it became apparent who Moonae might be. She was also willing to give Dragon the benefit of the doubt before Moonae expressed her confidence. So I am in two minds about Romice at present.

Reed voted for Dusty straight off but it could have just been random. However, I am still slightly bothered by the fact that when the choice was between someone claiming a good role and someone vaguely claiming a hero role, he kept his vote on the former. True, it could have been a false claim but that is equally so of the other person, and keeping his vote on a role that is known can only be good instead of switching to someone whose role could be either good or evil does seem odd. At the time I was making it quite clear that I was regretting my choice and even if Dusty had been claiming the role falsely she could not harm us with it.

I caused some of our problems by being too hasty last round so I am going to be a lot more cautious this one. In view of the doubts concerning Mordin, I am conscious that we can't afford to get it wrong this time.

I haven't voted for you yet, Reed. Would still like more information. You know, like a little clue as to who you might be.

Well, it seems to me that the last vote made it rather clear (at least in my pov) that the spies must be one of 3 players. Those being yourself, Romice, and Catilina. However, you have been potentially cleared via who we assume to be Liara. Now, I've never actually seen anyone dispute a claim in my time playing the games, but I assume it would happen should there be someone claiming a false role? But, I'd just like to remind everyone that anyone can claim any role in this game... so potentially some clever spy work could always be at play.

That said, I'm inclined to believe Liara here due to the lack of dispute of the claim. That leaves only 2 members not cleared in my pov: Romice and Catilina. 

Technically Fylimar did with Pela claiming her Varric last Skyhold game But yeah it's been rare

Well, I was hoping for more responses other than... "well you're suspicious!" before deciding on what to do. Literally the only people to say anything other than me is you and gervaise. What happens if catilina or romice hop and on and claim certain roles or even dispute current role claims? Since I'm under suspicion, I'm trying to be sure and not waste my votes. I've been burned by just trusting blind claims in previous games because contrary to what space said, fylimar didn't dispute the varric claim because we aren't allowed to hint in skyhold and pela claimed varric via pm under my cassandra power.

But if it pleases the court, your majesties, I'll vote for Romice.

What if I told you, there are certain roles where it does not help to hint at them because it would make you more suspicious to the heroes and a nice target for the villains at the same time? And that as such, if the spies knew the role, it'd make the situation worse for the heroes and not by me being eliminated...


ETA: And I said I was inclined to believe moonae because no one has disputed it, but not everyone has hinted, that could change. And I'm not even sure what Catilina said was a hint. How anyone got Mordin out of that is beyond me. lol

Well if I understand this hint correctly then for it to impact badly on us, the spies would need to focus on you during the night and there would be no elimination. However, I think they are hardly likely to do that at this stage because that would confirm your claim and the fact that the other person must be the spy.





This seemed to fit Mordin better than most, although I admit I am not that familiar with Kasumi. I am still waiting for some indication that someone else feels certain that Mordin is in the game. With 3 nights having passed he ought to have given out three protections and, even if evil, could only have given one to his fellow spy. So may be I did jump to the wrong conclusion about Catilina.

I'm still going to wait and see what develops before using my vote.

Objection - I did try to reclaim Varric, because Pela hinted not only via pm and I couldn't let that slide. That was the heated discussion, pela and I were having, because rules be damned, if I get my favorite character as a role I won't stand by and let some spy claim said role

I don't know Dragon Age as well as Mass Effect, so someone calling someone chuckles doesn't really register to me as anything. lol

To be fair, I wanted to execute you but the GM wouldn't let me cause of rules or something. Had to wait, and then the Gervaise elimination to varric happened D: so, even though I didn't get the hint, I wasn't completely fooled until the lucky break happened!!

It's the same with ME for me. I don't get a Lot of hints.