[Day/Night Game] Trouble on the Citadel - round "LE Part 2: Why Cerberus Is Right For You"

That I'm not sure of, it doesn't say in the first post like it does for other evils. Honestly the first post needs some more information posted lol

Right, and I'm confident she will survive the night

Thanks! I'll buy you a  ghost drink at the ghost bar

No, I meant the first post on this whole thread... about the roles. There needs to be more clear information on what evil versions of the heroes can do. If they can use their powers exactly as the hero does or what.

Oh, yeah agreed about that too.

Most of the heroes simply use their ability in exactly the same way. For example, Legion can sway the votes no matter whether they are good or evil, Javik blocks everyone equally on both sides.

The main differences which have not been made clear are that evil Kasumi actually blocks Liara from investigating for one night and evil Garrus cannot shoot his own side to appear innocent (a moot point in the current game). It is also not made explicit but if an evil Javik were to be voted off or shot by Garrus then Liara would still be so devastated that she would be unable to operate the following night.

Some evil characters have limited benefits to the spies. For example, if an evil Chakwas was eliminated after her fellow spy, then she could bring back her team-mate but everyone would already know they are the spy, so they would instantly be voted off again. However, if there were more than two spies in play then it would become more useful to them.

The problem with this Reed is that at present if we vote for Pela this round and she is Legion, then she will direct votes to someone else and whether she is good or evil that could end up with losing a hero, because there is enough doubt about the other players that even a good Legion could get it wrong. So at the end of the night we could be two heroes down and still none the wiser. Thus it seems preferable to leave Pela alone for the present and then vote for her tomorrow (assuming she survives the night) as by then there will be less options for her to get it wrong and so whether good or evil her choice will be revealing and we will still have sufficient heroes left the following day to vote her off.

Considering the various options, it does seem like the choice is between Dragon and Dusty in this round. That does not mean I rule out Space entirely from calculations but that it would be better to leave him in play for the present, given the role he seems to be claiming.

I think it highly unlikely that a good Garrus would shoot anyone in the night because of the potential to get it wrong. So if we do spare Dusty, even if evil, it is likely that only one hero would be eliminated overnight as shooting someone would flag Dusty up as the spy and could easily be voted off the following day. So in fact there is no more risk to leaving Dusty in play than there is leaving Dragon in terms of the damage they could do to the heroes overnight if evil.

Whilst a good Garrus could remove the problem of an evil Legion by shooting him in the night, as I say above, this could not happen until after another day's voting to be sure he got the right person and I actually think after this vote and another night's activity, it will be possible to resolve who is the spy without needing to go into further night in which Garrus could use his ability.

I still feel bad about voting for Dusty but this is my heart speaking rather than my head. Also I would equally feel bad about voting for Dragon simply because she seems an expendable role. However, there is one problem that makes me feel I should switch my vote to her and that is connected to the fact that she can only vote for the designated person. If we miss the spy this round and Dragon is forced to vote for a hero, that could present problems in the next round and definitely in the following round if it ends up going that far.

So on this basis, I am sorry Dragon but it does seem to make more sense to vote for you than for Dusty.

I change my vote from Dustyelf to Dragontartare

While I agree with your reasoning, given your role, I'd hope by the end of the night you'd be a little wiser

I still think you should force legion to use the power if she's even legion at all, because you all just said, dragon and dusty are expendable roles that you can still win without and this would force a potential evil legion out of her ability OR possibly eliminate an evil dragon or evil dusty with her power.

But I mean, who knows what catilina and even space can do with their powers so hopefully it works out for the heroes!

I followed you, but I'll wait to see what everyone else does again. They were all pretty quick to follow me last time.  I hope all these changes dont turn out to bite us in the end. (or anywhere else)

Dusty to Dragon then.