The forums already had their poll, but here is one by ScreenRant.

I'm really surprised how high EDI and Zaeed are on the list.

He's a creepy psycho murderer who sees evil everywhere and every time you see him he's got a new fixation on some new, poor bastard, who just happened to come along after he was finished killing the last guy he was obsessed with.

Torturing his victims to death on Omega in pre planned organised assaults and ambushes and then lying to Shepards face about it.

"Me and my gang chased him over half Omega but he got away in the end." Garm

"It was a tough fight but I had to let him go." Garrus.

"Shepard I need help with this guy!" Garrus fighting Garm.

Theres an Eclipse merc at the bottom of Dantius towers who wants to know why HE got pushed out of a window and why Archangel gets to play with a Thanix cannon and Snipe people on the Citadel, Shepard.

A Batarian with burnt out eye sockets wants to know why Archangel is making out with a Quarian at the end of days and he gets to poke around hell blind with an omni-stick.

Garrus has killed more people than most husks have and doesn't belong on the team.


That got a little bit ranty didn't it?

*Resumes seat*

Third thread is the charm?

Someone is clearly a hater of MEA.  Still, finding Grunt in the top 10 and Miranda outside of it just seems odd.  It doesn't seem to fit with what I hear from people.

I'm reserving judgment until all DLC is out and the game is actually complete. A lot of these characters had room to grow in sequels. If memory serves me right Garrus spent the first game mostly in Yessir mode. Liara was mild, sweet with a high propensity for fainting.

I'm sorry. I should've looked harder.

Which makes me soooo damn happy. He's NOT Wrex. Exactly! 

When I saw him in trailers\ met him in the game, I was 100% positive, that it's going to be 'the carbon-copy Wrex 2.0'. It's good to see that the writers could actually change that and make Drack...Drack, you know? He's got a unique personality, and some great writing too.

Don't shoot me for the blasphemy, but in my book, he's probably even better than Wrex (stars know, I loved Wrex!)

Apologies. New guy. Didn't see anything else on this. I'll look deeper next time.

EDI was great in ME2. ME3 was an abomination.
Legion was great in ME2. ME3 was an abomination.
Ashley was fine in ME1. ME3 was an abomination.
Kaidan was meh in ME1. He was nuclear slag material in ME3.
Jacob was bleh in ME2. ME3 was abomibleh.
Wrex was great in ME1. Just as well he died there as by ME3 he'd be an abomination.
Jack was just an abomination.
Liara in ME1 was an abomination. ME2/3 was great.

Tali was great though.

Agreed.  I understand that we had more time with the OT characters, so it's unfair to rank ME:A's cast alongside them.  But Drack is consistently awesome, and I'd put him at least where Zaeed is.

I'm not sure if i completely agree with this...since these are all opinions, but a well written character doesn't need a few games to flesh out or get to know. A well written character will be noticed on the spot (again i know opinions). I came in on the series in ME2 and instantly loved Garrus, Mordin ,Miranda and Samarah, Kasumi, Legion....I also Loved EDI and Garrus in ME3. But i do agree with you about Drack...his banter was consistently great and it didn't take a few games to know he was a great character. The only character that falls to the bottom is Jacob for me and Jack was even good by the time you got to the end of the game in ME2 and she made significant progress in ME3

Andromeda's characters are just poorly or blandly written which for me at this point (and i haven't finished the game yet) Jaal and Drack are my favs and that really isn't saying much compared to how much i loved almost the majority of the characters in ME2 & 3 

LOL Miranda ranking higher than Javik and Kasumi, and boring-af Garrus ranking at no1.........just LOL. Retards will be retards.