No wonder Casey Hudson left. This game is missing them sc-fi feels.

I didn't know I had to explain it. Do I really have to waste time in explaining this?

I think you might since you keep on going on how it isn't. When you do something like that, feelings are meaningless without references to back it up.

Here's a wiki page to get you started. Go nuts having fun comparing both games to it.

Not what a page defines it. How YOU define it. You're not understanding that your talking about something that is subjective. you're acting like it objective but it's not the case.  What you are using to criticize is a very unclear definition.

I already gave some comparisons.

1. You still dd not answer.

2.And I said being derelict does not mean it's scifi. Did you not get that?

3. No I'm not. that is literally what the codex says about the collectors. they are prothean husk. that what ME2 states it is. that is not the same as making organic life. Genetically modification is not the same as creating an organic race.  that's vastly 2 different things.
And the Kett are not the collectors. they are the borg 2.0.

1. Yes I did.
2. So you mean the derelict Reaper ship part of the game in ME2 wasn't sci-fi enough for you?
3. So what's you plan, to drown things out into super minor detail and pyramid quotes? I don't have time or patience for this.

Your tag is a reference to a movie about time travel that does not count it self  or makes  it's own actions point less. you want to talk about suspense of disbelief being shattered?

The only thing in MEA that come close to shattering any disbelief was the end of the asari act mission were they used a barrier to defect missiles back to a kett ship.

What's the matter?  Is your face tired?  

Genius troll thread, by the way.  The repetition of "Casey Hudson" in every line culminating in the "Best wishes to Casey Hudson" insincerity, paired with a hilariously bad picture of him.  I laughed.  Never thought you'd make it this far, but what did I know?  Congrats.

I know other people will have differing opinions. But this, here, to me is the crux of the whole thing.

A lot of people who liked ME2 are saying that ME:A's story is bad, and a lot of the point out "suspension of disbelief" areas to explain what they mean.

To me, ME2 completely DESTROYED any sense of suspension of disbelief within the first 5 minutes.  I generally take these kinda games, and either do a "dry run" to establish what I want my canon to be, or make a throw-away character to learn the game for a few hours before I start any "main" run.

My secondary Shepard, a Sole Survivor from ME1, was the first Shep I took into ME2....and the whole trite, stupidly conceived Lazarus project that was only there to ham-handedly force us to work with Cerberus completely WRECKED any connection I had for the second game, and the trilogy in general.  I won't go into too many details, but that first 5 minutes of ME2 set the "tone" for ME2 and ME3 for me.  IF I turned my brain off, and looked at the last two games as separate games in and of themselves, I could enjoy them for what they were.  As sequels to ME1, though, hell no. 

So, yeah, ME:A has some issues with the story, some typical Bioware "wtf?!?" moments, but it was VASTLY better than ME2 and ME3 for me.  I won't pretend the writing could be better, and I wont deny that the initial rollout and presentation of ME:A was...well, piss poor may be a BIT of a stretch, but pretty darned bad sums it for me.  But that, while certainly not good, and worth criticizing, is VASTLY better than the trite BS that ME2 and ME3 gave me. 

Again, different people, different opinions.  I'm just a little more willing to put up with the flaws of ME:A, simply because to me it's a vast improvement over the latter 2/3d's of the MET, and that it was a solidly good step back towards the "feel" of ME1.  It missed that bar, by a fair margin in places, but it was much closer to ME1 than ME2 or ME3 ever THOUGHT they could be.

I played on pc. so I did not get that. Add, ME1 in the xbox had alot of the same issues. The Asari have an accent is not an issue as much as a quarian have a similar accent.