Syv
N3
Posts: 882 Likes: 2,986
inherit
2079
0
Nov 14, 2016 15:32:17 GMT
2,986
Syv
882
Nov 13, 2016 18:49:33 GMT
November 2016
syv
|
Post by Syv on Dec 21, 2016 19:30:00 GMT
@ Daveliam I will keep an open mind.
@ toast I'm pretty sure that some transgender folks would be able to do the difference with folks who do not initially reject them unlike many, even if these people do not exactly share their beliefs, these guys ready to accept them for what they are while not totally willing to play a game with pronouns and trying to be as courteous as possible at the same time. For example calling them with their first name as much as possible when talking about them or to them ( though not always possible when it is spontaneous ). You don't have to argue with them about what they are, like I read above, I don't really understand this need to go to the worst examples. There is a middle line.
For a transman, the first name. But it could happen that I say she in a spontaenous way, not because I want to insult, but because that's what I have in my mind. That would annoy me very much that several folks would jump on me to correct me over that.
Also, I would not tell to a trans, what I think, I don't need to. But if I talk about him behind his back with other friends, I would not play with pronouns. And if there are people who would tell me, " please says she ", I would answer them that they are out of line and they shouldn't push. If it is a problem for them, then go away. You won't make me change my opinion that way. Because from there, that would be a dogma that I would be forced to follow, it wouldn't be about being courteous.
You have to be patient, at least for me. The struggle is real so far, don't underestimate it, even if for you, it's easy, it's nothing. For others it might not,, especially in a sizeable part of the society. Either you accept it, either you don't and then there is nothing more to say at this point and we are bound to never understand each other. If it is that much an issue, since the beginning, it isn't going to work, i'm sorry. Someone can change its way of thinking thanks to a close relationship that started carefully at the beginning for example, thanks to patience and empathy. Nothing tells that I couldn't change my mind after spending some good times with that person for example. Nothing says that thanks to an awesome person I like, face to face finally, my feelings could change. But still, you'll have to understand that initially it isn't just one way, one person, there are two folks with two minds, with two different ways of seeing things, two philosophies. I keep thinking it's neutral, I' m just being authentic and it's hard for me to believe that by just being authentic in a very neutral way with neutral words, I'm doing something wrong. If someone really thinks he is an alien, no, I reject this idea that because I consider him as a human and treats him as such, because that's what he is to me, I'm responsible of his state. That's a red line I'm not able to reach.
For the moment, when i read some folks, It's more likely that I am never going to risk talking to a transgender person and to spend some time with that person, if it is so much an issue. You are more discouraging me than anything else at this point. I do not mean to insult, But so far I consider as neutral what you don't consider as neutral.
I'd like to point out that before I knew this forum, I never talked to gay people, never learned their story, I live in a very heteronormative society. In real life, I have never seen two folks of the same sex kissing eah other on the streets; i changed my way of seeing things thanks to friendship with a few on this forum, people sharing their stories, people being reasonable and patient, not thanks to those who where yelling things like omg straight guys are evil. These people made hostile actually. Being ignorant of what lgbt could live and suffer in their life, I was shocked the first times to fall on all these hostile messages, and it took me one whole year on the bsn to see beyond that, to understand the frustration behind that thanks to reasonable folks, more able than others to explain their point. The big shift happened when I talked with a lesbian in several mps. After that, I saw things in a different way. It could maybe happen with a transgender too, who knows ?
But that would require not calling me an asshole in the first place. If you do so, then i can ony say gtfo ? and that's where ends the story. It's easy. You would be wrong thinking that people would care about what others think, if they feel they have done nothing.
If it is really an horribl issue, then it is very likely that I'm never going to be friends with transgenders. if it is the only way to not " insult transgenders ", so be it.
|
|
Syv
N3
Posts: 882 Likes: 2,986
inherit
2079
0
Nov 14, 2016 15:32:17 GMT
2,986
Syv
882
Nov 13, 2016 18:49:33 GMT
November 2016
syv
|
Post by Syv on Dec 21, 2016 19:33:29 GMT
There's a lot of things that I don't get/understand or simply disagree with, but I still do because otherwise I might hurt or offend others, whereas it would (admittedly) simply inconvenience me. There used to be a time where I didn't shake people's hands when greeting, didn't kiss family on the cheek when greeting, didn't look them in the eyes during conversations nor did I thank people for their gifts (yes, I was a major asshole). Some of them I understand now, but others I still don't, yet nowadays I politely shake hands, kiss family on the cheek, look people in the eyes and voice my gratitude for gifts, because not doing so would offend or hurt people, ranging from strangers to family. Eventually it became a matter of a trade-off: simply inconvenience myself or hurt others? As for the last point: I agree, the unusual pronouns does cheapen and mock those suffering from gender disphoria and you're welcome to bring up that discussion with whomever wants you to use those pronouns, but simply refusing to use someone's pronouns isn't going to change that or convince that person their pronouns are harmful, you'll just anger/hurt them at best. Unless you truly don't care about hurting people's feelings, or are willing to sacrifice absolutely nothing of yourself to avoid it. If that's the case, well, hate to break it to you - that makes you kind of an asshole, and you shouldn't be surprised when people call you out on it.If there are people who dare going that road, I will tell them to fuck off. They better ignore me. I don't give a shit about their judgemental opinions.
