Would you like to see a Paragon/Renegade system added to MEA?

He wasn't a prisoner, it was a field interrogation.

I'm not clear what distinction you're drawing there. You're not allowed to simply murder people during field interrogations either.

Edit : just to avoid a potential derail, I'm not saying there's much wrong with that scene. I'm in favor of the PC being able to murder people, as long as the game can assign the appropriate consequences, if any, to that action.

I have a hard time believing most of us want a full reversion to the OT P/R system, I know I don't, but as the dialog stands at the moment, it is basically different flavors of Paragon. When Addison talks smack to Ryder, about their father, I think a natural response could easily be to tell her to go to hell, or something similar, but you never get an option like that. Not in that conversation, and not in any conversation as far as I have been able to tell.

Renegade has almost always been more 'gut' feeling, hold nothing back, tell it like it is, break the rules/social norms, etc., at least to me. If we had more interrupts that accomplished some more Renegade-type things, I think I'd be happy.

Pushing Peebee off isn't Paragon or Renegade, neither are most interrupts that I can think of, except for shooting the one Kett after making a deal with them. In fact most interrupts are more akin to Paragon, which the game seems too filled with. It has a lack of emotion, passion specifically, and it's that reason why I would either like the Paragon/Renegade system to come back in some way (again, not fully), or have dialog choices that have passion, that aren't always nice.

Fair enough. I took it more as a version of the system, not a full return to it, PaRen Light if you will; Either with the dialog choices/tone or the style of interrupts.

While some of the shocker moments from the MET still make me laugh, we don't need that system back. This is one of my faves from ME1 after choosing to let the council die.

Shepard: I saw an opportunity to get rid of them, so I took it.
Anderson: My god Shepard, how could you even say that?!

Ok. The problem with R/P is that they put points and condoned certain actions like it was black and white even though most decisions should be grey.

Yes, it should be wide open and with consequences to choices/decisions made. You know, somewhat like real life. It's not all vanilla and safe spaces. Not to pick on the writers again, but seems like the decision to remove Paragon/Renegade was based on laziness.