|
|
inherit
57
0
Member is Online
1
35,524
SofaJockey
Not a jockey. Has a sofa.
13,923
August 2016
sofajockey
SofaJockey
SofaJockey
6000
7164
|
Post by SofaJockey on Dec 21, 2016 19:35:27 GMT
... I will keep an open mind. ... ^ This is this the bit that really matters, in my view
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
Deleted
inherit
guest@proboards.com
92
0
Deleted
0
January 1970
Deleted
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 21, 2016 20:13:27 GMT
^ This is this the bit that really matters, in my view I know, right? And that's why I bang on about these things long after most people think I should have stopped. Because if I can help with that, it was worth it! Go us! Maybe I'll take back that PM I sent to Nata saying that I was done with the board, now..... <stupid melodramatic me>
|
|
inherit
2151
0
Dec 20, 2016 21:34:27 GMT
4,309
fialka
1,112
Nov 21, 2016 14:39:12 GMT
November 2016
fialka
|
Post by fialka on Dec 21, 2016 20:22:10 GMT
Unless you truly don't care about hurting people's feelings, or are willing to sacrifice absolutely nothing of yourself to avoid it. If that's the case, well, hate to break it to you - that makes you kind of an asshole, and you shouldn't be surprised when people call you out on it.If there are people who dare going that road, I will tell them to fuck off. They better ignore me. I don't give a shit about their judgemental opinions. Here's the thing though... And I realize this is an emotional topic for both sides, but, you say you want to understand. Maybe I'm not the right person to try to make anyone understand. I'm blunt to a fault, and can come across as combative. It's who I am. I try not be rude, but I can't help but react. Unfortunately I'm bad at keeping my mouth shut, so here goes nothing... It come down to this: trans people struggle a lot. You said in your other post that coming to terms with this idea is a struggle for you, and to not underestimate that. And I get that, really. If it's not something you've ever been exposed to, it's hard to wrap your head around. And if you've never met a real trans person, it can be hard to have empathy for an abstract idea. But don't underestimate their struggles either. The bullying, the ridicule, the friends and family who will never accept them. The relationships with people they won't get to have, or will fear losing because of 'what' they are, not who they are. And yet, they're willing to go through all that because being born in the body they ended up with feels that wrong to them. On a personal level, to be honest, I don't get it either. I was born in a female body, and it 'fits' just fine, but I don't feel particularly bound to that. I genuinely feel that if I'd been born male instead, I'd be good with it. I see myself as a person. The 'woman' part is a biological accident, and convenient because I like dudes so I get a bigger dating pool But this is where that whole empathy thing comes in. I understand that these people struggle. I don't want to add to it. And I know, from reading online and speaking with actual trans people who have been friends, coworkers, etc., that having people refuse to call them by their preferred pronoun can really hurt. Often people do it intentionally to hurt, to mock, insult, ridicule. So regardless of your intentions, it will likely come across as mean, no matter how polite you try to be otherwise. And in the case of a person who has already transitioned and is passing (i.e. a post-op woman you'd never know was born male if she didn't tell you) 'outing' them by using the wrong pronoun can even endanger their safety. Hate crimes that target transgender people are unfortunately very prevalent. Not saying people shouldn't forgive an accidental slip-up, understanding should go both ways. I still feel it doesn't cost much to try. Again, as a person with ASD to whom polite behavior does not come naturally, I think it's worth the effort.
|
|
Destructive Deer
N2
Games: Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquistion, KOTOR, Baldur's Gate, Jade Empire
Posts: 101 Likes: 305
inherit
1256
0
Aug 26, 2016 18:56:43 GMT
305
Destructive Deer
101
Aug 26, 2016 18:54:43 GMT
August 2016
toastedllama
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquistion, KOTOR, Baldur's Gate, Jade Empire
|
Post by Destructive Deer on Dec 21, 2016 20:35:46 GMT
@ Daveliam I will keep an open mind. @ toast I'm pretty sure that some transgender folks would be able to do the difference with folks who do not initially reject them unlike many, even if these people do not exactly share their beliefs, these guys ready to accept them for what they are while not totally willing to play a game with pronouns and trying to be as courteous as possible at the same time. For example calling them with their first name as much as possible when talking about them or to them ( though not always possible when it is spontaneous ). You don't have to argue with them about what they are, like I read above, I don't really understand this need to go to the worst examples. There is a middle line. For a transman, the first name. But it could happen that I say she in a spontaenous way, not because I want to insult, but because that's what I have in my mind. That would annoy me very much that several folks would jump on me to correct me over that. Also, I would not tell to a trans, what I think, I don't need to. But if I talk about him behind his back with other friends, I would not play with pronouns. And if there are people who would tell me, " please says she ", I would answer them that they are out of line and they shouldn't push. If it is a problem for them, then go away. You won't make me change my opinion that way. Because from there, that would be a dogma that I would be forced to follow, it wouldn't be about being courteous. You have to be patient, at least for me. The struggle is real so far, don't underestimate it, even if for you, it's easy, it's nothing. For others it might not,, especially in a sizeable part of the society. Either you accept it, either you don't and then there is nothing more to say at this point and we are bound to never understand each other. If it is that much an issue, since the beginning, it isn't going to work, i'm sorry. Someone can change its way of thinking thanks to a close relationship that started carefully at the beginning for example, thanks to patience and empathy. Nothing tells that I couldn't change my mind after spending some good times with that person for example. Nothing says that thanks to an awesome person I like, face to face finally, my feelings could change. But still, you'll have to understand that initially it isn't just one way, one person, there are two folks with two minds, with two different ways of seeing things, two philosophies. I keep thinking it's neutral, I' m just being authentic and it's hard for me to believe that by just being authentic in a very neutral way with neutral words, I'm doing something wrong. If someone really thinks he is an alien, no, I reject this idea that because I consider him as a human and treats him as such, because that's what he is to me, I'm responsible of his state. That's a red line I'm not able to reach. For the moment, when i read some folks, It's more likely that I am never going to risk talking to a transgender person and to spend some time with that person, if it is so much an issue. You are more discouraging me than anything else at this point. I do not mean to insult, But so far I consider as neutral what you don't consider as neutral. I'd like to point out that before I knew this forum, I never talked to gay people, never learned their story, I live in a very heteronormative society. In real life, I have never seen two folks of the same sex kissing eah other on the streets; i changed my way of seeing things thanks to friendship with a few on this forum, people sharing their stories, people being reasonable and patient, not thanks to those who where yelling things like omg straight guys are evil. These people made hostile actually. Being ignorant of what lgbt could live and suffer in their life, I was shocked the first times to fall on all these hostile messages, and it took me one whole year on the bsn to see beyond that, to understand the frustration behind that thanks to reasonable folks, more able than others to explain their point. The big shift happened when I talked with a lesbian in several mps. After that, I saw things in a different way. It could maybe happen with a transgender too, who knows ? But that would require not calling me an asshole in the first place. If you do so, then i can ony say gtfo ? and that's where ends the story. It's easy. You would be wrong thinking that people would care about what others think, if they feel they have done nothing. If it is really an horribl issue, then it is very likely that I'm never going to be friends with transgenders. if it is the only way to not " insult transgenders ", so be it. Actually I think your comment nicely highlights why courtesy is so important (from both sides). Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong but you are clearly turned off by the more aggressive and demeaning type of people, those who start ranting and raging at you for simple things. Those are the type of people you should avoid regardless. Admittedly there are many of them as this topic is very emotional to many, as one group feels oppressed by another. (Though obviously it's wrong to direct this anger at those who mean no harm.) Evidently that just results into more anger and hate, eventually reaching an endless cycle of animosity. Nonetheless: If you are polite and kind to others, if you are courteous, they will return with politeness and kindness of their own, as well as have a lot more patience with you. You will find much more pleasant dialogue/discussions and people are much more willing to approach things from your perspective, as well as be very forgiving of potential mistakes. If despite your courtesy people are still treating you like dirt you have all the reasons to ignore and avoid them. You're not an asshole or wrong if you do so. It's all up to you whether you consider it worth it though, but just keep in mind that courtesy can go a long way. (Speaking of courtesy from both sides: if my initial comment came off as rude; my apologies! I've obviously been guilty of being an asshole myself as well.)
|
|
Destructive Deer
N2
Games: Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquistion, KOTOR, Baldur's Gate, Jade Empire
Posts: 101 Likes: 305
inherit
1256
0
Aug 26, 2016 18:56:43 GMT
305
Destructive Deer
101
Aug 26, 2016 18:54:43 GMT
August 2016
toastedllama
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquistion, KOTOR, Baldur's Gate, Jade Empire
|
Post by Destructive Deer on Dec 21, 2016 20:45:50 GMT
If there are people who dare going that road, I will tell them to fuck off. They better ignore me. I don't give a shit about their judgemental opinions. Often people do it intentionally to hurt, to mock, insult, ridicule. So regardless of your intentions, it will likely come across as mean, no matter how polite you try to be otherwise. And in the case of a person who has already transitioned and is passing (i.e. a post-op woman you'd never know was born male if she didn't tell you) 'outing' them by using the wrong pronoun can even endanger their safety. Hate crimes that target transgender people are unfortunately very prevalent.THIS, so much this. This is why it's so important to use their preferred pronouns, even if you don't understand or agree, even if other people have been a total dick to you. It's SO hard to know someone's intentions, since people can't read eachother's minds.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
Deleted
inherit
guest@proboards.com
49
0
Deleted
0
January 1970
Deleted
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 21, 2016 21:28:49 GMT
I'd like to point out that before I knew this forum, I never talked to gay people, never learned their story, I live in a very heteronormative society. In real life, I have never seen two folks of the same sex kissing eah other on the streets; i changed my way of seeing things thanks to friendship with a few on this forum, people sharing their stories, people being reasonable and patient, not thanks to those who where yelling things like omg straight guys are evil. These people made hostile actually. Being ignorant of what lgbt could live and suffer in their life, I was shocked the first times to fall on all these hostile messages, and it took me one whole year on the bsn to see beyond that, to understand the frustration behind that thanks to reasonable folks, more able than others to explain their point. The big shift happened when I talked with a lesbian in several mps. After that, I saw things in a different way. It could maybe happen with a transgender too, who knows ? I think the worst part of stuff like this is understanding... like... people cant really imagine it, its an alien concept to lots of people
But everyone has different experiences with it, like ive had a fairly good one comparatively... never really struggled with figuring out who I was, just something ive always known. I never really "came out" to my mom... I met my first girlfriend in an lgbt club-thing in high school and while I think my mom might have suspected something beforehand I didnt discuss it, I just started dating my first girlfriend and introduced them, my mom is amazing so just like... it didnt really matter if I was a lesbian or straight, she was just happy for me
But my current girlfriend??? like... it took YEARS for her to figure out who she was... when we first met she told me how she struggled to like... know what she was feeling and why she was feeling it
But even for me, its hard to imagine an lgbtq person growing up in a family which arent open minded like my mom, and to imagine how they must feel...
Its a sore subject for lots of people I guess... some people fear/hate/dislike/don't understand lgbtq people... and some others have suffered BECAUSE of that, whether on a family, personal or government level... people have suffered and still DO suffer, and theres a risk that even more people might suffer in the future
And when people suffer... being reasonable can stop sometimes
But for me... understanding is the most important thing anyone could ever show... and the more people you talk to, the more youll understand, and the more you understand, the less people will suffer
When people say things like they have "things shoved down their throats"... I can kinda understand it, in a way, not about some things but at times I can understand why people would think like that But if people are to stop suffering (which kinda needs to happen) people need to be comfortable with it, and the more representation they get, the more information thats shared and experiences listened to... the more people will get comfortable with it, the more people will understand, and the less people will suffer
Its hard to get a balance right... because to get people to understand you need to start like at the beginning, almost like starting with the basics... but if you do that, youll upset some lgbtq people because like... its important that gender and sexuality arent all theyre being represented as, that theres "more to them" than that, that theres more they care about in a way... but then people will also complain about things being shoved down their throats... its hard from a writers perspective to make everyone happy
|
|
inherit
738
0
4,633
Link"Guess"ski
3,882
August 2016
linkenski
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, KOTOR, Mass Effect Andromeda
Linkenski
asblinkenski
Linkenski
|
Post by Link"Guess"ski on Dec 21, 2016 21:50:51 GMT
I try to be supportive of the trans people I know in real life, and will use he/she/they if they ask me to, but I draw the line at made up pronouns. If a non trans person asked me to address them as "lord or lady" I would refuse because it comes across as them being pompous and self-important. And, although it may sound mean, I feel the same way about weird and obscure pronouns. Nobody should have to memorize your bizarre pronouns, that's just causing everyone you meet an unnecessary hassle. I had a friend at university who was a trans woman and she hated people who would request weird and obscure pronouns because she felt like they were trying to politicize their identity and gave other trans people a bad name. Telling people you identify as butter, however serious you are, cheapens and mocks people who legitimately suffer from gender dysphoria. It makes it much harder to the average person who doesn't really understand the topic to take trans people as a whole seriously. Interestingly, despite my stance on this topic, I'm also a bit mixed on the gender neutral pronouns. It feels a bit self-indulgent. That being said, if I were ever asked to use one, I'd almost certainly use it because of all of the reasons that I've already stated. It costs me nothing and I think it's respectful to do. I also don't think it's very common at all. I mean, I work in NYC. I run a graduate program (and higher education tends to be a place where you see more dialogue on gender). And I have pretty substantial experience with the LGBT community through volunteer work and my social life. And I've never once had someone ask me to use a gender neutral pronoun with them. Amen. I have long accepted that I am okay with identifying as my gender of origin and people'll call me "dude, sir, mr, bro, boy, man" etc.. You don't wanna be male or female? Fine, but if you want to be in between then you're a "trans" or "trans" or "boygirl" in my book. I don't care. The world does not have to satisfy your self-imposed demands. People who are in the vein of "I identify as XYZ, don't ever use gender-pronouns!" are a bunch of narcissists.
|
|
Destructive Deer
N2
Games: Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquistion, KOTOR, Baldur's Gate, Jade Empire
Posts: 101 Likes: 305
inherit
1256
0
Aug 26, 2016 18:56:43 GMT
305
Destructive Deer
101
Aug 26, 2016 18:54:43 GMT
August 2016
toastedllama
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquistion, KOTOR, Baldur's Gate, Jade Empire
|
Post by Destructive Deer on Dec 21, 2016 22:03:32 GMT
Actually I think your comment nicely highlights why courtesy is so important (from both sides). Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong but you are clearly turned off by the more aggressive and demeaning type of people, those who start ranting and raging at you for simple things. Those are the type of people you should avoid regardless. Admittedly there are many of them as this topic is very emotional to many, as one group feels oppressed by another. (Though obviously it's wrong to direct this anger at those who mean no harm.) Evidently that just results into more anger and hate, eventually reaching an endless cycle of animosity. Nonetheless: If you are polite and kind to others, if you are courteous, they will return with politeness and kindness of their own, as well as have a lot more patience with you. You will find much more pleasant dialogue/discussions and people are much more willing to approach things from your perspective, as well as be very forgiving of potential mistakes. If despite your courtesy people are still treating you like dirt you have all the reasons to ignore and avoid them. You're not an asshole or wrong if you do so. It's all up to you whether you consider it worth it though, but just keep in mind that courtesy can go a long way. (Speaking of courtesy from both sides: if my initial comment came off as rude; my apologies! I've obviously been guilty of being an asshole myself as well.) On the subject of courtesy: I see here a sort of assumption that courtesy would demand that I (for example) would use the preferred pronouns of the person in front of me. From my point of view that's a very skewed view of courtesy, most especially when it comes to made up pronouns. A courteous person wouldn't start making demands from a person they just met (or anyone really) especially not the kind of demands that would inconvenience them and force them to change their usual speech patterns, in short it's a hassle to remember whatever that newfangled pronoun is and use them correctly. I supposed it could be more acceptable to request something like this from a friend or a close acquaintance, but aside from that, making this demand in the name of courtesy seems to me like double standards. The difference between a request and a demand is huge. A request is courteous, a demand is not. Asking for something is not inherently discourteous.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
Deleted
inherit
guest@proboards.com
92
0
Deleted
0
January 1970
Deleted
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 21, 2016 22:17:57 GMT
On the subject of courtesy: I see here a sort of assumption that courtesy would demand that I (for example) would use the preferred pronouns of the person in front of me. From my point of view that's a very skewed view of courtesy, most especially when it comes to made up pronouns. A courteous person wouldn't start making demands from a person they just met (or anyone really) especially not the kind of demands that would inconvenience them and force them to change their usual speech patterns, in short it's a hassle to remember whatever that newfangled pronoun is and use them correctly. I supposed it could be more acceptable to request something like this from a friend or a close acquaintance, but aside from that, making this demand in the name of courtesy seems to me like double standards. I have a legitimate question, but feel free to tell me to shove off and not answer. Have you ever had a face-to-face conservation with a trans person and had their gender come up? My impression based on your statements is that you haven't, but I could very well be wrong which is why I wanted to ask. From my experience, I've never had a conversation with a trans person who has demanded anything. I think that this is another example of people thinking that the tumblr crowd is representational of trans people and their experiences.
|
|
inherit
Resident Diplomat
526
0
8,896
Natashina
In lurking mode, playing the ME games.
2,340
August 2016
natashina
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, KOTOR, Neverwinter Nights
16,553
19,139
|
Post by Natashina on Dec 21, 2016 22:33:52 GMT
I have a legitimate question, but feel free to tell me to shove off and not answer. Have you ever had a face-to-face conservation with a trans person and had their gender come up? My impression based on your statements is that you haven't, but I could very well be wrong which is why I wanted to ask. From my experience, I've never had a conversation with a trans person who has demanded anything. I think that this is another example of people thinking that the tumblr crowd is representational of trans people and their experiences. Or that people always behave the same offline as they do on the internet in general.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
Deleted
inherit
guest@proboards.com
49
0
Deleted
0
January 1970
Deleted
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 21, 2016 23:24:57 GMT
|
|
inherit
57
0
Member is Online
1
35,524
SofaJockey
Not a jockey. Has a sofa.
13,923
August 2016
sofajockey
SofaJockey
SofaJockey
6000
7164
|
Post by SofaJockey on Dec 22, 2016 0:38:44 GMT
... Have you ever had a face-to-face conservation with a trans person and had their gender come up? ... I suspect we all have such different experiences (or lack of them) which shape our views. I once managed someone at work who was going through a transition to a trans woman. To put it bluntly, she looked like a big guy who had donned a dress and a wig and (inexpertly) popped on some makeup. But talking to someone in front of you who is plainly on a desperately tough journey makes academic debates about pronouns moot. The last thing she needed was a boss who didn't have her back or who was unkind on points of linguistics. Taking this right back to games, all I think BioWare needs to do in its worlds populated with NPCs is to show humanity that looks like 'us', and 'us' includes many different folk. The reason this topic is discussion-worthy is that trans characters have not traditionally been included in 'us', within games. If that happens within a populous RPG with multiple interesting characters and storylines, that's just fine.
|
|
Syv
N3
Posts: 882 Likes: 2,986
inherit
2079
0
Nov 14, 2016 15:32:17 GMT
2,986
Syv
882
Nov 13, 2016 18:49:33 GMT
November 2016
syv
|
Post by Syv on Dec 22, 2016 3:26:03 GMT
Alright people, you won, you got me. I'll be considerate and " courteous " by saying she or he according to what the transgender person prefers. You suceeded to convince me of the necessity to do this ( without feeling guilty of thinking that i am just submitting myself to a forced process for a wrong reason, which was very important to me ), you found the words to move me, to make me want to do it myself, because I want to, and not because of pressure. I can be obstinate sometimes if i truly believe something, but I have a heart, I am not totally insensitive, and I can be also convinced by reasonable arguments. @ Fialka You have probably said why it was probably so difficult for me to understand. You succeeded to move me with your words about the struggle of transgenders without dismissing my own feelings and struggle on this matter. It was quite effective, I admit. It's' true that I have not been much exposed to all of this in the end. Never talked to a trans. It remained an abstract idea. Hence maybe this difficulty to imagine why it should matter so much that I have to choose a particular pronoun wanted in spite of what I could think as an individual who just wants peace and freedom. @ Toast, good post. I mostly agree with your post. And yes you got it. Thanks for being " courteous " lol ! See folks, you suceeded to convince me with a discussion, not stigmatization over differences in our beliefs. Case closed, I think.
|
|
inherit
Resident Diplomat
526
0
8,896
Natashina
In lurking mode, playing the ME games.
2,340
August 2016
natashina
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, KOTOR, Neverwinter Nights
16,553
19,139
|
Post by Natashina on Dec 22, 2016 3:44:09 GMT
Now this warms my heart to read. I think this fits:
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
Deleted
inherit
guest@proboards.com
49
0
Deleted
0
January 1970
Deleted
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 22, 2016 8:14:15 GMT
Awwwwwwwwwwwwwww Lovely thing to come home from work to! So happy I think that this discussion was great like... it... was a good thing So many threads on this forum i kinda say wont end well for lots of reasons, but this is a thread which HAS... Youre all awesome *hugs* Wish more people could be like the people in this thread then everything would be so much better be happy! Also maybe relevant
|
|
inherit
Wanted Apostate
127
0
18,270
Catilina
11,035
August 2016
catilina
Top
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, KOTOR, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire, Mass Effect Andromeda
|
Post by Catilina on Dec 22, 2016 13:35:06 GMT
I do not really understand this debate about the pronouns. I have never occurred to me to use it differently than the person would like, with whom I talk. Frankly, for me no matter, which pronoun I use, when I speak about/with someone. To HIM/HER matter. So why I NOT could use, that s/he want? I can not imagine, what helps when forcing your will, even if you do not agree with? If you think he/her is "not normal/sick", that will "change/heal" him/her, if you disagree with his/her request? Hardly. The only thing that causes: some bad day/depression for him/her. Don't worth it!
|
|
inherit
2151
0
Dec 20, 2016 21:34:27 GMT
4,309
fialka
1,112
Nov 21, 2016 14:39:12 GMT
November 2016
fialka
|
Post by fialka on Dec 22, 2016 14:38:36 GMT
@ Fialka You have probably said why it was probably so difficult for me to understand. You succeeded to move me with your words about the struggle of transgenders without dismissing my own feelings and struggle on this matter. It was quite effective, I admit. It's' true that I have not been much exposed to all of this in the end. Never talked to a trans. It remained an abstract idea. Hence maybe this difficulty to imagine why it should matter so much that I have to choose a particular pronoun wanted in spite of what I could think as an individual who just wants peace and freedom. Thank you... I'm kind of lost for words, actually I'm glad I was able to move you with my post - not because I wanted to be right, but because I think this issue is such an important one. And it goes to demonstrate that discussions like these are not pointless - but they can only work if both sides listen to one another. We won't get anywhere if we jump to conclusions about people and judge them based on our assumptions. This is something I need to work on as well! It also goes to demonstrate, I think, why good portrayals of diverse characters are so important. Be they in games, film, whatever. Perhaps the mixed opinions on Krem indicate a missed opportunity. Personally, I thought the character and the writing were fine... but the way he and Iron Bull got super defensive when my character started asking questions (questions I, the player, chose to have her ask because I was curious about Krem's backstory and what I could learn about the world from it) put me off . Because they assumed something about my character's attitude that I did not intend for her to have. Now, for me that was a mild annoyance, one I was able to forgive because I thought the inclusion of a trans character was such a great thing to see in a AAA game. But I'm starting to see how, for players who might not know much about this issue or hadn't given it much thought before, it could come across as preachy or jarring. Where it could've been an eye-opening moment that brought a little bit of understanding and compassion instead. So here's to hoping we see more good, well-written, diverse characters in the future, and, that they do it a little better next time Although... Whether you like Krem or not, you gotta admit he sparked quite the conversation here!
|
|
inherit
The Unbelievable
752
0
4,176
Panda
1,410
August 2016
panda
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquistion, Jade Empire
|
Post by Panda on Dec 22, 2016 15:16:19 GMT
It sure is easier when language doesn't have gendered pronouns, no chance of using wrong one either by mistake.
I wish English was so as well, cause I always mix up he and she when writing and have to check my texts for that before posting ^^;
|
|
inherit
Wanted Apostate
127
0
18,270
Catilina
11,035
August 2016
catilina
Top
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, KOTOR, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire, Mass Effect Andromeda
|
Post by Catilina on Dec 22, 2016 15:19:51 GMT
I do not really understand this debate about the pronouns. I have never occurred to me to use it differently than the person would like, with whom I talk. Frankly, for me no matter, which pronoun I use, when I speak about/with someone. To HIM/HER matter. So why I NOT could use, that s/he want? I can not imagine, what helps when forcing your will, even if you do not agree with? If you think he/her is "not normal/sick", that will "change/heal" him/her, if you disagree with his/her request? Hardly. The only thing that causes: some bad day/depression for him/her. Don't worth it! Here is a list of *some* of the pronouns out there, just to illustrate how deep this rabbit hole goes. You should not return here. This already mentioned, and answered. But okay, then again,as you wish: Most of these are not typical. I've even seen them on Tumblr (never experienced in the real life – probably because our language don't have gender based pronouns...). In most cases, they were written next to them: OR, it/they, s/he. SO: this "extreme" pronouns mostly not forced... In any way, I don't think, this pronouns would request typically by transgender people. This is typically gender-fluid or other sexual identity defining request. (As I see – but I'm not expert on the subject.)
|
|
inherit
Wanted Apostate
127
0
18,270
Catilina
11,035
August 2016
catilina
Top
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquisition, KOTOR, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire, Mass Effect Andromeda
|
Post by Catilina on Dec 22, 2016 16:01:00 GMT
You should not return here. ... I shouldn't return here?... Errr... No. That's not how it goes. I go where I please. I'm going to assume you meant to say something else and simply have difficulties with english. In any case my point is that rare or not, these things exist, and I'd be very careful in any case about moralizing at other people in order to make them change their speech patterns. Offer others the same courtesy you wish them to show you. Respect their preferences, you personal preferences are not important enough to override others. Enjoy the freedom to be whatever you want and think whatever you want, but don't try to to impose your will on others, just as they do not impose their will on you. Oh, I see... sorry. Just wanted to say, that someone mentioned that, and people answered, much better, than I would be able for it. (I rather wrote about s/he, they pronouns. I don't know about, how people uses the others. But the s/he, they mostly good enough. – As I see.)
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
Deleted
inherit
guest@proboards.com
49
0
Deleted
0
January 1970
Deleted
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 22, 2016 16:22:14 GMT
I have a legitimate question, but feel free to tell me to shove off and not answer. Have you ever had a face-to-face conservation with a trans person and had their gender come up? My impression based on your statements is that you haven't, but I could very well be wrong which is why I wanted to ask. From my experience, I've never had a conversation with a trans person who has demanded anything. I think that this is another example of people thinking that the tumblr crowd is representational of trans people and their experiences. A long conversation? Not exactly. I did have a few short conversations where various people let me know what I'm "supposed" to call them. (I worked for a while as a secretary / aide) And one embarrassing encounter in particular where I referred to someone (not out of any malicious intent) as a male and he/she angrily demanded to be referred to as female. So I think that the discussion about courtesy is relevant to the topic, and that enlisting courtesy as an argument in this case is hasty and depends heavily on the situation. Edit: Also, you might notice that I was referring more to made-up pronouns than someone asking to be referred to as he or she. You should treat people as you want to be treated, not how they treat you or how youve been treated by others ... applies so long as youre not a masochist, in which case just be nice to people There isnt some kind of battle about what you can and cant say, just things people feel strongly about, and like... if you want a nice conversation with someone then it would be a good thing to do it for their sake baring in mind its something which has probably happened mannnyyy times before... even the smallest something can make someone happy, and acting in kindness will inspire kindness in others also
|
|
inherit
Korean Supermodel
1
0
1
7,464
Cyonan
2,189
Jul 31, 2016 20:55:30 GMT
July 2016
admin
Cyonan
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquistion, KOTOR, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire
Cyonan
|
Post by Cyonan on Dec 22, 2016 23:00:55 GMT
My general rule for gender pronouns is to refer to the person by whatever they physically are. If they wish to correct me they may do so and I'll attempt to use the proper variant of he/she. Beyond that I don't get into the other ones because we are a binary gendered species, and using a different term for "born male but identifies as female"(I think this is a thing, I don't really keep up with it) seems like an inefficient and non-intuitive use of the English language that just hinders communication when using she would have worked just as well.
I don't really view gender identity in the same way most people do but if asked I'll tell them to just use male pronouns because that's what I physically am.
As far as this pertaining to Mass Effect Andromeda I don't as particularly care if they include such characters, but I'd rather them be full blown characters that are interesting in their own right as opposed to somebody like Krem in DA:I who felt like more of a walking PSA.
Basically I want the characters to be well written more than I want them to be any one specific thing.
|
|
inherit
Champion of Kirkwall
1212
0
8,026
Sifr
3,737
Aug 25, 2016 20:05:11 GMT
August 2016
sifr
Mass Effect Trilogy, Dragon Age: Origins, Dragon Age 2, Dragon Age Inquistion, KOTOR, Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter Nights, Jade Empire
|
Post by Sifr on Dec 23, 2016 1:49:34 GMT
My general rule for gender pronouns is to refer to the person by whatever they physically are. If they wish to correct me they may do so and I'll attempt to use the proper variant of he/she. Beyond that I don't get into the other ones because we are a binary gendered species, and using a different term for "born male but identifies as female"(I think this is a thing, I don't really keep up with it) seems like an inefficient and non-intuitive use of the English language that just hinders communication when using she would have worked just as well. I don't really view gender identity in the same way most people do but if asked I'll tell them to just use male pronouns because that's what I physically am. Agreed. I must admit to finding attempts to create terms such as "Xir, Xem and Xe" to be extremely counter-intuitive and redundant, given that most people (including trans individuals) tend to identify as solely one gender or the other, so male and female pronouns should work fine? Granted there are those who are gender-queer who don't really identify as either sex, which does complicate matters somewhat. But for convenience sake, surely it would be easier to use their physical sex (or the one they prefer and/or identify most with) as the de facto terminology in those instances, even if it's understood to not be entirely accurate? Otherwise, wouldn't "Their, Them or They" serve as sufficiently gender neutral terms in a crunch, especially since they have the benefit of already existing in the English language? It tends to be my go-to for game protagonists that have both genders playable. As an aside, does else find the terms "Cisgender" and "Neurotypical" to be a tad redundant? Trans or Autistic individuals often identify as such, so there does seem little point in labels that really only equate to "Everyone else", when that does ultimately constitute the majority of individuals. As someone with Aspergers, the notion of a term denoting non-Autistic people always seemed a bit batty to me, since it's pretty clear most people aren't as ridiculously quirky (or quirkily ridiculous) as I often tend to be?
|
|